The revenge of the places that don’t matter (and what to do about it)
2017/12/29 by Andrés Rodríguez‐Pose · 1 voice · 186 citations
Economics, Econometrics and Finance · Social Sciences · #Regional Economics and Spatial Analysis #Urbanization and City Planning #Regional Development and Policy
paper · pdf · doi:10.1093/cjres/rsx024
Abstract
Persistent poverty, economic decay and lack of opportunities are at the root of considerable discontent in declining and lagging-behind areas the world over. Poor development prospects and an increasing belief that these places have “no future”—as economic dynamism has been posited to be increasingly dependent on agglomeration economies—have led many of these so-called “places that don’t matter” to revolt against the status quo. The revolt has come via an unexpected source: the ballot-box, in a wave of political populism with strong territorial, rather than social foundations. I will argue that the populist wave is challenging the sources of existing well-being in both the less-dynamic and the more prosperous areas and that better, rather than more, place-sensitive territorial development policies are needed in order to find a solution to the problem. Place-sensitive development policies need, however, to stay clear of the welfare, income support and big investment projects of past development strategies if they are to be successful and focus on tapping into untapped potential and on providing opportunities to those people living in the places that “don’t matter”.
Citations
Cited by
- Rural Decline and Spatial Voting Patterns
- Beyond anti-urban sentiment: Rural consciousness and affect toward undocumented immigrants
- The imperial treasury: appraisal methodology and regional economic performance in the UK
- The Geography of EU Discontent and the Regional Development Trap
- Is the European Social Progress Index robust? Implications for the design of European Union regional Cohesion Policy
- Left-behind versus unequal places: interpersonal inequality, economic decline and the rise of populism in the USA and Europe
- Geography of Shrinkage: Local Population Decline and Electoral Support for the Anti-establishment Parties AfD and BSW in East German State Elections
- The Changing Shape of Spatial Income Disparities in the United States
- Rethinking Path Creation: A Geographical Political Economy Approach
- Multiple Scales of Income Inequality: A Longitudinal Analysis of Swedish Regions
- The Regional Development Trap in Europe
- Without Roots: The Political Consequences of Collective Economic Shocks
- The effects of marginalisation in areas of high political centralisation
- For growth or equity: a taxonomy of ‘Bidenomics’ place-based policies and implications for US regional inequality
- Accessibility, Car Dependence and Rural Peripheralization: The Automobility Gap in the Spanish Countryside
- Global Development, Converging Divergence and Development Studies: A Rejoinder
- Searching for “The New Oil”: Preemptive Hope and Post‐Petroleum Futures in Norway's Oil Capital
- Regional diversification and intra-regional wage inequality in the Netherlands
- What makes ethnic majorities support the radical right? A combination of relative deprivation and social dominance approaches
- Between Socioeconomic Decline and Lack of Political Competition: What Explains the Success of the AfD in North Rhine-Westphalia’s 2025 Integration Council Elections?
- Between home turf and Hinterland: Directly elected MPs focus more on local and deprived places than list candidates on social media
- Unequal Political Representation of Core and Periphery: How Regions That Don’t Matter Vote for Parties That Don’t Bother
- Irish regional GDP since independence
- Updating cleavage theory for the twenty-first century
- Who Is Left Behind? Economic Status Loss and Populist Radical Right Voting
- Shaping opportunity spaces: the role of narratives in place leadership
- Do they feel like they don’t matter? The rural-urban divide in external political efficacy
- Transatlantic lessons from Bidenomics place-based policies: opportunities and limits for addressing regional inequality
- Beyond Thriving Cities and Declining Rural Areas: Mapping Geographic Divides in Germany’s Employment Structure, 1993–2019
- A map of discontent: economic distress or public service deprivation?
- The long shadow of local decline: Birthplace economic adversity and long-term individual outcomes in the UK
- How Local Context Affects Populist Radical Right Support: A Cross-National Investigation Into Mediated and Moderated Relationships
- From nations to regions: electoral volatility in European multi-level politics
- Left behind in a public services wasteland? On the accessibility of public services and political trust
- The Populist Backlash Against Globalization: A Meta-Analysis of the Causal Evidence
- Why Some Want Something for Nothing: Three Explanations for Unfunded Spending Demand
- The four waves of regional policy: towards an era of trade-offs?
- Confidence Across Cleavage: The Swiss Rural–Urban Divide, Place‐Based Identity and Political Trust
- Discontent in ‘left-behind places’? How perception of space and local political climate matter for the success of right-wing populism in rural areas of Germany
- Places that matter and places that don’t: territorial revenge and counter-revenge in Poland
- Golfing with Trump. Social capital, decline, inequality, and the rise of populism in the US
- Political legitimacy after the pits: Corruption narratives and labour power in a former coalmining town in England
- Exploring the Economic Geographies of Sustainability Transitions: Commentary and Agenda
- Episodes in Dutch Policy to Develop ‘Left Behind Places’ (1945–2025)
- The green transition and its potential territorial discontents
- The intersection of productivity and governance capacity in spatial inequality: the case of England’s devolution periphery
- Local decline and populism
- The heroes and killjoys of green megaprojects: a feminist critique
- Forging a sustainable future together: Cohesion Policy at its defining moment
- Geographies of feeling stuck behind and populist voting in The Netherlands
- Angry together or agitated alone? The role of social capital in the geographies of discontent
- Overcoming left-behindedness. Moving beyond the efficiency versus equity debate in territorial development
- Patterns of opportunity spaces and agency across regional contexts: Conditions and drivers for change
- The challenge of devolved English governance and the rise of political spatial inequality
- Ethnic diversity, deprivation, and populist radical right voting: A rural-urban perspective on AfD support in Germany
- Place matters for the poor: Digitisation and spatial inequality in Chile
- Urban sustainability: a spatial justice critique
- Emerging issues and new frontiers in federalism, regionalism and territorial governance: the role of Regional & Federal Studies in shaping future research agendas
- Place, education, and voting along the transnational cleavage in Europe
- Exploring the deep roots of interregional inequality: spatial income distribution in the European regions
- Why size really doesn’t matter: from megacity myths to place-sensitive prosperity
- Geography, the foundational economy, and the fallen-below
- Downhill from here? Why shrinking regions are not necessarily ‘left-behind’
- Government bias, territorial divides and constitutional preferences in Scotland and Wales
- Unlocking firm innovation under regional disadvantage: Can psychological openness compensate?
- Leveraging Entrepreneurship Education in Italy’s Inner Areas: Implications for Regional Planning
- Cultivating trust? The role of European Union investments in bridging rural-urban divides
- Radical right support and the deepened rural-urban and educational divides among younger generations
- The impact of Brexit on SME lending in the UK
- Community culture and development challenges in left behind places: the impact of historical legacies in the South Wales Valleys
- Behavioural theory and regional development: nurturing cultures of possibility
- Global forces and local impacts: megatrends in regional development
- Unfunded Mandates and the Economic Impact of Decentralisation. When Finance Does Not Follow Function
- Addressing inclusion, innovation, and sustainability challenges through the lens of economic geography: Introducing the hierarchical regional innovation system
- The polarisation of Italian metropolitan areas, 2000–2018: structural change, technology and growth
- Coastal towns as ‘left-behind places’: economy, environment and planning
- Out of Sight? Revealing Creativity-Led Innovation in Rural Regions
- The geography of exclusion: cumulative causation and the persistence of lagging regions
- There is more to national economies than the national economy: extending the Growth Model research programme in comparative political economy
- How places are contesting the privatisation of local public services
- The subsidiarity trap: how EU constitutional architecture perpetuates regional decline
- How generational replacement feeds the urban-rural divide: Evidence from Switzerland (1995–2023)
- Challenging narratives of homogeneity: Using PCA and Cluster Analysis to develop a typology of key towns in Ireland
- Exchanging money for love? A regional analysis of EU cohesion policy and Euroscepticism
- Effects and responses of peripheral regions to financialization: Exploring an extension of the cluster approach
- Banking on trust: Institutional trust and the geography of financial exclusion in Central and Eastern Europe
- Geographies of anti-political establishment parties in the Netherlands: The role of broader welfare and local representation
- Rural entrepreneurship: foundations and future directions during a time of transformation
- The multidimensional phenomenon of left behindness: a local approach
- Modelling regional exposure to new trade wars
- Urban–ruraljustice
- Places that don't matter or people that don't matter? A multilevel modelling approach to the analysis of the geographies of discontent
- Democratic resilience and re-democratisation
- Growth and decline in rural Spain: an exploratory analysis
- Lithuanian rural settlements: The legacy of Soviet rural planning and current challenges
- Explaining Attitudes Towards Climate Action in Germany: AfD vs. the Greens, the East vs. the West, Wind vs. Solar Energy
- Taking ‘fallen-below’ seriously: Spacing, placing, and scaling foundational liveability
- The making and unmaking of uneven development: the role of anchor firms in creating and overcoming industrial decline in East Germany
- Skill relatedness: A dynamic approach to regional diversification in the UK
- Quality of government cohesion across EU regions: success or failure?
- Left behind and out of the loop: Examining the spatial distribution of news outlet closures in Canada
- The abandoned, the depressed, and the sacrificed: stretching the terms of the economic geographical debate on left-behind places
- Addressing interregional inequality with Chinese characteristics? The Mountain–Sea Collaboration model in Zhejiang
- Competing over the ‘left behind’: the effect of independent local lists on the electoral performance of populist parties
- The importance of trade and technology for productivity: An empirical assessment across EU regions
- Mapping rural-urban differences in state expenditures with geospatial methods – explorative spatial data analysis from Finland
- Liberté, Égalité, Fraternité? The role of spatial inequalities in understanding the determinants of the populist vote in the 2022 French presidential election
- The evolution of Cohesion Policy in 40 years of economic policy agenda
- A tale of no cities? The neglect of cities in South Africa’s post-apartheid national economic policies
- Rural development as the propagation of regional ‘communities of values’: A case study of local discourses promoting social innovation and social sustainability
- Urban transport system changes in the UK: In danger of populism?
- The variegated hinterlands of the digital growth machine
- Will territorial cohesion survive after 2028? Assessing the implications of the reform of Cohesion Policy for future structural funds
- Universities, polycrisis and regional redistribution
- Twin Transition Attitudes and Regional Left‐Behindness: Unpacking the Drivers of Interregional Migration Intentions
- Does private education pay off?
- Transformative innovation policy and collaborative governance in regions and cities
- Voting red again: how social capital and local change drove the Trump swing
- A Union under siege, or a Union besieging itself? The EU's new budget and the future of European integration
- Revisiting the growth–inequality nexus in Italian regions: inter-regional inequality and regional traps
- Revitalizing marginal areas: A foundational economy approach
- Green with anger: polarised environmental mobilisation and the knowledge economy
- The economics of negative population growth: global to local perspectives
- Prohibited Plants: Converging Sustainability Transitions and Local Development in ‘Left‐Behind Places’
- Territorial Agenda 2030, spatial justice, and the social investment turn: a capabilities approach perspective
- Rethinking evolutionary economic geography through a gender lens
- ‘Left Behind Places’: Examining the Evolution of a Concept With an Application to the Canadian Regional Development Context
- Change Agency and the Capability Approach: Regional Development and Well-Being on the Edge
- Income support and voting with territorial disparities
- One Kazakhstan, multiple nations: on a growing regional divide amidst economic dynamism
- A postcode lottery in education? Explaining regional inequality in multilevel systems
- Is energy geography running out of steam?
- Industrial policy, multilevel governance and regional development: the case of the UK semiconductor industry
- Governing Differences
- Beyond growth paralysis
- The Backlash Against Globalization
- Income inequality in Italian regions: an empirical study on the mitigating role of organisation-based volunteering
- Heterogeneous labour market trajectories in the EU: convergence, divergence and stagnation across regions
- From strugglers to superstars: assessing the roles of European regions in knowledge flows
- Innovations in Agri-Food Systems in Europe: Pathways and Challenges to Inclusion and Sustainability
- The right kind of growth for everyone: policy challenges during the digital and green transformations
- Instability and inequality in the British state
- Communist Legacy, Anti-Elite Sentiments, and Modernization Theory
- Do European cities converge in life satisfaction?
- Stadt, Land, Weltverschwörung? Eine qualitative Inhaltsanalyse des Aufgewacht-Magazins der radikal rechten Kleinstpartei Freie Sachsen
- There is nothing here! Unequal access to services and rural resentment in Spain
- Pragmatic remunicipalisation across diverse geographies in the US
- Capital cities in multi-level settings: Assessing Scottish and Welsh residents’ perceptions of London, Edinburgh and Cardiff
- Mission-oriented innovation: from a new vocabulary to a new grammar for regional innovation policy
- Does regional context affect populist voting? A comparative multilevel analysis from Czechia and eastern Germany
- “Now I’m here”. Youth transitions, mobilities and uncertainties in rural peripheries
- Beyond path dependence: a methodological review for studying regional futures
- Zero-sum thinking in regional development? – Green and/or inclusive socio-economic development dynamics in challenged regions
- The geography of the green transition: Performance, vulnerabilities and opportunities
- The geography of discontent revisited: decoupling attitudinal clustering and affective intensification in urban Britain
- Strengthening Institutions for a Green and Digital Future: Regional Evidence from Europe's Twin Transition
- The Rise of Populism and the Revenge of the Places That Don’t Matter
- Entrepreneurship for the rural? A reflection on rural entrepreneurship in a time of multi-crisis
- Investment or Losers’ Compensation? The Mis-Selling and Re-Selling of EU Cohesion Policy
- Ballots, budgets and bricks: Brexit and the polarisation of individual economic behaviours
- Unpacking Endogeneity: Growth, Discontent and Cohesion Policy in the EU Regions
- Geography of discontent and beyond: Extreme voting, protestations, riots and violence, and their spatial content
- Underappreciated mid-sized cities: Policy opportunities and challenges
- What do we owe a place? How the debate about left-behind places is challenging how we distribute public funding and the problems it should address
- Does public R&D funding reinforce regional disparities? Exploring the changing geography of public and business R&D expenditure in Europe
- Unraveling the nexus: Subjective well-being and left-behind places
- The rural consolidation state: A critical examination of municipal consolidation strategies in Bavaria, Germany
- When the past becomes the future: The challenges of policies in ‘Left Behind’ places in East Germany – A case study from the Gera region
- Performing Authority in Times of Crisis: Six Frames of Contested Authority During the Pandemic Era in Finland
- The Normalization of the Radical Right
- The interplay of politics and space: How elected politicians shape place‐based policies and outcomes
- Constrained divergence in multi-level systems: the case of skill formation in the United Kingdom
- How Rural is Rural Populism? On the Spatial Understanding of Rurality for Analyses of Right‐wing Populist Election Success in Germany*
- Anxiety status: Foundational thinking about the ‘fallen below’
- Aineen ja tunteen kylät: Uusmaterialistisia tulkintoja Sivakasta ja Rasimäestä
- Divergence of economic opportunity in average places: Pathways to growth
- When place shapes attitudes: explaining rural discontent with climate policies
- Beyond GDP in an island region: constructing a capability-oriented well-being index for Corsica
- Black and green: How electoral outcomes influence provincial circular economy performance in Italy
- The migrant-native ‘equilibrium’ in Western European labour markets: a long-term analysis
- Technology Network Structure Conditions the Economic Resilience of Regions
- Township Economies as Left-Behind Places: Case of Chitungwiza, Zimbabwe
- Place-based rural development: building capacities, multi-actor collaborations and making sense of the local ‘place’
- Riga and Vilnius: the socio-spatial dimensions of rivalry between the largest Baltic cities
- Vicious circle of peripheries: Representation of sub‐municipal units in local election manifestos in amalgamated municipalities
- Revolutionary resistance against full autocratization. Actors and strategies of resistance after the 2021 military coup in Myanmar
Discussions
Related