Deterministic Nonperiodic Flow
1963/03/01 by Edward N. Lorenz · 277 citations
Mathematics · Earth and Planetary Sciences · Engineering · #Differential Equations and Numerical Methods #Meteorological Phenomena and Simulations #Fluid Dynamics and Turbulent Flows
paper · pdf · doi:10.1175/1520-0469(1963)020<0130:dnf>2.0.co;2
Abstract
Finite systems of deterministic ordinary nonlinear differential equations may be designed to represent forced dissipative hydrodynamic flow. Solutions of these equations can be identified with trajectories in phase space. For those systems with bounded solutions, it is found that nonperiodic solutions are ordinarily unstable with respect to small modifications, so that slightly differing initial states can evolve into considerably different states. Systems with bounded solutions are shown to possess bounded numerical solutions. A simple system representing cellular convection is solved numerically. All of the solutions are found to be unstable, and almost all of them are nonperiodic. The feasibility of very-long-range weather prediction is examined in the light of these results.
Cited by
- Obstacles to High-Dimensional Particle Filtering
- Spatially-Enhanced Temporal Fusion Transformer: Interpretable Multi-Output Prediction for Parametric Dynamical Systems with Time-Varying Inputs
- Using Local Dynamics to Explain Analog Forecasting of Chaotic Systems
- Potentials in Improving Predictability of Multiscale Tropical Weather Systems Evaluated through Ensemble Assimilation of Simulated Satellite-Based Observations
- How to stop being surprised by unprecedented weather
- The onset of Alfvénic turbulence
- Color image encryption algorithm based on a novel five-dimensional chaotic system
- Propofol anesthesia destabilizes neural dynamics across cortex
- Pattern formation outside of equilibrium
- Chaos in biological systems
- CMIP6 Models Trend Toward Less Persistent European Blocking Regimes in a Warming Climate
- Subseasonal Prediction of Heat‐Related Mortality in Switzerland
- Sparse identification of nonlinear dynamical systems via reweighted <mml:math xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML" display="inline" id="d1e1573" altimg="si188.svg"><mml:msub><mml:mrow><mml:mi>ℓ</mml:mi></mml:mrow><mml:mrow><mml:mn>1</mml:mn></mml:mrow></mml:msub></mml:math>-regularized least squares
- Local and large-scale controls of the exceptional Venice floods of November 2019
- Respecting causality for training physics-informed neural networks
- An architectural capacity ceiling, not a barren plateau: why a fixed-encoding variational quantum circuit cannot fit the Lorenz-63 attractor
- The geometry of chaos: Dynamics of a nonlinear second-order difference equation
- Where a Quantum Reservoir Works: A Transferable Operating Band
- Contribution of expert aggregation to temperature prediction part i
- Beyond the Edge of Chaos: Stability-Expressivity Transfer in Reservoir Forecasting
- A machine-learned probability distribution in the phase space of turbulent channel flow for synthetic turbulence and flow reconstruction
- Towards transferable lightweight neuromorphic computing through a model-free temporal-switch framework
- A zero-one law for one-shot system identification
- Dynamic models with p parameters are identified by 2p+1 random features
- Quantifying the complexity of trajectory ensembles with clustering-weighted multivariate multiscale sample entropy
- A Minimal Interpretable Architecture for Zero-Shot Reconstruction of Dynamical Systems
- The Symbolic Partition of Chaotic Flows Based on Ordinal Patterns
- SKooP: Symmetric Koopman Predictions for Faster and More Generalizable Legged Robot Locomotion with Reinforcement Learning
- Near-term ecological forecasting for climate change action
- Training-Free Bayesian Filtering with Generative Emulators
- A Simple Criterion for Identifying Slow–Fast Relaxation Oscillations
- Position: A Dynamical Systems Perspective is Needed to Advance Time Series Modeling
- From Basins to safe sets: a machine learning perspective on chaotic dynamics
- Continuous-Time Piecewise-Linear Recurrent Neural Networks
- Controllable Probabilistic Forecasting with Stochastic Decomposition Layers
- Reconfigurable Analog Computers
- Identifying statistical indicators of temporal asymmetry using a data-driven approach
- Are Statistical Methods Obsolete in the Era of Deep Learning? A Study of ODE Inverse Problems
- Panda: A pretrained forecast model for chaotic dynamics
- Spontaneous period-doubling cascade and chaos
- Reframing the Free Will Debate: The Universe is Not Deterministic
- Morse-Smale systems and horseshoes for three dimensional singular flows
- Efficient method for detection of periodic orbits in chaotic maps and flows
- On the relation between reliable computation time, float-point precision and the Lyapunov exponent in chaotic systems
- A simple method for detecting chaos in nature
- Bayesian equation selection on sparse data for discovery of stochastic dynamical systems
- Period-Bubbling Transition to Chaos in Thermo-Viscoelastic Fluid Systems
- A conversation analysis-complex dynamics systems theory (CA-CDST) approach for analyzing longitudinal development in L2 pragmatics
- Toward the Fully Physics-Informed Echo State Network -- an ODE Approximator Based on Recurrent Artificial Neurons
- Mathematical Modelling of Heart Rate Changes in the Mouse
- On discrete pseudohyperbolic attractors of Lorenz type
- Fast–Slow Dynamics and Bifurcation Mechanism in a Novel Chaotic System
- Borel Cantelli Lemmas and Extreme Value Theory for Geometric Lorenz Models
- Strategies for Reduced-Order Models for Predicting the Statistical Responses and Uncertainty Quantification in Complex Turbulent Dynamical Systems
- NONCHAOTIC AND CHAOTIC BEHAVIOR IN THREE-DIMENSIONAL QUADRATIC SYSTEMS: FIVE-ONE CONSERVATIVE CASES
- Learning Runge-Kutta Integration Schemes for ODE Simulation and Identification
- Wild Lorenz like attractors
- Theoretical Design and Circuit Implementation of Integer Domain Chaotic Systems
- Adaptation modulates effective connectivity and network stability
- Long-term prediction of chaotic systems with recurrent neural networks
- A Data-Assimilation-Augmented Optimization Framework for Parameter Estimation in Dynamical Systems
- A SURVEY OF METHODS FOR COMPUTING (UN)STABLE MANIFOLDS OF VECTOR FIELDS
- Constructing a Novel No-Equilibrium Chaotic System
- Revealing Hidden Features of Chaotic Systems Using High-Performance Bifurcation Analysis Tools Based on CUDA Technology
- Quantum Breakdown Condensate as a Disorder-Free Quantum Glass
- Chaos, Ito-Stratonovich dilemma, and topological supersymmetry
- Wave-Like Statistics from Classical Active Particles with Internal Degrees Of Freedom
- Exact Conservation Laws of the Lorenz Attractor: Classification and Deterministic Prediction of Lobe-Switching Events
- Research Program: Theory of Learning in Dynamical Systems
- Clean Numerical Simulation: A New Strategy to Obtain Reliable Solutions of Chaotic Dynamic Systems
- Learning solution operator of dynamical systems with diffusion maps kernel ridge regression
- Granger Causality Maps for Langevin Systems
- The Universe Learning Itself: On the Evolution of Dynamics from the Big Bang to Machine Intelligence
- Learning stochastic dynamical systems with neural networks mimicking the\n Euler-Maruyama scheme
- Cascades of Lorenz attractors in the Shimizu-Morioka model
- Chaotic dynamics of a continuous and discrete generalized Ziegler pendulum
- A New 7D Hyperchaotic System with Five Positive Lyapunov Exponents Coined
- Periodic solutions of hybrid jump diffusion processes
- Prediction performance of random reservoirs with different topology for nonlinear dynamical systems with different number of degrees of freedom
- Beta-Dependent Gamma Feedback and Endogenous Volatility Amplification in Option Markets
- ECO: Energy-Constrained Operator Learning for Chaotic Dynamics with Boundedness Guarantees
- DAISI: Data Assimilation with Inverse Sampling using Stochastic Interpolants
- Self-Supervised Dynamical System Representations for Physiological Time-Series
- Strategic nomadic-colonial switching: Stochastic noise and subsidence-recovery cycles
- Don’t Call It a Failure: Systemic Risk Governance for Complex Financial Systems
- Predicting Friction under Vastly Different Lubrication Scenarios
- Enforcing governing equation constraints in neural PDE solvers via training-free projections
- Numerical Transitivity and Numerical Leo Properties for Lorenz Maps with Applications to Courbage-Nekorkin-Vdovin Neuron Model
- The Ensemble Kalman Inversion Race
- Chemical systems with chaos
- Constrained Sparse Galerkin Regression
- Convergent least-squares optimisation methods for variational data\n assimilation
- On Boundedness of Quadratic Dynamics with Energy-Preserving Nonlinearity
- Chaos of Learning Beyond Zero-sum and Coordination via Game Decompositions
- A parallel-in-time Newton's method-based ODE solver
- Period Constraints on Hyperelliptic Branch Points
- STICK: Spike Time Interval Computational Kernel, A Framework for General Purpose Computation using Neurons, Precise Timing, Delays, and Synchrony
- Exploring Ultra Rapid Data Assimilation Based on Ensemble Transform Kalman Filter with the Lorenz 96 Model
- Learning enhanced ensemble filters
- Modeling Unsteady Aircraft Aerodynamics Using Lorenz Attractor: A Reduced-Order Approach for Wing Rock
- Reconstruction of Ordinary Differential Equations From Time Series Data
- Phase space volume preserving dynamics for non-Hamiltonian systems
- Diffusion Models Bridge Deep Learning and Physics in ENSO Forecasting
- Integrating Score-Based Generative Modeling and Neural ODEs for Accurate Representation of Multiscale Chaotic Dynamics
- Implementation of a generalized intermittency scenario in the Rossler dynamical system
- Kneading the Lorenz attractor
- Variational Data-Consistent Assimilation
- Sparse and nonparametric estimation of equations governing dynamical systems with applications to biology
- Geomimicry: Emergent Dynamics in Earth-Mediated Complex Materials
- FMint-SDE: A Multimodal Foundation Model for Accelerating Numerical Simulation of SDEs via Error Correction
- pDANSE: Particle-based Data-driven Nonlinear State Estimation from Nonlinear Measurements
- Regime identification and control of extremes in the non-autonomous Lorenz model with chaos and intransitivity
- Neural Stochastic Flows: Solver-Free Modelling and Inference for SDE Solutions
- Predictability of Storms in an Idealized Climate Revealed by Machine Learning
- COBASE: A new copula-based shuffling method for ensemble weather forecast postprocessing
- Data-driven Exploration of Tropical Cyclone's Controllability
- A 3D Strange Attractor with a Distinctive Silhouette. The Butterfly Effect Revisited
- Determining Lyapunov exponents from a time series
- Finite-time and exact Lyapunov dimension of the Henon map
- The one-way function based on computational uncertainty principle
- Adjoint chaos via cumulant truncation
- Homoclinic saddle to saddle-focus transitions in 4D systems
- Nonlinear dynamics: A new perspective on IHRM research and practice in the 21st century
- Replication of Li-Yorke Chaos Near a Homoclinic Orbit
- Entropy theory for sectional hyperbolic flows
- Complexity theory and leadership practice: A review, a critique, and some recommendations
- The predictability problems in numerical weather and climate prediction
- A practical method for calculating largest Lyapunov exponents from small data sets
- A set-oriented path following method for the approximation of parameter dependent attractors
- Determining embedding dimension for phase-space reconstruction using a geometrical construction
- Some simple chaotic flows
- Using machine learning to predict statistical properties of non-stationary dynamical processes: System climate,regime transitions, and the effect of stochasticity
- Advances and challenges in climate modeling
- Does Google Scholar contain all highly cited documents (1950-2013)?
- Practical method for determining the minimum embedding dimension of a scalar time series
- Nonlinear dynamics, delay times, and embedding windows
- Supply Network Structure, Visibility, and Risk Diffusion: A Computational Approach
- The structure and dynamics of networks with higher order interactions
- From limited observations to the state of turbulence: Fundamental\n difficulties of flow reconstruction
- A lower-bound estimate of the Lyapunov dimension for the global\n attractor of the Lorenz system
- Predictability in the large: an extension of the concept of Lyapunov exponent
- End-to-end learning of energy-based representations for irregularly-sampled signals and images
- Assessing Turbulence Strength via Lyaponuv Exponents
- Review of Nonlinear Methods and Modelling
- On the algorithmic descriptive complexity of attractors in topological dynamics
- Data Assimilation: A Mathematical Introduction
- A modified particle filter that reduces weight collapse
- Complex behavior from a simple physical system: A numerical investigation
- Dopamine-driven synaptic credit assignment in neural networks
- An Introductory Guide to Koopman Learning
- Analytical and numerical study of the hidden boundary of practical stability: complex versus real Lorenz systems
- Minimizing Residuals in ODE Integration Using Optimal Control
- Entropy production and dynamical complexity in a low‐order atmospheric model
- Small Ensemble-based Data Assimilation: A Machine Learning-Enhanced Data Assimilation Method with Limited Ensemble Size
- Dissecting Neural ODEs
- From Observations to Parameters: Detecting Changepoint in Nonlinear Dynamics with Simulation-based Inference
- Notation for Iteration of Functions, Iteral
- Computation of minimal periods for ordinary differential equations
- Wild dynamics on manifolds
- Data adaptation in HANDY economy-ideology model
- Towards Foundation Inference Models that Learn ODEs In-Context
- Invariant Set Theory
- Sensitivity dependence of the Navier-Stokes turbulence of a two-dimensional Rayleigh-Bénard convection on time-step
- On the Dynamics of Complex Quadratic Families under Holomorphic and Non-Holomorphic Singular Perturbations
- From quantum feature maps to quantum reservoir computing: perspectives and applications
- Quantifying the computability of the Lorenz system
- Extreme value forecasting using relevance-based data augmentation with deep learning models
- Machine Learning Classification Informed by a Functional Biophysical System
- Adaptation and Parameter Estimation in Systems with Unstable Target Dynamics and Nonlinear Parametrization
- Data selection: at the interface of PDE-based inverse problem and randomized linear algebra
- Ultra-chaotic property of Navier-Stokes turbulence
- Learning to Predict Chaos: Curriculum-Driven Training for Robust Forecasting of Chaotic Dynamics
- Detecting Invariant Manifolds in ReLU-Based RNNs
- Dynamical system reconstruction from partial observations using stochastic dynamics
- Digital Twins: McKean-Pontryagin Control for Partially Observed Physical Twins
- Bilinear residual Neural Network for the identification and forecasting of dynamical systems
- Clean numerical simulation of three-dimensional turbulent Kolmogorov flow
- Machine Learning Workflows in Climate Modeling: Design Patterns and Insights from Case Studies
- Learning strange attractors with reservoir systems
- Invariant Algebraic Surfaces and Constrained Systems
- Spike Spectra for Recurrences
- Reducing Storage of Global Wind Ensembles with Stochastic Generators
- Shape-Informed Clustering of Multi-Dimensional Functional Data via Deep Functional Autoencoders
- A Multivariate Method for Dynamic System Analysis: Multivariate Detrended Fluctuation Analysis Using Generalized Variance
- The discontinuous dynamics and non-autonomous chaos
- A Statistical Theory of Deep Learning via Proximal Splitting
- Multilevel Estimation of Normalization Constants Using the Ensemble\n Kalman-Bucy Filter
- Dynamical Low-Rank Filters for Data Assimilation
- Recurrence-based characterization of model shadowability in the presence of unstable dimension variability
- Electrohydrodynamic interaction of spherical particles under Quincke rotation
- Weather Jiu-Jitsu: Prospects for atmospheric nudging to defuse the impact of catastrophic weather extremes
- On definition of Devaney chaos for a continuous group action on a Hausdorff uniform space
- Persistent heterodimensional cycles in periodic perturbations of Lorenz-like attractors
- Discretisation of the Bloch Sphere, Fractal Invariant Sets and Bell's Theorem
- Ulam's method for Lasota-Yorke maps with holes
- Convergent Numerical Solutions for Unsteady Regular or Chaotic Differential Equations
- Probabilistic Performance-Pattern Decomposition (PPPD): analysis framework and applications to stochastic mechanical systems
- A Cr-connecting lemma for Lorenz attractors and its application on the space of ergodic measures
- Computational Complex Dynamics Of The Discrete Lorenz System
- Chaotic interaction between thermodynamic systems
- METASTABILITY IN SIMPLE CLIMATE MODELS: PATHWISE ANALYSIS OF SLOWLY DRIVEN LANGEVIN EQUATIONS
- Nonlinear analysis of bivariate data with cross recurrence plots
- Spatiotemporal graph neural process for reconstruction, extrapolation, and classification of cardiac trajectories
- Reservoir computing with complex Ginzburg–Landau lattice dynamics for chaotic time-series prediction
- Synergistic effects of El Niño–Southern Oscillation and the Indian Ocean Dipole on Middle Eastern subseasonal precipitation variability and predictability
- Protein folding tames chaos
- Omega-limit sets close to singular-hyperbolic attractors
- The influence of numerical noises on statistics computation of chaotic dynamic systems
- Nonlinear dynamical models from time series
- Numerical differentiation: local versus global methods
- AquaCast: Urban Water Dynamics Forecasting with Precipitation-Informed Multi-Input Transformer
- Revisiting Hammel et al. (1987): Does the shadowing property hold for modern computers?
- Toward Chaotic Group Velocity Hopping of an On-Chip Dissipative Kerr Soliton
- Energy-dynamics interplay in temporal networks triggers explosive synchronization
- Hidden and self-excited attractors in Chua circuit: SPICE simulation and synchronization
- Building causation links in stochastic nonlinear systems from data
- Detecting extreme event-driven causality
- Sustainability Risks under Lotka-Volterra Dynamics
- Modelings and mechanism analysis underlying both the 4D Euler equations and Hamiltonian conservative chaotic systems
- Dynamic Cournot oligopoly game based on general isoelastic demand
- Forecasting Low-Dimensional Turbulence via Multi-Dimensional Hybrid Quantum Reservoir Computing
- A New Approach to Stability of Delay Differential Equations with Time-Varying Delays via Isospectral Reduction
- Deficiency of equation-finding approach to data-driven modeling of dynamical systems
- Solving the nonlinear Klein-Gordon equation: semianalytical Galerkin method
- A unified theory of chaos linking nonlinear dynamics and statistical physics
- Modular knots obey the Chebotarev law
- A hybrid dynamical-stochastic model of maximum temperature time series of Imphal, Northeast India incorporating nonlinear feedback and noise diagnostics
- The Rikitake two-disc dynamo system
- DeepSeasons: a Deep Learning scale-selecting approach to Seasonal Forecasts
- Designing learning in high dimensional oscillator networks with low dimensional read-out
- Estimation of mutual information using kernel density estimators
- Chaotic mechanism description by an elementary mixer for the template of an attractor
- SpeedMalloc: Improving Multi-threaded Applications via a Lightweight Core for Memory Allocation
- Discovering equations from data: symbolic regression in dynamical systems
- Tracking Individual Clouds to Assess the Fidelity of High‐Resolution Modeling
- How Non-linearity will Transform Information Systems
- Reduction of Complex Dynamics in Far-from-equilibrium Systems: Nambu Non-equilibrium Thermodynamics
- Reduced-Order Modeling of Cyclo-Stationary Time Series Using Score-Based Generative Methods
- Analog-based ensembles to characterize turbulent dynamics from observed data
- HypER: Hyperbolic Echo State Networks for Capturing Stretch-and-Fold Dynamics in Chaotic Flows
- Reservoir observers: Model-free inference of unmeasured variables in chaotic systems
- GBEES-GPU: An efficient parallel GPU algorithm for high-dimensional nonlinear uncertainty propagation
- Econophysics deserves a revamping
- Dynamics and synchronization of a novel 4D-hyperjerk autonomous chaotic system with a Van der Pol nonlinearity
- Detecting chaos from a time series
- Flow Matching for Efficient and Scalable Data Assimilation
- Identification of Piecewise Linear Models of Complex Dynamical Systems
- Compositional Modeling of Nonlinear Dynamical Systems with ODE-based\n Random Features
- Recurrence Patterns Correlation
- Efficient and Optimally Accurate Numerical Algorithms for Stochastic Turbulent Flow Problems
- Can renormalization group flow end in a Big Mess?
- Reduction of breast cancer relapses with perioperative non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs: new findings and a review
- From Formal Methods to Data-Driven Safety Certificates of Unknown Large-Scale Networks
- Real-time forecasting of chaotic dynamics from sparse data and autoencoders
- On the Stability of Gradient Based Turbulent Flow Control without Regularization
- Forecasting with Historical Data or Process Knowledge under\n Misspecification: A Comparison
- Hitting times distribution and extreme value law for flows
- Next-generation reservoir computing for dynamical inference
- Generalized Kernel-Based Dynamic Mode Decomposition
- Reservoir computing with large valid prediction time for the Lorenz system
- Machine Learning-Based Nonlinear Nudging for Chaotic Dynamical Systems
- Thermal convection in huddling emperor penguins
- OpenMP parallelization of multiple precision Taylor series method
- Preterm Birth Analysis Using Nonlinear Methods (a preliminary study)
- Causal inference for process understanding in Earth sciences
- Major open problems in chaos theory and nonlinear dynamics
- Introduction to Focus Issue: Topics in Nonlinear Science
- The Minimum Energy Principle Applied to Parker's Coronal Braiding and Nanoflaring Scenario
- Trimmed Ensemble Kalman Filter for Nonlinear and Non-Gaussian Data Assimilation Problems
- Data-Efficient Control of Polynomial Systems via Physics-Guided Quadratic Constraints
- A numerical method for computing time-periodic solutions in dissipative wave systems
- PnP-DA: Towards Principled Plug-and-Play Integration of Variational Data Assimilation and Generative Models
- The Lyapunov Exponents of Hyperbolic Measures for C1 Star Vector Fields on Three-dimensional Manifolds
- Solving large number of non-stiff, low-dimensional ordinary differential\n equation systems on GPUs and CPUs: performance comparisons of MPGOS, ODEINT\n and DifferentialEquations.jl
- Physics-Informed Neural Networks with Dynamical Boundary Constraints
- Geometrical approach to modeling of nonlinear systems from experimental data
- Evolutionary global optimization posed as a randomly perturbed\n martingale problem and applied to parameter recovery of chaotic oscillators
Related