New perspectives for estimating body condition from mass/length data: the scaled mass index as an alternative method
2009/09/10 by Jordi Peig, Andy J. Green · 50 citations
Environmental Science · #Wildlife Ecology and Conservation #Species Distribution and Climate Change #Fish Ecology and Management Studies
paper · doi:10.1111/j.1600-0706.2009.17643.x
Abstract
Body condition is assumed to influence an animal's health and fitness. Various non‐destructive methods based on body mass and a measure of body length have been used as condition indices (CIs), but the dominant method amongst ecologists is currently the calculation of residuals from an ordinary least squares (OLS) regression of body mass against length. Recent studies of energy reserves in small mammals and starlings claimed to validate this method, although we argue that they did not include the most appropriate tests since they compared the CI with the absolute size of energy reserves. We present a novel CI (the ‘scaled mass index’) based on the central principle of scaling, with important methodological, biological and conceptual advantages. Through a reanalysis of data from small mammals, starlings and snakes, we show that the scaled mass index is a better indicator of the relative size of energy reserves and other body components than OLS residuals, performing better in all seven species and in 19 out of 20 analyses. We also present an empirical and theoretical comparison of the scaled mass index and OLS residuals as CIs. We argue that the scaled mass index is a useful new tool for ecologists.
Cited by
- Tokay geckos adjust their behaviour based on handler familiarity but according to context
- Does the Post‐Natal Social Environment Influence Cognitive Development in a Social Gecko?
- From eggs to adulthood: sustained effects of early developmental temperature and corticosterone exposure on physiology and body size in an Australian lizard
- Does a Frog Change its Diet along a Successional Forest Gradient? The Case of the Shovel-Nosed Treefrog (Diaglena spatulata) in a Tropical Dry Forest in Western Mexico
- Cat colonies reshape the abundance and body size of lizards
- The influence of the pre- and post-natal environment on Tokay gecko (Gekko gecko, Squamata, Gekkonidae) development in captivity
- Pace of life predicts parasite resistance and fecundity tolerance, but not mortality tolerance, among Trinidadian guppies, Poecilia reticulata
- Real-time context-dependent cooperation in parental provisioning reveals fitness payoffs in barn owls
- Evidence for a relationship between bird body size and uncertainty in individual morphological measurements at ringing
- Long-term evaluation of the association between dominance, bib size, sex and age
- State-Dependent and Social Modulation of Circulating Glucocorticoids in a Nomadic Songbird, the Red Crossbill ( Loxia Curvirostra )
- Clinal Variation in Reproductive Modes and Offspring Body Condition Across a Contact Zone of a Bimodal Viviparous Salamander
- Maternal, offspring and environmental influences on weaning age and supersuckling in Galápagos Sea Lions
- An investigation into the impact of urbanization on home range size, dispersal patterns, and body condition of a kin-structured songbird, the black-crested titmouse (Baeolophus atricristatus)
- Sublethal effects of pesticide residues differ between strains of captive Grey partridge: Consequences in terms of rearing conditions
- Validation of aerial photogrammetry methods to measure body size, condition and mass in small cetaceans
- Scaling and developmental integration of a secondary sexual sensory trait
- Passerine stopover physiology: weather variability does not alter corticosterone dynamics after sea crossing
- Variation in body condition, corticosterone response and immune function is related to the timing of nesting in Franklin’s Gull
- Spontaneous quantity discrimination in the Australian sleepy lizard (Tiliqua rugosa)
- Sex-role reversal and the Bateman gradient in coucals—females benefit from mating with multiple partners
- Defensive coloration is not a reliable indicator of fungal infection in aposematic poison frogs
- Experimental evidence for flexibility in provisioning behavior in a cooperatively breeding bird
- Restored seagrass rapidly provides high‐quality habitat for mobile animals
- Sex interacts with fledge date to influence dispersal probability in Fratercula arctica (Atlantic Puffin)
- Fighter–pilot parents: relationships of nest defense with species, nest stage, and brood quality
- Drivers of body condition in South American sea lion pups along a latitudinal gradient
- Sources of variability in advertisement and aggressive calling in competitive interactions in the grey treefrog,Hyla versicolor
- Corticosterone Contributes to Diet-Induced Reprogramming of Post-Metamorphic Behavior in Spadefoot Toads
- Life in plastic, it's not fantastic: Sublethal effects of polyethylene microplastics ingestion throughout amphibian metamorphosis
- Interactions between urbanization, malaria infection and avian cloacal microbiome
- Effects of the invasive riparian plant Arundo donax on riverine fish: a call for action?
- Farming-associated variation in chytrid infection and shedding dynamics in invasive American bullfrogs
- Test of a Body Condition Index with Amphibians
- Forest fragmentation and edge effects impact body condition, fur condition and ectoparasite prevalence in a nocturnal lemur community
- Differences in Establishment of Host and Parasite After One Decade Among Four Simultaneous Translocations of a Long‐Lived Reptile
- Energetic metabolism and condition indices in native versus invasive common waxbills
- Effect of parasite infections on fish body condition: a systematic review and meta-analysis
- Integrating Personality and Thermal Physiology Traits in a Specialist Liolaemus Lizard: Is There a Syndrome?
- Lean mass deposition occurs at a greater rate than fat deposition during pre-breeding stopover in highly depleted songbirds in the northern Gulf of Mexico
- Song overlapping and matching during low‐arousal singing and their relation to visual ornaments, parental care and breeding success in the great tit (Parus major)
- Evaluating the effects of tracking devices on survival, breeding success, behavior, and condition of a small, partially migratory shorebird
- Performance of Cerrado lizards: a test of the center–periphery hypothesis
- Herbicide application improves plethodontid salamander habitat conditions in regenerating clear-cut forests
- Habituation to human disturbance is faster in urban than rural house sparrows
- Organic farming positively affects the vitality of passerine birds in agricultural landscapes
- Cross‐Continental Analysis Shows That Disturbance Effects on Reptile Body Condition Do Not Predict Abundance Responses
- Effects of conventional vs. organic farming practices on raptor nestling health: Neither black nor white
- Assessing body condition in the platypus (Ornithorhynchus anatinus): a comparison of new and old methods
- Experimental exposure of red-legged partridges (Alectoris rufa) to seeds coated with imidacloprid, thiram and difenoconazole
Related