2020/09/04 by Steve Elliott · 5 citations
Biochemistry, Genetics and Molecular Biology · Arts and Humanities · Social Sciences · #Evolution and Genetic Dynamics #Philosophy and History of Science #Evolutionary Game Theory and Cooperation
paper · doi:10.1086/711503
Researchers often pursue proof of concept research, but criteria for evaluating such research remain poorly specified. This article proposes a general framework for proof of concept research that knits together and augments earlier discussions. The framework includes prototypes, proof of concept demonstrations, and post facto demonstrations. With a case from theoretical evolutionary genetics, the article illustrates the general framework and articulates some of the reasoning strategies used within that field. This article provides both specific tools with which to understand how researchers evaluate models in theoretical evolutionary genetics and general tools that apply to proof of concept research more generally.