An imprecise-probabilistic characterization of frequentist statistical inference

2021/12/20 by Martin, Ryan
#FOS: Mathematics #Statistics Theory (math.ST)

paper · doi:10.48550/arxiv.2112.10904

Abstract

Between the two dominant schools of thought in statistics, namely, Bayesian and classical/frequentist, a main difference is that the former is grounded in the mathematically rigorous theory of probability while the latter is not. In this paper, I show that the latter is grounded in a different but equally mathematically rigorous theory of imprecise probability. Specifically, I show that for every suitable testing or confidence procedure with error rate control guarantees, there exists a consonant plausibility function whose derived testing or confidence procedure is no less efficient. Beyond its foundational implications, this characterization has at least two important practical consequences: first, it simplifies the interpretation of p-values and confidence regions, thus creating opportunities for improved education and scientific communication; second, the constructive proof of the main results leads to a strategy for new and improved methods in challenging inference problems.

Related

• Valid and efficient imprecise-probabilistic inference with partial priors, II. General framework
• Valid and efficient imprecise-probabilistic inference with partial priors, I. First results
• Hypothesis testing and confidence sets: why Bayesian not frequentist, and how to set a prior with a regulatory authority
• Strictly Frequentist Imprecise Probability
• The relation between frequentist confidence intervals and Bayesian credible intervals