Partisans without Constraint: Political Polarization and Trends in American Public Opinion
2008/09/01 by Delia Baldassarri, Andrew Gelman · 73 citations
Social Sciences · #Electoral Systems and Political Participation #Social Media and Politics #Social Capital and Networks
paper · doi:10.1086/590649
Abstract
Public opinion polarization is here conceived as a process of alignment along multiple lines of potential disagreement and measured as growing constraint in individuals' preferences. Using NES data from 1972 to 2004, the authors model trends in issue partisanship—the correlation of issue attitudes with party identification—and issue alignment—the correlation between pairs of issues—and find a substantive increase in issue partisanship, but little evidence of issue alignment. The findings suggest that opinion changes correspond more to a resorting of party labels among voters than to greater constraint on issue attitudes: since parties are more polarized, they are now better at sorting individuals along ideological lines. Levels of constraint vary across population subgroups: strong partisans and wealthier and politically sophisticated voters have grown more coherent in their beliefs. The authors discuss the consequences of partisan realignment and group sorting on the political process and potential deviations from the classic pluralistic account of American politics.
Cited by
- Emergent Meanings: Reconciling Dispositional and Situational Accounts of Meaning-Making from Cultural Objects
- The social media discourse of engaged partisans is toxic even when politics are irrelevant
- Value Shift: Immigration Attitudes and the Sociocultural Divide
- The Long-Term Dynamics of Partisanship and Issue Orientations
- Idiosyncratic Issue Opinion and Political Choice
- How digital media drive affective polarization through partisan sorting
- The Avoidance of Strong Ties
- The Politicization of Climate Change and Polarization in the American Public's Views of Global Warming, 2001–2010
- One more constrained than the other: Asymmetrical ideological alignment and its implications for polarization
- Why Are U.S. Parties So Polarized? A “Satisficing” Dynamical Model
- Rooted America: Immobility and Segregation of the Intercounty Migration Network
- Mass Polarization: Manifestations and Measurements
- Polarization Eh? Ideological Divergence and Partisan Sorting in the Canadian Mass Public
- A Longitudinal Study on the Dynamic Relationship Between Affective Polarization and Radical Right’s Emergence: The Case of VOX in Spain
- Politicultural Linking: Inferences Between Political and Apolitical Traits
- “I Disrespectfully Agree”: The Differential Effects of Partisan Sorting on Social and Issue Polarization
- It’s Not Polarization; It’s the Radicalization of the Political Right
- Polarization and the Global Crisis of Democracy: Common Patterns, Dynamics, and Pernicious Consequences for Democratic Polities
- The nature and structure of European belief systems: exploring the varieties of belief systems across 23 European countries
- Destructive polarization in digital communication contexts: a critical review and conceptual framework
- (Mis-)Perceptions, information, and political polarization: A survey and a systematic literature review
- Long-run trends in partisan polarization of climate policy-relevant attitudes across countries
- The Polarization of Contemporary American Politics
- What Explains Country-Level Differences in Political Belief System Coherence?
- Political polarization and health
- Thinking Ideologically: The Limited Role of Left and Right Labels as Policy Shortcuts
- Network polarization: The study of political attitudes and social ties as dynamic multilevel networks
- The Preparedness Paradox in Climate Attitudes: Democrats Worry, Republicans Prepare
- A framework for quantifying individual and collective common sense
- Why are professors liberal?
- What do stances on immigrants' welfare entitlement mean? Evidence from a correlational class analysis
- The Curious Case of Black “Conservatives”: Assessing the Validity of the Liberal-Conservative Scale among Black Americans
- What’s in a Font?: Ideological Perceptions of Typography
- Affective polarisation and the sorting of policy preferences in multiparty systems
- Public Religion and Gendered Attitudes
- Aligned, competing, and blurred: Gender and family attitudes in East Asia
- When partisanship and technocratic credibility collide: mass attitudes and central bank endorsements of fiscal policy in Canada and the USA
- Heuristic Inference and the Left-Right
- Whose Kulturkampf? Asymmetric cleavage mobilisation and the 2023 Turkish elections
- Decomposing attitude distributions to characterize attitude polarization in Europe
- Exposure to opposing views on social media can increase political polarization
- Cultural inheritance is driving a transition in human evolution
- Ideology from topic mixture statistics: inference method and example application to carbon tax public opinion
- Limits of rationality? Moral foundations and polarization in attitudes towards diversity in Germany
- Are universities left‐wing bastions? The political orientation of professors, professionals, and managers in Europe
- Beyond the median voter: A model of how the ideological dimension shapes party polarization
- New threat of culture wars? The religious roots of public opinion polarization on morality issues in Europe
- Emotional Reactions and the Pulse of Public Opinion: Measuring the Impact of Political Events on the Sentiment of Online Discussions
- Interthematic Polarization
- Referendum opposition to fluoridation and health literacy: a cross-sectional analysis conducted in three large US cities. [europepmc]
- The evolution of polarization in the legislative branch of government. [europepmc]
- Legislators' roll-call voting behavior increasingly corresponds to intervals in the political spectrum. [europepmc]
- No echo in the chambers of political interactions on Reddit. [europepmc]
- Rational inference strategies and the genesis of polarization and extremism. [europepmc]
- Cognitive-motivational mechanisms of political polarization in social-communicative contexts. [europepmc]
- Politically-polarized perceptions of governmental autonomy-support impact internal motivations to comply with COVID-19 safety guidelines. [europepmc]
- News sharing on Twitter reveals emergent fragmentation of media agenda and persistent polarization. [europepmc]
- Statistical Mechanics of Political Polarization. [europepmc]
- 'Them' without 'us': negative identities and affective polarization in Brazil. [europepmc]
- A systematic review of worldwide causal and correlational evidence on digital media and democracy. [europepmc]
- Red and blue states: dichotomized maps mislead and reduce perceived voting influence. [europepmc]
- Political Ideology and Trust in Government to Ensure Vaccine Safety: Using a U.S. Survey to Explore the Role of Political Trust. [europepmc]
- Seven years of studying the associations between political polarization and problematic information: a literature review. [europepmc]
- The world around us and the picture(s) in our heads: The effects of news media use on belief organization. [europepmc]
- An Agent-Based Statistical Physics Model for Political Polarization: A Monte Carlo Study. [europepmc]
- Partisan styles of self-presentation in U.S. Twitter bios. [europepmc]
- Imagined otherness fuels blatant dehumanization of outgroups. [europepmc]
- Liberal-conservative asymmetries in anti-democratic tendencies are partly explained by psychological differences in a nationally representative U.S. sample. [europepmc]
- Respondents with more extreme views show moderation of opinions in multi-year surveys in the USA and the Netherlands. [europepmc]
- The polarization of literary censorship in the U.S. [europepmc]
- Application of the Three-Group Model to the 2024 US Elections. [europepmc]
- Politicultural Linking: Inferences Between Political and Apolitical Traits. [europepmc]
- Susceptibility to Moral Arguments Among Liberals and Conservatives. [europepmc]
Related