1999/03/01 by Aletta Biersack · 196 citations
Social Sciences · #Anthropological Studies and Insights #Anthropology #Biology #Cultural materialism (cultural studies) #Ecology #Environmental ethics #Epistemology #Geographies of human-animal interactions #Historical materialism #Idealism #Law #Materialism #Philosophy #Political science #Politics #Posthumanism #Rappaport #Sociology #Southeast Asian Sociopolitical Studies
paper · doi:10.1525/aa.1999.101.1.5
published in American Anthropologist 101(1), 5-18 (Wiley)
openalex publication_date 1999/03/01 · openalex created_date 2025/10/10 · openalex updated_date 2026/07/10
An earlier ecological anthropology defined its project within the compass of the idealism v. materialism debate. Culture was an adaptive tool, instrumental rather than formal; it was intelligible with respect to its material effects, not—as the idealists would maintain—in terms of itself, as an autonomous, self‐determining order of reality. This argument was mounted with respect to bounded, stable, self‐regulating, local, or at best regional entities and the environment they inhabited. All of the premises of the earlier ecology have since been challenged, and today's ecologies—symbolic, historical, and political—radically depart from the reductions and elisions of the ecological anthropology of the past. In particular, the new ecologies override the dichotomies that informed and enlivened the debates of the past—nature/culture, idealism/materialism—and they are informed by the literature on transnationalist flows and local‐global articulations. This introduction positions Rappaport's work within this historical shift from a polarized field of mutually exclusive frameworks to today's synthetic new ecologies and their antireductive materialism. Rappaport's work, produced over three decades, serves, in and through its own transformations, as a bridge between the reductive materialism of the past and a new‐materialist ecology. [Rappaport, ecological anthropology, materialism v. idealism, the new materialism]