Sampling biases shape our view of the natural world
2021/06/21 by Alice C. Hughes, Michael C. Orr, Keping Ma +7 · 52 citations
Environmental Science · Biochemistry, Genetics and Molecular Biology · #Species Distribution and Climate Change #Genetic diversity and population structure #Wildlife Ecology and Conservation
paper · pdf · doi:10.1111/ecog.05926
Abstract
Spatial patterns of biodiversity are inextricably linked to their collection methods, yet no synthesis of bias patterns or their consequences exists. As such, views of organismal distribution and the ecosystems they make up may be incorrect, undermining countless ecological and evolutionary studies. Using 742 million records of 374 900 species, we explore the global patterns and impacts of biases related to taxonomy, accessibility, ecotype and data type across terrestrial and marine systems. Pervasive sampling and observation biases exist across animals, with only 6.74% of the globe sampled, and disproportionately poor tropical sampling. High elevations and deep seas are particularly unknown. Over 50% of records in most groups account for under 2% of species and citizen‐science only exacerbates biases. Additional data will be needed to overcome many of these biases, but we must increasingly value data publication to bridge this gap and better represent species' distributions from more distant and inaccessible areas, and provide the necessary basis for conservation and management.
Citations
Cited by
- Completeness analysis for over 3000 United States bee species identifies persistent data gap
- Patterns and Drivers of Knowledge Gaps in Global Databases of Mammal Traits
- Contrasting effects of protected areas on understory plant diversity in broadleaved deciduous forests
- Global research priorities for historical ecology to inform conservation
- Crossing borders: Connectivity analyses reveal potential patterns of range expansion of the Northern raccoon in Europe
- Capability of big data to capture threatened vertebrate diversity in protected areas
- <scp>EuPPollNet</scp>: A European Database of Plant‐Pollinator Networks
- GBIF information is not enough: national database improves the inventory completeness of Amazonian epiphytes
- Drivers of species knowledge across the Tree of Life
- Developing lists of alien taxa in the Global South
- How to Identify Priority Sites for Invasive Alien Species Policy and Management
- Mobilisation of data from natural history collections can increase the quality and coverage of biodiversity information
- Gaps and biases in vertebrate wildlife genetics from a global biodiversity hotspot
- Exploring the impact of data curation criteria on the observed geographical distribution of mosses
- <scp>FISHGLOB</scp> : A collaborative infrastructure to bridge the gap between scientific monitoring and marine biodiversity conservation
- A Global, Taxon‐Stratified, High‐Resolution Sampling‐Effort Dataset From <scp>GBIF</scp> for Bias‐Aware Ecological Modelling
- Migratory species strongly affect seabird biomass in seasonal assemblages off northeast Aotearoa/New Zealand
- When Good Fit Goes Bad: Identifying and Minimising Overfitting in Ecological Niche Models
- BON in a Box: An Open and Collaborative Platform for Biodiversity Monitoring, Indicator Calculation, and Reporting
- A Threat‐Scoring Framework Using Crowdsourced Data Indicates High Threat Levels in Fossorial Shieldtail Snakes
- Geographic biases undermine environmental representativeness of European biodiversity data
- Mapping ignorance to uncover shortfalls in the knowledge on global Orthoptera distribution
- Combining Distribution Models of Plants and Their Mutualists to Map Gaps in the Knowledge of Ecological Interactions
- Worldwide Soundscapes: A Synthesis of Passive Acoustic Monitoring Across Realms
- The global distribution patterns of alien vertebrate richness in mountains
- Global Conservation Prioritisation Approach Provides Credible Results at a Regional Scale
- Does urbanization impact terrestrial vertebrate ectotherms across a biodiversity hotspot?
- When accessibility distorts niche estimates: A virtual species framework across species prevalence and sample size gradients
- Biogeography and global flows of 100 major alien fungal and fungus‐like oomycete pathogens
- Flexible methods for species distribution modeling with small samples
- Scrutinizing the Wallacean shortfall: global gaps in snake occurrence data across space and environment
- Conservation data infrastructures: From carbon accounting to multiple biodiversity and social measures
- Open‐Source Marine Biodiversity Data Quality in the Norwegian Sea Spanning 149 Years: Knowledge Gaps in the Deep‐Sea Mining Opening Area
- A nature tourism and citizen science alliance
- Shallow coverage in shallow waters: the incompleteness of intertidal species inventories in biodiversity database records
- An integrated species distribution modelling framework for heterogeneous biodiversity data
- Plant diversity darkspots for global collection priorities
- A DNA barcode reference library of terrestrial and freshwater molluscs of Catalonia, northeastern Iberian Peninsula
- Occurrence data and range maps in endemicity analysis: Data choice matters
- Projecting Climate‐Driven Habitat Loss in Highly Trafficked Lizards: The Role of Dispersal Limitations and Protected Areas
- <i>SeedArc</i>, a global archive of primary seed germination data
- Global trends and biases in biodiversity conservation research
- Coalescent-delimitation framework disentangles species boundaries within the Neotropical mouse-opossums subgenus <i>Marmosops</i>
- Beyond the various contrivances by which orchids are pollinated: global patterns in orchid pollination biology
- The abundance, biomass, and distribution of ants on Earth
- Neglected seed dispersers and research compartmentalisation: how much do we know about what we don't know?
- Geopolitical impacts on the description of new terrestrial mollusc species
- Incorporating sampling bias into ENM/SDM permutation tests: new methods and a case study on neotropical ants
- Mobilizing bibliographic, natural history collections and citizen science data for addressing biodiversity biases: A case study with the herpetofauna of an endemic rich island nation
- European colonial empires accelerated ant invasions
- Environment, Society, and Machine Learning
- Priorities for conservation rely heavily on discovery and assessments
Related