Error Cascades in the Biological Sciences: The Unwanted Consequences of Using Bad Taxonomy in Ecology
2008/03/01 by Alejandro Bortolus · 415 citations
Biochemistry, Genetics and Molecular Biology · Engineering · Environmental Science · Psychology · #Artificial intelligence #Biology #Biomedical Text Mining and Ontologies #Computer science #Conceptual framework #Data science #Ecology #Engineering #Management science #Process (computing) #Psychology #Set (abstract data type) #Social science #Sociology #Species Distribution and Climate Change #Taxonomy (biology) #Variety (cybernetics)
paper · pdf · doi:10.1579/0044-7447(2008)37[114:ecitbs]2.0.co;2
published in AMBIO 37(2), 114-118 (Springer Science+Business Media)
openalex publication_date 2008/03/01 · openalex created_date 2025/10/10 · openalex updated_date 2026/08/03
Abstract
Why do ecologists seem to underestimate the consequences of using bad taxonomy? Is it because the consequences of doing so have not been yet scrutinized well enough? Is it because these consequences are irrelevant? In this paper I examine and discuss these questions, focusing on the fact that because ecological works provide baseline information for many other biological disciplines, they play a key role in spreading and magnifying the abundance of a variety of conceptual and methodological errors. Although overlooked and underestimated, this cascade-like process originates from trivial taxonomical problems that affect hypotheses and ideas, but it soon shifts into a profound practical problem affecting our knowledge about nature, as well as the ecosystem structure and functioning and the efficiency of human health care programs. In order to improve the intercommunication among disciplines, I propose a set of specific requirements that peer reviewed journals should request from all authors, and I also advocate for urgent institutional and financial support directed at reinvigorating the formation of scientific collections that integrate taxonomy and ecology.
Citations
Cited by
- BIEN : A biodiversity informatics ecosystem advancing open and reproducible workflows for plant observation, plot and trait data
- Identifying the Big Questions in paleontology: a community-driven project
- Towards a species‐level phylogeny for Neotropical Myrtaceae: Notes on topology and resources for future studies
- Recent Progress and Future Prospects in Fossil Xenarthran Studies, with Emphasis on Current Methodology in Sloth Taxonomy
- American highbush cranberry maintains strong population structure despite naturalization of Eurasian relatives in North America
- Harmonizing taxon names in biodiversity data: A review of tools, databases and best practices
- Biodiversity conservation depends on the expansion of taxonomy and systematics research
- Towards harmonized standards for freshwater biodiversity monitoring and biological assessment using benthic macroinvertebrates
- Advancing ecological assessment: The integration of eDNA metabarcoding into an estuarine fish index
- Charting a future for entomological taxonomy in New Zealand
- Incomplete but invaluable: Reassessing the holotype of a singleton madagascan woodlouse (Oniscidea, Armadillidae)
- Environmental DNA metabarcoding: Transforming how we survey animal and plant communities
- Combining new technology with classic taxonomy to overcome hurdles to discovering dark taxa
- Effective monitoring of freshwater fish
- Molluscs for Sale: Assessment of Freshwater Gastropods and Bivalves in the Ornamental Pet Trade
- To increase trust, change the social design behind aggregated biodiversity data
- Controlling the taxonomic variable: Taxonomic concept resolution for a southeastern United States herbarium portal
- DNA barcode analysis of butterfly species fromPakistan points towards regional endemism
- Phytoplankton Evolution, Taxonomy and Ecology
- The Aquatic Heteroptera (Hemiptera) of Marshes in the Florida Everglades
- Natural history clues to the evolution of bivalved gastropods (Mollusca: Gastropoda: Sacoglossa: Juliidae)
- Species delimitation and phylogeography of Aphonopelma hentzi (Araneae, Mygalomorphae, Theraphosidae): cryptic diversity in North American tarantulas. [europepmc]
- The taxonomist - an endangered race. A practical proposal for its survival. [europepmc]
- DNA barcoding for community ecology--how to tackle a hyperdiverse, mostly undescribed Melanesian fauna. [europepmc]
- A ranking system for reference libraries of DNA barcodes: application to marine fish species from Portugal. [europepmc]
- Will the real Bemisia tabaci please stand up? [europepmc]
- The taxonomic name resolution service: an online tool for automated standardization of plant names. [europepmc]
- Non-repeatable science: assessing the frequency of voucher specimen deposition reveals that most arthropod research cannot be verified. [europepmc]
- Biodiversity inventories in high gear: DNA barcoding facilitates a rapid biotic survey of a temperate nature reserve. [europepmc]
- A near-infrared spectroscopy routine for unambiguous identification of cryptic ant species. [europepmc]
- Turning Up the Heat on a Hotspot: DNA Barcodes Reveal 80% More Species of Geometrid Moths along an Andean Elevational Gradient. [europepmc]
- Molluscs for Sale: Assessment of Freshwater Gastropods and Bivalves in the Ornamental Pet Trade. [europepmc]
- How many species and under what names? Using DNA barcoding and GenBank data for west Central African amphibian conservation. [europepmc]
- To increase trust, change the social design behind aggregated biodiversity data. [europepmc]
- Characterization of ecto- and endoparasite communities of wild Mediterranean teleosts by a metabarcoding approach. [europepmc]
- A multigene and morphological analysis expands the diversity of the seabod shrimp Xiphopenaeus Smith, 1869 (Decapoda: Penaeidae), with descriptions of two new species. [europepmc]
- A reference library for Canadian invertebrates with 1.5 million barcodes, voucher specimens, and DNA samples. [europepmc]
- Sharpening the DNA barcoding tool through a posteriori taxonomic validation: The case of Longitarsus flea beetles (Coleoptera: Chrysomelidae). [europepmc]
- Biodiversity inventory of the grey mullets (Actinopterygii: Mugilidae) of the Indo-Australian Archipelago through the iterative use of DNA-based species delimitation and specimen assignment methods. [europepmc]
- Polypore fungi as a flagship group to indicate changes in biodiversity - a test case from Estonia. [europepmc]
- eDNA metabarcoding for biodiversity assessment, generalist predators as sampling assistants. [europepmc]
- Getting science priorities straight: how to increase the reliability of specimen identification? [europepmc]
- Phylogenomic Analyses of the Genus Pseudomonas Lead to the Rearrangement of Several Species and the Definition of New Genera. [europepmc]
- Blue mussels of the Mytilus edulis species complex from South America: The application of species delimitation models to DNA sequence variation. [europepmc]
- Publication practice in Taxonomy: Global inequalities and potential bias against negative results. [europepmc]
- Molecular Weevil Identification Project: A thoroughly curated barcode release of 1300 Western Palearctic weevil species (Coleoptera, Curculionoidea). [europepmc]
Related