Educated Preferences: Explaining Attitudes Toward Immigration in Europe
2007/04/01 by Jens Hainmueller, Michael J. Hiscox, Michael Hiscox · 1,158 citations
Social Sciences · #Competition (biology) #Demographic economics #Economics #European Social Survey #Immigration #Labour economics #Migration and Labor Dynamics #Migration, Ethnicity, and Economy #Migration, Refugees, and Integration #Political science
paper · doi:10.1017/s0020818307070142
published in International Organization 61(02) (University of Cambridge)
openalex publication_date 2007/04/01 · openalex created_date 2025/10/10 · openalex updated_date 2026/07/25
Abstract
Recent studies of individual attitudes toward immigration emphasize concerns about labor-market competition as a potent source of anti-immigrant sentiment, in particular among less-educated or less-skilled citizens who fear being forced to compete for jobs with low-skilled immigrants willing to work for much lower wages. We examine new data on attitudes toward immigration available from the 2003 European Social Survey. In contrast to predictions based on conventional arguments about labor-market competition, which anticipate that individuals will oppose immigration of workers with similar skills to their own but support immigration of workers with different skill levels, we find that people with higher levels of education and occupational skills are more likely to favor immigration regardless of the skill attributes of the immigrants in question. Across Europe, higher education and higher skills mean more support for all types of immigrants. These relationships are almost identical among individuals in the labor force (that is, those competing for jobs) and those not in the labor force. Contrary to the conventional wisdom, then, the connection between the education or skill levels of individuals and views about immigration appears to have very little, if anything, to do with fears about labor-market competition. This finding is consistent with extensive economic research showing that the income and employment effects of immigration in European economies are actually very small. We find that a large component of the link between education and attitudes toward immigrants is driven by differences among individuals in cultural values and beliefs. More educated respondents are significantly less racist and place greater value on cultural diversity than do their counterparts; they are also more likely to believe that immigration generates benefits for the host economy as a whole.The authors would like to thank Beth Simmons, Shigeo Herano, Mike Tomz, James Alt, Jeffry Frieden, Ron Rogowski, Ken Scheve, Torben Iversen, Andy Baker, and Peter Gourevitch for helpful comments on earlier drafts.
Cited by
- Team and Nation: Sports, Nationalism, and Attitudes Toward Refugees
- The Impact of Economic and Cultural Cues on Support for Immigration in Canada and the United States
- Trust, Economic Development and Attitudes toward Immigration
- Which immigrants do citizens prefer? A meta-reanalysis of 100 conjoint experiments
- Sectoral Economies, Economic Contexts, and Attitudes toward Immigration
- Separated by Degrees: Social Closure by Education Levels Strengthens Contemporary Political Divides
- Shutting the Gates in South Africa: National Identification and Popular Attitudes towards Closing Borders to Immigration
- When the Going Gets Tough: The Differential Impact of National Unemployment on the Perceived Threats of Immigration
- Does Occupation Shape Attitudes on Europe? Benchmarking Validity and Parsimony
- Opposition to Pro‐Immigrant Public Policy: Symbolic Racism and Group Threat
- Unpacking the liberalizing potential of higher education: an analysis of academic majors, anti-Black prejudice, and opposition to immigration
- Taking cues on multidimensional issues: the case of attitudes toward immigration
- Explaining Attitudes toward Immigration: The Role of Regional Context and Individual Predispositions
- Low-Skilled Liberalizers: Support for Free Trade in Africa
- Attitudes towards interethnic partnerships with refugees: Evidence from a factorial survey experiment in Germany
- How Local Context Affects Populist Radical Right Support: A Cross-National Investigation Into Mediated and Moderated Relationships
- A New Approach to the Study of Tolerance: Conceptualizing and Measuring Acceptance, Respect, and Appreciation of Difference
- The mass politics of public debt, immigration, and austerity
- Perceived threat, compassion, and public evaluations toward refugees
- Immigration, Ethnic Diversity, and Political Outcomes: Evidence from Denmark
- Drinking Alone: Local Socio-Cultural Degradation and Radical Right Support—The Case of British Pub Closures
- Anti-Immigrant Attitudes and Political Participation in Europe
- Fostering refugee receptivity through perspective taking: Evidence from Thailand
- Place, education, and voting along the transnational cleavage in Europe
- The Brexit realignment amid electoral volatility: The role of party blocs in the 2024 General Election
- Does Higher Education Have Liberalizing or Inoculating Effects? A Panel Study of Anti-Immigrant Sentiment before, during, and after the European Migration Crisis
- Revisiting the role of education in attitudes toward immigration in different contexts in Europe
- What do stances on immigrants' welfare entitlement mean? Evidence from a correlational class analysis
- Between fearmongers and Samaritans: Does information provision affect attitudes towards the right of asylum in Germany?
- Attitudes towards immigration and unemployment risk cleavages: Untangling the economically rooted group conflict framework
- Does educational attainment matter for attitudes toward immigrants in Chile? Assessing the causality and generalizability of higher education's so‐called “liberalizing effect” on economic and cultural threat
- The economic and cultural dimensions of unequal policy representation
- Migrant Deaths at Borders and Immigration Attitudes: Evidence from the 2013 Lampedusa Shipwreck
- Framing refugees: experimental evidence from the United States, Canada, and Australia
- Enfranchising immigrants and/or emigrants? Attitudes towards voting rights expansion among sedentary nationals in Europe
- Education as identity? A meta-analysis of education-based in-group preferences in candidate choice experiments
- Neighbors and visitors: impact of diversity on attitudes toward migrants
- The polarizing impact of numeracy, economic literacy, and science literacy on attitudes toward immigration
- Do integration policies relate to economic and cultural threat perceptions? A comparative study in Europe
- Diverse Effects of Mass Media on Concerns about Immigration: New Evidence from Germany, 2001–2016
- Do first-generation immigrant scholars outperform native researchers? Evidence from US business schools
- Doctors with borders: occupational licensing as an implicit barrier to high skill migration
- Do Concerns about Immigration Change after Adolescence? How Education and Critical Life Events Affect Concerns about Immigration
- Moralizing Immigration: Political Framing, Moral Conviction, and Polarization in the United States and Denmark
- Real World is Not Enough: The Media as an Additional Source of Negative Attitudes Toward Immigration, Comparing Denmark and the Netherlands
- No country for young people? The rise of anti-immigration politics in ageing societies
- The Polarizing Effect of Anti-Immigrant Violence on Radical Right Sympathies in Germany
- Mirror, Mirror on the Wall: How Social Projection and Social Sampling Interact in the Formation of Public Opinion Perceptions
- Skill of the immigrants and vote of the natives: Immigration and nationalism in European elections 2007–2016
- Identification of Causal Diffusion Effects Under Structural Stationarity
- Network Analysis of Attitudes towards Immigrants in Asia
- Immigration in American Economic History
- Party Identification, Contact, Contexts, and Public Attitudes toward Illegal Immigration
- Crime Story: The role of crime and immigration in the anti-immigration vote
- Construction, Robustness Assessment and Application of an Index of Perceived Level of Socio-Economic Threat from Immigrants: A Study of 47 European Countries and Regions
- The Behavioral Immune System Shapes Political Intuitions: Why and How Individual Differences in Disgust Sensitivity Underlie Opposition to Immigration
- Economic and Cultural Drivers of Immigrant Support Worldwide
- What’s left unsaid? In-group solidarity and ethnic and racial differences in opposition to immigration in the United States
- Public Attitudes Toward Immigration
- Economic Explanations for Opposition to Immigration: Distinguishing between Prevalence and Conditional Impact
- Sources of Negative Attitudes toward Immigrants in Europe: A Multi-Level Analysis
- The Effects of 9/11 on Attitudes toward Immigration and the Moderating Role of Education
- Boundaries of Solidarity: Immigrants, Economic Contributions, and Welfare Attitudes
- Has Opposition to Immigration Increased in the United States after the Economic Crisis? An Experimental Approach
- Intergenerational Correlations of Extreme Right‐Wing Party Preferences and Attitudes toward Immigration
- What Is Islamophobia? Disentangling Citizenss Feelings Towards Ethnicity, Religion and Religiosity Using a Survey Experiment
- Skill of the Immigrants and Vote of the Natives: Immigration and Nationalism in European Elections 2007-2016
- WHY SWISS-GERMANS DISLIKE GERMANS
- Attitudes toward Highly Skilled and Low-skilled Immigration: Evidence from a Survey Experiment
- Left-Wing Xenophobia in Europe
- Opposition to immigration [wikipedia]
- Development of anti-immigrant attitudes in adolescence: The role of parents, peers, intergroup friendships, and empathy. [europepmc]
- Americans preferred Syrian refugees who are female, English-speaking, and Christian on the eve of Donald Trump's election. [europepmc]
- Attitudes towards Immigration among Students in the First Year of a Nursing Degree at Universities in Coimbra, Toledo and Melilla. [europepmc]
- Left-Wing Xenophobia in Europe. [europepmc]
- Austerity, Short-term Economic Recovery and Public Perception of Immigration in Ireland. [europepmc]
- Labour market institutions and immigration policy attitudes: The moderated impact of economic vulnerability. [europepmc]
- Educational Mobility and Attitudes Towards Migration from an International Comparative Perspective. [europepmc]
- Demystifying the link between higher education and liberal values: A within-sibship analysis of British individuals' attitudes from 1994-2020. [europepmc]
- Social media, education, and the rise of populist Euroscepticism. [europepmc]
- Different names, different discrimination? How perceptions of names can explain rental discrimination. [europepmc]
- The role of personality, authoritarianism and cognition in the United Kingdom's 2016 referendum on European Union membership. [europepmc]
- The Role of Income in System Justification. [europepmc]
- Attitudes toward immigration in Europe: Cross-regional differences. [europepmc]
- Does educational attainment matter for attitudes toward immigrants in Chile? Assessing the causality and generalizability of higher education's so-called "liberalizing effect" on economic and cultural threat. [europepmc]
- How Income and Discrimination Shape the Acceptance of Newcomers in Europe: A Comparative Analysis of Native-Born and Immigrant Populations. [europepmc]
- Revisiting the role of education in attitudes toward immigration in different contexts in Europe. [europepmc]
- The delusive economy: how information and affect colour perceptions of national economic performance. [europepmc]
- The Effect of Attitudes toward Immigration on Support for COVID-19 Mitigation Policies in Immigration Detention Centers in the United States [europepmc]
Related