2026/08/02 by Montek Singh Gill
Mathematics · #math.GT #msc:57K30 #msc:57K32 #msc:57K35 #msc:57M50 #msc:57M05 #msc:20E26
16 pages
arxiv created 2026/08/02 · arxiv updated 2026/08/04
The fundamental groups of compact 3-manifolds are known to be residually finite. Feng Luo conjectured that a stronger statement is true, by only allowing finite groups of the form PGL(2,R), where R is a finite commutative ring. In earlier work, this conjecture was disproven in full generality. The conjecture arose in the context of orientable connected compact 3-manifolds which are geometrizable. By constructing explicit faithful linear representations using rings with nilpotent elements, we demonstrate that the conjecture holds for six of the eight Thurston model geometries, namely all but \mathbbS3 and \widetildeSL2. In the case of \mathbbS3, the conjecture holds if we replace PGL(2,R) with GL(2,R). A spherical counterexample for the projective variant is the Poincaré homology sphere Σ(2,3,5). In the case of \widetildeSL2, the conjecture fails to hold for both the projective and non-projective variants; a counterxample is provided by the Brieskorn sphere Σ(2,3,7).