Fixed and random effects models: making an informed choice
2018/08/06 by Andrew Bell, Malcolm Fairbrother, Kelvyn Jones · 74 citations
Mathematics · Social Sciences · #Advanced Causal Inference Techniques #Health disparities and outcomes #Urban, Neighborhood, and Segregation Studies
paper · pdf · doi:10.1007/s11135-018-0802-x
Abstract
This paper assesses the options available to researchers analysing multilevel (including longitudinal) data, with the aim of supporting good methodological decision-making. Given the confusion in the literature about the key properties of fixed and random effects (FE and RE) models, we present these models’ capabilities and limitations. We also discuss the within-between RE model, sometimes misleadingly labelled a ‘hybrid’ model, showing that it is the most general of the three, with all the strengths of the other two. As such, and because it allows for important extensions—notably random slopes—we argue it should be used (as a starting point at least) in all multilevel analyses. We develop the argument through simulations, evaluating how these models cope with some likely mis-specifications. These simulations reveal that (1) failing to include random slopes can generate anti-conservative standard errors, and (2) assuming random intercepts are Normally distributed, when they are not, introduces only modest biases. These results strengthen the case for the use of, and need for, these models.
Citations
Cited by
- Role-Accumulation and Mental Health across the Life Course
- Pesticides and habitat loss additively reduce wild bees in crop fields
- Track Differences in Civic and Democratic Engagement During Secondary Education: A New Panel Study From the Netherlands
- Whose (future) democracy? Examining Inequalities in the Development of Adolescents’ Political Efficacy and the Mediating Role of Political Socialization
- The link between changing news use and trust: longitudinal analysis of 46 countries
- News participation is declining: Evidence from 46 countries between 2015 and 2022
- Rising inequality: is the public response really lacking? A comparative longitudinal analysis of perceived inequality and evaluative attitudes
- Momentary motivations for digital disconnection: an experience sampling study
- What do people watch under adversity? Testing interactions of semantic affinity and coping style using Netflix data donations
- Does political polarisation undermine democratic accountability? Evidence from 28 European democracies
- Causal Inference With Observational Data and Unobserved Confounding Variables
- How Education Policies Shape Political Inequality: Analyzing Policy Feedback Effects in Germany
- Equally performing, unfairly evaluated
- Revealing the interplay between digital media use and affective well-being across developmental stages: Results of an experience sampling study with Austrian adolescents
- Escaping the digital panopticon? Longitudinal effects of dataveillance salience shocks on privacy attitudes and inhibited behaviors
- What Reproductive Justice Brings to and Requires of The Feminist Economics Project
- Robustness assessment of regressions using cluster analysis typologies: a bootstrap procedure with application in state sequence analysis
- Social networks and distributive conflict: the class divide in social ties and attitudes to income inequality across 29 countries
- Regional banks and economic resilience: the impact of the global financial crisis and COVID-19 on countries with decentralised and centralised banking systems
- Interventions to reduce adult state anxiety, dental trait anxiety, and dental phobia: A systematic review and meta-analyses of randomized controlled trials
- ‘In the company of cheerful ladies’: whether female entrepreneurs are more productive?
- Government Transparency and Innovation: Evidence from Wireless Products
- Does educational attainment matter for attitudes toward immigrants in Chile? Assessing the causality and generalizability of higher education's so‐called “liberalizing effect” on economic and cultural threat
- Financial accumulation in non-financial corporations: a firm-level assessment for the OECD
- Trust, social movements, and the state
- Revisiting sources of variability in gait analysis
- Government Religious Discrimination, Support of Religion, and Muslim Minority-Related Societal Violence in Western Democracies
- Dominance of leading business schools in top journals: Insights for increasing institutional representation
- Careless whisper: Political elite discourses activate national identities for far‐right voting preferences
- Investing in the knowledge economy: The comparative political economy of public investments in knowledge‐based capital
- Investigating relationships among perceptions of yielding, safety, and comfort for pedestrians in unsignalized crosswalks
- Disrupting democracy: how informational pathways and misinformation shape trust in election results
- Clinic and care: associations with adolescent antiretroviral therapy adherence in a prospective cohort in South Africa
- Beyond the Breakfast Club: Variability in the Effects of Suspensions by School Context
- When do cities propose taxes? Evidence from California municipalities, 1996–2010
- Women's international football success and women's economic freedom
- Estimating causal effects from panel data with dynamic multivariate panel models
- Psychological pricing in online food retail
- Climate hazard experience linked to increased climate risk perception worldwide
- Cognitive-Behavioral Therapy and Support Services for People With Serious Mental Illness Who Were Experiencing Homelessness
- Are Alberta’s Northern Pike Populations at Risk from Walleye Recovery?
- Perceived discrimination in the workplace and mental health from early adulthood to midlife
- Estimating Heterogeneous Treatment Effects with Item-Level Outcome Data: Insights from Item Response Theory
- Coping with Emotional Distress via Self-Disclosure to Robots: An Intervention with Caregivers
- Building prediction models with grouped data: A case study on the prediction of turnover intention
- Consistency of common spatial estimators under spatial confounding
- Social Participation Through the Retirement Transition: Differences by Gender and Employment Status
- Sheltered From Eviction? A Framework for Understanding the Relationship Between Subsidized Housing Programs and Eviction
- Nationalism, Class, and Status: How Nationalists Use Policy Offers and Group Appeals to Attract a New Electorate
- Comparison of the Quality of Hospitals That Admit Medicare Advantage Patients vs Traditional Medicare Patients. [europepmc]
- Association between tax on sugar sweetened beverages and soft drink consumption in adults in Mexico: open cohort longitudinal analysis of Health Workers Cohort Study. [europepmc]
- Relationships with caregivers and mental health outcomes among adolescents living with HIV: a prospective cohort study in South Africa. [europepmc]
- Using multilevel models for the analysis of event-related potentials. [europepmc]
- Small area variation in child undernutrition across 640 districts and 543 parliamentary constituencies in India. [europepmc]
- Are adversities and worries during the COVID-19 pandemic related to sleep quality? Longitudinal analyses of 46,000 UK adults. [europepmc]
- Associations of changes in neighbourhood walkability with changes in walking activity in older adults: a fixed effects analysis. [europepmc]
- A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of the Potential of Millets for Managing and Reducing the Risk of Developing Diabetes Mellitus. [europepmc]
- Can Millet Consumption Help Manage Hyperlipidemia and Obesity?: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. [europepmc]
- Effect of Distraction Intervention for Needle-Related Pain and Distress in Children: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. [europepmc]
- Millets Can Have a Major Impact on Improving Iron Status, Hemoglobin Level, and in Reducing Iron Deficiency Anemia-A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. [europepmc]
- Pilot randomized trial of self-guided virtual reality exposure therapy for social anxiety disorder. [europepmc]
- National Narcissism predicts the Belief in and the Dissemination of Conspiracy Theories During the COVID-19 Pandemic: Evidence From 56 Countries. [europepmc]
- Should I use fixed effects or random effects when I have fewer than five levels of a grouping factor in a mixed-effects model? [europepmc]
- Health insurance coverage and timely antenatal care attendance in sub-Saharan Africa. [europepmc]
- The longitudinal effect of COVID-19 infections and lockdown on mental health and the protective effect of neighbourhood social relations. [europepmc]
- Variation in Use of Surgical Care During the COVID-19 Pandemic by Surgical Urgency and Race and Ethnicity. [europepmc]
- The association of physical activity, sleep, and screen time with mental health in Canadian adolescents during the COVID-19 pandemic: A longitudinal isotemporal substitution analysis. [europepmc]
- LLIN Evaluation in Uganda Project (LLINEUP2)-Factors associated with coverage and use of long‑lasting insecticidal nets following the 2020-21 national mass distribution campaign: a cross-sectional survey of 12 districts. [europepmc]
- The social determinants of national tuberculosis incidence rates in 116 countries: a longitudinal ecological study between 2005-2015. [europepmc]
- Understanding the relationship between income and mental health among 16- to 24-year-olds: Analysis of 10 waves (2009-2020) of Understanding Society to enable modelling of income interventions. [europepmc]
- Neural α Oscillations and Pupil Size Differentially Index Cognitive Demand under Competing Audiovisual Task Conditions. [europepmc]
- Daily social media use, social ties, and emotional well-being in later life. [europepmc]
- Efficacy and safety of therapeutic HPV vaccines to treat CIN 2/CIN 3 lesions: a systematic review and meta-analysis of phase II/III clinical trials. [europepmc]
- Mycobacterium tuberculosis cough aerosol culture status associates with host characteristics and inflammatory profiles. [europepmc]
Related