Conceptualizing from the Inside: Advantages, Complications, and Demands on Insider Positionality

2015/01/14 by Christina Chavez, Christina Chávez · 8 citations
Social Sciences · #Focus Groups and Qualitative Methods #Participatory Visual Research Methods #Qualitative Research Methods and Ethics

paper · pdf · doi:10.46743/2160-3715/2008.1589

openalex publication_date 2015/01/14 · openalex created_date 2025/10/10 · openalex updated_date 2026/07/29

Abstract

The debate on insider/outsider positionality has raised issues about the methodological advantages and liabilities between the two, yet no clear account exists for what insider scholars can expect when they enter the field. First, I conceptualize how insider positionality can dually benefit and disadvantage the insider. Using a partial review of insider studies, including my study of my multigenerational Mexican American family, I also present a practical discussion on specific insider advantages and complications. In conclusion, I present a new approach to training novice insider scholars that will help them mediate between insider perspective and researcher position, an approach that promises greater rigor to insider research that will serve the goals of qualitative research for social justice in minority and indigenous communities.

Citations

• The Lives and Values of Researchers: Implications for Educating Citizens in a Multicultural Society

Cited by

• Institutional entrepreneurship and the negotiation and blending of multiple logics in the Southern Arizona local food system
• The Moral Labour of Legitimacy: Recognition, Misrecognition and Entrepreneurial Evaluation in Racialised Markets
• Presumed identities perceived difference: how children of South Asian Indian immigrants experience and negotiate being an American
• A systematic review of socioecological factors, community violence exposure, and disparities for Latinx youth
• Negotiating the insider–outsider dilemma in urban research: Experiences of a graduate student returning home for fieldwork
• Telling their own stories: Māori entrepreneurship in the mainstream screen industry
• Methodological Reflections for Qualitative Research with Older Migrants: Focusing on Chinese-heritage Grandparents in New Zealand
• Queer Roma

Related

• Outsider Championship of Insider Research: A Collaborative Approach to Community Engaged Research in Cross-Cultural Settings.
• Becoming an Insider: Positionality, Ethics, and Methods in a Turn to Institutional Ethnography in China
• The Emotional and Psychological Labor of Insider Qualitative Research Among Systemically Marginalized Groups: Revisiting the Uses of Reflexivity
• Elite Interviewing as an In-Betweener
• ‘Insiderness’ in my Pilot Study Research