Estimating Dynamic State Preferences from United Nations Voting Data
2015/08/17 by Michael A. Bailey, Michael Bailey, Anton Strezhnev +1 · 59 citations
Social Sciences · Economics, Econometrics and Finance · #International Development and Aid #Global trade and economics #Political Conflict and Governance
paper · doi:10.1177/0022002715595700
Abstract
United Nations (UN) General Assembly votes have become the standard data source for measures of states preferences over foreign policy. Most papers use dyadic indicators of voting similarity between states. We propose a dynamic ordinal spatial model to estimate state ideal points from 1946 to 2012 on a single dimension that reflects state positions toward the US-led liberal order. We use information about the content of the UN’s agenda to make estimates comparable across time. Compared to existing measures, our estimates better separate signal from noise in identifying foreign policy shifts, have greater face validity, allow for better intertemporal comparisons, are less sensitive to shifts in the UN’ agenda, and are strongly correlated with measures of liberalism. We show that the choice of preference measures affects conclusions about the democratic peace.
Citations
Cited by
- Trade networks and firm value: Evidence from the U.S.-China trade war
- Mask wars: Sourcing a critical medical product from China in times of COVID-19
- Playing with blocs: Quantifying decoupling
- State Control and the Effects of Foreign Relations on Bilateral Trade
- International bureaucrats under transparency: The case of the WTO TRIPS Council
- Can Aid Buy Foreign Public Support? Evidence from Chinese Development Finance
- The Geopolitical Threat Index: A Text-Based Computational Approach to Identifying Foreign Threats
- Liberal Ideology and Foreign Opinion on China
- Foreign Aid, Development, and US Strategic Interests in the Cold War
- Does Foreign Aid Bifurcate Donor Approval?: Patronage Politics, Winner–Loser Status, and Public Attitudes toward the Donor
- International Financial Institutions and the Promotion of Autocratic Resilience
- The Argumentative Power of International Law: Legal Rhetoric, Human Rights, and the Universal Periodic Review
- Civil war and state support for conventional arms control
- Changing global linkages: A new Cold War?
- Estimating the Geopolitical Preferences of Large Language Models from United Nations Voting Data
- A Multifaceted Analysis of Social Biases in Large Language Models
- Interstate rivalry, major power status, and state support for arms control
- Reaching for the Threshold: How Minimum Participation Rules Facilitate Multilateral Treaty Ratification
- Multidimensional conflicts over disarmament and international security: analyzing speeches in the First Committee of the UN General Assembly
- Effects of international sanctions on age-specific mortality: a cross-national panel data analysis
- A Dynamic Additive and Multiplicative Effects Model with Application to the United Nations Voting Behaviors
- Do States Constrain Non-State Hackers? International Telecommunication Union Elections and Non-State Cyber Aggression
- The Brandt Line after forty years: The more North–South relations change, the more they stay the same?
- The Political and Pragmatic Determinants of Chinese Development Finance in Latin America and the Caribbean, 2008–2019
- The Russian threat and the consolidation of the West: How populism and EU-skepticism shape party support for Ukraine
- Partners and rivals? The AIIB’s cooperation with preexisting multilateral development banks
- Exiting Russia
- The Power of Peers: a spatial analysis of nationally determined contributions
- Words that matter: A machine learning analysis of United Nations General Assembly speeches and their influence on aid allocation
- External threats and state support for arms control
- With Friends Like These: The Impact of US Troop Deployments on Economic Sanctions Busting
- Who Speaks for Beijing? Insights from a New Dataset on China's Diplomatic Elite
- Are dollars popular? The Fed’s currency swap arrangements and recipient governments’ popularity
- In-group punishment in international relations: US reactions to the founding of China’s AIIB
- Legislative Politics under “One Country, Two Systems”: Evidence from Macau, 2013–2021
- Friendshoring: how geopolitical tensions affect foreign sourcing, supply base complexity, and sub-tier supplier sharing
- IMF Lending Programs and Repression in Autocracies
- Who Gets Targeted with Soft Power? Evidence from Henry Kissinger’s International Seminar
- Following the Dragon: Understanding Chinese NGOs’ Location Choices in Global Development Initiatives
- Polarization, Political Turnover, and the Stability of Democratic Foreign Policy
- Insuring the Weak: The Institutional Power Equilibrium in International Organizations
- Debating Threats in the UNSC: A New Dataset on Explanations of Votes 1989–2019
- Trade, Political Distance and the World Trade Organization
- Connector countries in a geoeconomically fragmenting world
- Exploring geopolitics and innovation: the role of bilateral relationships in shaping research collaboration
- Multinational investment activity under policy uncertainty in host and competing countries
- Democracy, Trade Networks, and International Condemnation of Russia Following the Invasion of Ukraine
- Multiplex communities and the emergence of international conflict. [europepmc]
- Who sends me face masks? Evidence for the impacts of COVID-19 on international trade in medical goods. [europepmc]
- Discovering cooperation: Endogenous change in international organizations. [europepmc]
- Mitigating donor interests in the case of COVID-19 vaccine: the implication of COVAX and DAC membership. [europepmc]
- Impact of the COVID-19 epidemic on medical product imports from china from outbreak to stabilization: Monthly panel data regression and instrumental variable test. [europepmc]
- Parliamentary roll-call voting as a complex dynamical system: The case of Chile. [europepmc]
- Legitimacy challenges to the liberal world order: Evidence from United Nations speeches, 1970-2018. [europepmc]
- Barriers to child vaccination: The role of international sanctions. [europepmc]
- Diffusion of Influence? Detecting China's Footprint in Foreign Policies of Other Countries. [europepmc]
- Quantifying Global Foreign Affairs with a Multimodal Dataset of Diplomatic Websites. [europepmc]
- A spatial perspective on the impact of official development assistance on sustainable development goals. [europepmc]
- IMF-Supported Programs and Sovereign Debt Crises [europepmc]
Related