Is decentralization good for your health? Transformations in the Italian NHS

2012/06/22 by Emmanuele Pavolini, Giovanna Vicarelli · 9 citations
Social Sciences · Health Professions · #Social Policy and Reform Studies #Global Health Care Issues #Employment and Welfare Studies

paper · doi:10.1177/0011392112438332

Abstract

Decentralization is a cornerstone of health policy reforms across Europe and beyond. This article analyses some of the effects of decentralization using the Italian National Health System (NHS) as a case study. The authors evaluate the risks of welfare state retrenchment and the rise of territorial inequalities in accessing healthcare, using document analysis, secondary sources and micro-data elaboration. The analysis does not confirm an overall welfare state retrenchment, but reveals an increase in territorial inequalities. The results highlight a paradox: if decentralization is to be implemented in a country with strong territorial socioeconomic divides and a critical financial situation, it needs a strong central government in order to support and control local authorities. Otherwise, decentralization may cause a zero-sum game where the gains for the better-off regions counterbalance the losses in performance of the weaker ones; a situation which could lead to the growth of social inequalities, including gender inequalities.

Cited by

• Phenomenology of health and social care integration in Italy
• Interregional Patient Mobility in the Italian NHS: A Case of Badly-Managed Decentralization Comment on "Regional Incentives and Patient Cross-Border Mobility: Evidence From the Italian Experience". [europepmc]
• Experiences from Decentralised Radiological Services in Norway - a rural case study. [europepmc]
• Dealing with COVID-19 Epidemic in Italy: Responses from Regional Organizational Models during the First Phase of the Epidemic. [europepmc]
• The Effects of Health Sector Fiscal Decentralisation on Availability, Accessibility, and Utilisation of Healthcare Services: A Panel Data Analysis. [europepmc]
• Italian public's views on sharing genetic information and medical information: findings from the 'Your DNA, Your Say' study. [europepmc]
• National heroes, disposable workers. How collective action in the health and social care sector during the pandemic negotiated with the self-sacrificing worker ideal. [europepmc]
• The managerial role of healthcare professionals in public hospitals: a time-driven analysis of their activities. [europepmc]
• Unveiling and understanding health inequalities: A bi-clustering study on SDG3 implementation in the Italian regions. [europepmc]

Related

• The impacts of decentralization on health system equity, efficiency and resilience: a realist synthesis of the evidence
• Restructuring the Italian NHS: a case study of the regional hospital network
• The impact of decentralization of health services on health outcomes: evidence from Canada
• How decentralization can generate democratic deficits-a comparative analysis of Sicily (Italy) and Zuid-Holland (Netherlands)
• Divergent Outcomes of Centralisation Versus Decentralisation: A Comparative Analysis of Poland’s and Sweden’s COVID-19 Governance Models and Their Implications for the Health Security of the European Union