Fear and Loathing across Party Lines: New Evidence on Group Polarization
2014/12/16 by Shanto Iyengar, Sean J. Westwood, Sean Westwood · 127 citations
Social Sciences · #Social and Intergroup Psychology #Electoral Systems and Political Participation #Social and Cultural Dynamics
paper · doi:10.1111/ajps.12152
Abstract
When defined in terms of social identity and affect toward copartisans and opposing partisans, the polarization of the American electorate has dramatically increased. We document the scope and consequences of affective polarization of partisans using implicit, explicit, and behavioral indicators. Our evidence demonstrates that hostile feelings for the opposing party are ingrained or automatic in voters' minds, and that affective polarization based on party is just as strong as polarization based on race. We further show that party cues exert powerful effects on nonpolitical judgments and behaviors. Partisans discriminate against opposing partisans, doing so to a degree that exceeds discrimination based on race. We note that the willingness of partisans to display open animus for opposing partisans can be attributed to the absence of norms governing the expression of negative sentiment and that increased partisan affect provides an incentive for elites to engage in confrontation rather than cooperation.
Citations
Cited by
- The Economic Consequences of Partisanship in a Polarized Era
- The Nature of Affective Polarization: Disentangling Policy Disagreement from Partisan Identity
- When Common Identities Decrease Trust: An Experimental Study of Partisan Women
- How to Improve Attitudes Toward Disliked Groups
- Social divides in the age of globalization
- The (alleged) consequences of affective polarization: A survey experiment in nine democracies
- Polarization by Design: How Elites Could Shape Mass Preferences as AI Reduces Persuasion Costs
- Untangling altruism and parochialism in human intergroup conflict
- Communicating a common front: mainstream party rhetoric and affective polarisation towards the radical right
- A New Measure of Affective Polarization
- The limits of Brexit prejudice
- ‘Seen one, seen ‘em all’: political outgroup homogeneity and negative affect
- Perspective Getting and Cross-Party Support for Electoral Fairness
- Heroes and villains: motivated projection of political identities
- Cleavage politics, polarisation and participation in Western Europe
- Affective polarization within parties
- The role of partisan news and political parasocial relationships in shaping meta‐perceptions: Cross‐national evidence
- The affective nature of affective polarization: Evidence from physiological and self‐reported responses to US politicians
- American social media users have ideological differences of opinion about the War in Ukraine
- A critique of the polarisation narrative: expanding the limits of democracy, parties and political participation
- Misinformation, Narratives, and Intergroup Attitudes: Evidence from India
- Truthfulness, pluralism and the ethics of democratic representation
- Party Identity and the Evaluation of Political Candidates
- Affective polarization is uniformly distributed across American States
- The i-frame and the s-frame: How focusing on individual-level solutions has led behavioral public policy astray
- What Is It Like To Be a Partisan? Measures of Partisanship and Its Value for Democracy
- Affective Polarization in Multiparty Systems? Comparing Affective Polarization Towards Voters and Parties in Norway and the United States
- Us-vs-Them bias in Large Language Models
- Affective Polarization: Over Time, Through the Generations, and During the Lifespan
- Interacting as equals reduces partisan polarization in Mexico
- Entrepreneurs of conflict: A descriptive analysis of when and how political elites use divisive rhetoric
- Party Animals? Extreme Partisan Polarization and Dehumanization
- Negative and Positive Partisanship in the 2016 U.S. Presidential Elections
- Partisan Dehumanization in American Politics
- Is Sexism for White People? Gender Stereotypes, Race, and the 2016 Presidential Election
- The Contingent Effects of Candidate Sex on Voter Choice
- Political Considerations in Nonpolitical Decisions: A Conjoint Analysis of Roommate Choice
- Grand Old (Tailgate) Party? Partisan Discrimination in Apolitical Settings
- Need for Chaos and Dehumanization are Robustly Associated with Support for Partisan Violence, While Political Measures are Not
- The Differential Effects of Actual and Perceived Polarization
- Partisanship, Deservingness, and the Attitudinal Policy Feedback Process for Social Policy
- Political polarization and health
- Does Media Coverage of Partisan Polarization Affect Political Attitudes?
- Cross-partisan discussions reduced political polarization between UK voters, but less so when they disagreed
- When polarization meets backsliding: Affective polarization and support for undemocratic practices in Turkey
- Political Self-Confidence and Affective Polarization
- Political diversity in U.S. police agencies
- How the Engagement of High-Profile Partisan Officials Affects Education Politics, Public Opinion, and Polarization
- What Do We Measure When We Measure Affective Polarization?
- Affective polarization and habits of political participation
- Partisan Homogeneity Does Not Increase Collaborative Corruption
- Is Partisanship Dysfunctional for Representative Institutions?
- Supremely Polarizing
- Megastudy testing 25 treatments to reduce antidemocratic attitudes and partisan animosity
- A New Measure of Affective Polarization
- Beliefs about Climate Beliefs: The Importance of Second-Order Opinions for Climate Politics
- Are politically diverse Thanksgiving dinners shorter than politically uniform ones?
- Opting Out of Political Discussions
- How the Politicization of Everyday Activities Affects the Public Sphere: The Effects of Partisan Stereotypes on Cross-Cutting Interactions
- The Rationality of Affective Polarization
- Using Message Strategies to Attenuate the Effects of Disinformation on Credibility
- Reducing Affective Polarization: Warm Group Relations or Policy Compromise?
- Partisanship and the Social Construction of Deservingness in the United States
- Contingent Confidence: The Effect of the 2024 Election Outcome on Public and Elite Confidence in National Elections
- What’s in a Font?: Ideological Perceptions of Typography
- You’re Making Us Look Bad: Can Partisan Embarrassment Dampen Partisanship and Polarization?
- Affective polarisation and the sorting of policy preferences in multiparty systems
- Why more social interactions lead to more polarization in societies
- A Waste of Time? Partisan Deliberative Bias as a Barrier to Political Crosstalk
- The Strengthening of Partisan Affect
- Determinants of Affective Polarization in Mexico's 2018 Presidential Election
- Who thinks the media is hostile?! An examination of individual differences predicting the hostile media effect concerning news media coverage of individuals with a migratory background in Germany
- Data-Driven Modeling of U.S. Ideological Dynamics
- Registered report: Cognitive ability, but not cognitive reflection, predicts expressing greater political animosity and favouritism
- Polarizing Political Polls: How Visualization Design Choices Can Shape Public Opinion and Increase Political Polarization
- Do Stock Market Return and Volatility Respond to U.S. Partisan Conflict Uncertainty?
- Conflict on the campaign trail? How campaign effort and electoral competitiveness shape affective polarization
- Can Interparty Contact Reduce Affective Polarization? A Systematic Test of Different Forms of Intergroup Contact
- Voting red again: how social capital and local change drove the Trump swing
- The “Clinching Effect” and Affective Polarization: Exposure to Incivility via Social Media in the Presence of Online News
- The Kids Are Online: Teen Social Media Use, Civic Engagement, and Affective Polarization
- Exposure to opposing views on social media can increase political polarization
- Do Justices Defend the Speech They Hate?
- When Do Broken Campaign Promises Matter? Evidence From Four Experiments
- Democratic transition and party polarization: A fuzzy regression discontinuity design approach
- Seeing Red (And Blue): Partisan Identity, Emotions, and Selective Exposure
- Mainstream partisans’ affective response to (non) cooperation with populist radical right parties
- Seeing Divides: Citizens’ Biased Perceptions of Political Cleavages
- ‘The enemy within’: Campaign attention and motivated reasoning in voter perceptions of intra-party conflict
- Executives Strike Back: Political Benefits of Sanctioning the U.S. Supreme Court
- Network Issue Agenda Setting on Facebook: Exploring the Interplay Between Polarized Campaigns and Party Supporters
- Partisan Consumerism: Experimental Tests of Consumer Reactions to Corporate Political Activity
- Co-evolution of groups and opinions in an agent-based model
- Sorting It Out in the American States: Party Ideology and Mass Alignment
- Group Prototypicality and Boundary Definition: Comparing White and Black Perceptions of Whether Latinos Are American
- New threat of culture wars? The religious roots of public opinion polarization on morality issues in Europe
- The Implicit Association Test: A Method in Search of a Construct
- Swaying the Public? Impacts of Election Forecast Visualizations on Emotion, Trust, and Intention in the 2022 U.S. Midterms
- Social Desirability and Affective Polarization
- The Origins and Consequences of Affective Polarization in the United States
- Perspective-Taking and Partisan Depolarization in the U.S. and Turkey
- Political segregation in the US workplace
- Effect of Media Environment Diversity and Advertising Tone on Information Search, Selective Exposure, and Affective Polarization
- Partisanship as a Social Identity: Implications for Polarization
- What explains elite affective polarization? Evidence from Canadian politicians
- How candidates evoke identity and issues on TikTok
- Embedding Democratic Values into Social Media AIs via Societal Objective Functions
- Counteracting Narratives: Evidence from An Online Experiment
- L’heure du conte drag au Québec
- Partisan Differences in Support for Political Violence: Results from a Natural Experiment in the United States
- Descriptive or Partisan Representation? Examining Trade-Offs for Asian Americans
- The Elephant and Donkey in the Room: Time-Varying Effects of Political Dissimilarity on Social Interactions at Work During U.S. Elections
- Compliance with Public Health Orders: The Role of Trust, Representation, and Expertise
- Why Do Deliberative Discussions Reduce Affective Polarization? Evidence from a Deliberation Experiment in Honduras
- Choosing between Alternative Concepts in a Worrisome World: Concern as a Criterion
- Personal experiences bridge moral and political divides better than facts
- Affective Polarization in Political and Nonpolitical Settings
- Fallibility Salience Increases Intellectual Humility: Implications for People’s Willingness to Investigate Political Misinformation
- Exploring voter turnout dynamics in polarized elections: A group-rule utilitarian framework
- Technopopulism
- How Ideology Fuels Affective Polarization
- The geography of partisan homophily in the 2020 US presidential election
- Gendered Divides in Online Discussions about Reproductive Rights
- Multi-polarization during the 9th European Parliament
- Xenophobic and Islamophobic Rhetoric among Evangelical Opinion Leaders in the Age of Trump
- Polarization versus professionalism: military and civilian views on the domestic use of the military
- When Networks Mislead: How Partisan Communication Undermines Democratic Decision-Making
Related