A Century of Grading Research

2016/10/04 by Susan M. Brookhart, Thomas R. Guskey, Alex J. Bowers +5 · 22 citations
Social Sciences · #Student Assessment and Feedback #Evaluation of Teaching Practices #Innovative Teaching Methods

paper · doi:10.3102/0034654316672069

Abstract

Grading refers to the symbols assigned to individual pieces of student work or to composite measures of student performance on report cards. This review of over 100 years of research on grading considers five types of studies: (a) early studies of the reliability of grades, (b) quantitative studies of the composition of K–12 report card grades, (c) survey and interview studies of teachers’ perceptions of grades, (d) studies of standards-based grading, and (e) grading in higher education. Early 20th-century studies generally condemned teachers’ grades as unreliable. More recent studies of the relationships of grades to tested achievement and survey studies of teachers’ grading practices and beliefs suggest that grades assess a multidimensional construct containing both cognitive and noncognitive factors reflecting what teachers value in student work. Implications for future research and for grading practices are discussed.

Cited by

• The stability of students’ academic achievement in school: A meta-analysis of longitudinal studies
• The Norwegian legacy of resisting formal grading
• How do mathematics teachers grade tests? Different scoring and content priorities in micro-decisions, yet similar final grades
• Going ‘grade-free’? – Teachers’ and students’ perceived value and grading preferences for holistic competency assessment
• Silver Lining or Missed Opportunity? A Mixed Methods Study of COVID-19 School Closures and Grading Reform Efforts in K-12 Schools
• Hierarchical Linear Modeling Approach to Measuring the Effects of Class Size and Other Classroom Characteristics on Student Learning in an Active-Learning Based Introductory Physics Course
• Examining grading purpose and practices: A multivariate analysis of secondary stakeholder perceptions
• Variability in the Grades Teachers Give: Teacher Grade Value-Add, Mismatch, and Long-Term Effects
• Preservice teachers' assessment decisions: Exploring the role of fairness conceptions
• Crisis-driven digitalization and academic success across disciplines
• Unraveling the Relationship Between Teacher-Assigned Grades, Student Personality, and Standardized Test Scores. [europepmc]
• Fluid Intelligence and Competence Development in Secondary Schooling: No Evidence for a Moderating Role of Conscientiousness. [europepmc]
• The agonizing effects of uncertainty: Effects of announced vs. unannounced performance assessments on emotions and achievement. [europepmc]
• Learning effectiveness of a flexible learning study programme in a blended learning design: why are some courses more effective than others? [europepmc]
• Crisis-driven digitalization and academic success across disciplines. [europepmc]
• Teacher-assigned grades and external exams: sources of discrepancy. [europepmc]
• The Ungrading Learning Theory We Have Is Not the Ungrading Learning Theory We Need. [europepmc]
• Novick Meets Bayes: Improving the Assessment of Individual Students in Educational Practice and Research by Capitalizing on Assessors' Prior Beliefs. [europepmc]
• Socioeconomic and racial/ethnic disparities in sleep and cognitive and academic functioning across childhood and adolescence: a meta-analytic review. [europepmc]
• Challenges in student assessment in medical and health sciences education in Northern Iraq. [europepmc]
• Student Socioeconomic Status and Teacher-Student Perceptual Discrepancies of School Effort and Enjoyment. [europepmc]
• How Perspective Directs Outcomes: The Structure and Function of Deficit and Anti-deficit Framing and Their Relevance to Chemistry Education. [europepmc]

Related

• What do children think about grading?
• Teaching More by Grading Less (or Differently)
• Scaling Success: A Systematic Review of Peer Grading Strategies for Accuracy, Efficiency, and Learning in Contemporary Education
• How do mathematics teachers grade tests? Different scoring and content priorities in micro-decisions, yet similar final grades
• A Regression Approach to Fairer Grading