1995/06/01 by Bruce Stephenson, James R. Voelkel · 50 citations
Physics and Astronomy · Arts and Humanities · #History and Developments in Astronomy #Historical Astronomy and Related Studies #Historical and Architectural Studies #Kepler #Astronomy #Physics #Astrophysics #Theoretical physics #Stars
paper · doi:10.1063/1.2808069
published in Physics Today 48(6), 59-60 (AIP Publishing)
openalex publication_date 1995/06/01 · openalex created_date 2025/10/10 · openalex updated_date 2026/07/30
Valued today for its development of the Third Law of Planetary Motion, Harmonice mundi (1619) was intended by Kepler to expand on ancient efforts to discern a Creator's plan for the planetary system - an arrangement thought to be based on harmonic relationships. Challenging critics who characterize Kepler's theories of harmonic astronomy as mystical, Bruce Stephenson offers a thorough technical analysis of the music the astronomer thought the heavens made, and the logic that led him to find musical patterns in his data. In so doing, Stephenson illuminates crucial aspects of Kepler's intellectual development, particularly his ways of classifying and drawing inferences. Beginning with a survey of similar theories associating music with the cyclic motions of planets, from Plato to Boethius, the author highlights Ptolemy's Harmonics, a source of inspiration for Kepler's later work. Turning to Kepler himself, Stephenson gives an account of his polyhedral theory, which explains the number and sizes of the planetary orbits in terms of the five regular polyhedral. He then examines in detail an early theory that relates the planets' velocities to a musical chord, and analyzes Kepler's unpublished commentary on Ptolemy's Harmonics.