Patterns of ‘leakage’ in the utilisation of clinical guidelines: a systematic review
2011/06/29 by Sharon Mickan, Amanda Burls, Paul Glasziou · 25 citations
Economics, Econometrics and Finance · Health Professions · Medicine · Nursing · #Alternative medicine #Family medicine #Guideline #Health Systems, Economic Evaluations, Quality of Life #MEDLINE #Medication Adherence and Compliance #Medicine #Mental Health and Patient Involvement #Nursing #Pathology #Psychological intervention #Systematic review
paper · pdf · doi:10.1136/pgmj.2010.116012
openalex publication_date 2011/06/29 · openalex created_date 2025/10/10 · openalex updated_date 2026/07/30
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Research evidence is insufficient to change physicians' behaviour. In 1996, Pathman developed a four step model: that physicians need to be aware of, agree with, adopt, and adhere to guidelines. OBJECTIVE: To review evidence in different settings on the patterns of 'leakage' in the utilisation of clinical guidelines using Pathman's awareness-to-adherence model. METHODS: A systematic review was conducted in June 2010. Primary studies were included if they reported on rates of awareness and agreement and adoption and/or adherence. RESULTS: 11 primary studies were identified, reporting on 29 recommendations. Descriptive analyses of patterns and causes of leakage were tabulated and graphed. Leakage was progressive across all four steps. Median adherence from all recommendations was 34%, suggesting that potential benefits for patients from health research may be lost. There was considerable variation across different types of guidelines. Recommendations for drug interventions, vaccination and health promotion activities showed high rates of awareness. Leakage was most pronounced between adoption and adherence for drug recommendations and between awareness and agreement for medical management recommendations. Barriers were reported differentially for all steps of the model. CONCLUSION: Leakage from research publication to guideline utilisation occurs in a wide variety of clinical settings and at all steps of the awareness-to-adherence pathway. This review confirms that clinical guidelines are insufficient to implement research and suggests there may be different factors influencing clinicians at each step of this pathway. Recommendations to improve guideline adherence need to be tailored to each step.
Cited by
- Adjusting team involvement: a grounded theory study of challenges in utilizing a surgical safety checklist as experienced by nurses in the operating room. [europepmc]
- What Makes Me Screen for HIV? Perceived Barriers and Facilitators to Conducting Recommended Routine HIV Testing among Primary Care Physicians in the Southeastern United States. [europepmc]
- Awareness, agreement, adoption and adherence to type 2 diabetes mellitus guidelines: a survey of Indonesian primary care physicians. [europepmc]
- A framework of the desirable features of guideline implementation tools (GItools): Delphi survey and assessment of GItools. [europepmc]
- Do guidelines offer implementation advice to target users? A systematic review of guideline applicability. [europepmc]
- Developing a checklist for guideline implementation planning: review and synthesis of guideline development and implementation advice. [europepmc]
- Trends in guideline implementation: a scoping systematic review. [europepmc]
- Healthcare professionals' and policy makers' views on implementing a clinical practice guideline of hypertension management: a qualitative study. [europepmc]
- Integrating an EMR-based Transition Planning Tool for CYSHCN at a Children's Hospital: A Quality Improvement Project to Increase Provider Use and Satisfaction. [europepmc]
- Achieving change in primary care--causes of the evidence to practice gap: systematic reviews of reviews. [europepmc]
- The quantity and quality of complementary and alternative medicine clinical practice guidelines on herbal medicines, acupuncture and spinal manipulation: systematic review and assessment using AGREE II. [europepmc]
- Number and type of guideline implementation tools varies by guideline, clinical condition, country of origin, and type of developer organization: content analysis of guidelines. [europepmc]
- Dissemination of evidence in paediatric emergency medicine: a quantitative descriptive evaluation of a 16-week social media promotion. [europepmc]
- HPV vaccine recommendation profiles among a national network of pediatric practitioners: understanding contributors to parental vaccine hesitancy and acceptance. [europepmc]
- General practitioners' views on managing knee osteoarthritis: a thematic analysis of factors influencing clinical practice guideline implementation in primary care. [europepmc]
- Barriers and enablers for the implementation of clinical practice guidelines in China: a mixed-method study. [europepmc]
- Facilitating Guideline Implementation in Primary Health Care Practices. [europepmc]
- Improved treatment of community-acquired pneumonia through tailored interventions: Results from a controlled, multicentre quality improvement project. [europepmc]
- Nudge strategies to improve healthcare providers' implementation of evidence-based guidelines, policies and practices: a systematic review of trials included within Cochrane systematic reviews. [europepmc]
- Dissemination and implementation research in sports and exercise medicine and sports physical therapy: translating evidence to practice and policy. [europepmc]
- Barriers to and Facilitators of Adherence to Clinical Practice Guidelines in the Middle East and North Africa Region: A Systematic Review. [europepmc]
- The temporospatial epidemiology of rheumatic heart disease in Far North Queensland, tropical Australia 1997-2017; impact of socioeconomic status on disease burden, severity and access to care. [europepmc]
- Barriers and facilitators to implementing evidence-based guidelines in long-term care: a qualitative evidence synthesis. [europepmc]
- Development and Results of an Implementation Plan for High-Intensity Gait Training. [europepmc]
- Trends in guideline implementation: an updated scoping review. [europepmc]
Related