Measurement Matters
2015/05/01 by Angela L. Duckworth, Angela Duckworth, David Scott Yeager +1 · 49 citations
Psychology · #Grit, Self-Efficacy, and Motivation #Cognitive Abilities and Testing #Behavioral Health and Interventions
paper · doi:10.3102/0013189x15584327
Abstract
There has been perennial interest in personal qualities other than cognitive ability that determine success, including self-control, grit, growth mind-set, and many others. Attempts to measure such qualities for the purposes of educational policy and practice, however, are more recent. In this article, we identify serious challenges to doing so. We first address confusion over terminology, including the descriptor noncognitive. We conclude that debate over the optimal name for this broad category of personal qualities obscures substantial agreement about the specific attributes worth measuring. Next, we discuss advantages and limitations of different measures. In particular, we compare self-report questionnaires, teacher-report questionnaires, and performance tasks, using self-control as an illustrative case study to make the general point that each approach is imperfect in its own way. Finally, we discuss how each measure’s imperfections can affect its suitability for program evaluation, accountability, individual diagnosis, and practice improvement. For example, we do not believe any available measure is suitable for between-school accountability judgments. In addition to urging caution among policymakers and practitioners, we highlight medium-term innovations that may make measures of these personal qualities more suitable for educational purposes.
Cited by
- Estimating social preferences using stated satisfaction: Novel support for inequity aversion
- Perceiving effort as poor learning: The misinterpreted-effort hypothesis of how experienced effort and perceived learning relate to study strategy choice
- The development of grit and growth mindset during adolescence
- Using wise interventions to motivate deliberate practice.
- Using design thinking to improve psychological interventions: The case of the growth mindset during the transition to high school.
- Teacher Effects on Complex Cognitive Skills and Social-Emotional Competencies
- Social and Emotional Learning: A Principled Science of Human Development in Context
- Growing Minds, Diverging Paths: Psychological Suzhi Trajectories and Adolescent Adjustment in China
- Construct Diversity in Measures of Helicopter Parenting in Emerging Adulthood
- Seeing eye to eye on student motivation: Moderators of student–teacher agreement
- Achievement Motivation and Academic Dishonesty: A Meta-Analytic Investigation
- Predictors and consequences of intellectual humility
- Associations Between Behavioral, Cognitive, and Emotional Self-Regulation and Academic and Social Outcomes Among Chinese Children: a Meta-analysis
- Teacher and Teaching Effects on Students’ Attitudes and Behaviors
- Artificial intelligence, 21st century competences, and socio‐emotional learning in education: More than high‐risk?
- Extracurricular activities and achievement growth in kindergarten through first grade: The mediating role of non-cognitive skills
- Artificial Intelligence and Education: End the Grammar of Schooling
- From Meritocracy to Human Interdependence: Redefining the Purpose of Education
- Rethinking Traditional Methods of Survey Validation
- The Death and Rebirth of Research in Education in the Age of AI: Problems and Promises
- What Matters for Students’ Learning? The Roles of Social and Emotional Skills and the Factors Affecting These Skills
- Development of working memory and inhibitory control in early childhood: Cross-sectional analysis by age intervals and gender in Ecuadorian preschoolers
- Advanced, Analytic, Automated (AAA) Measurement of Engagement During Learning
- Review of Grit and Resilience Literature within Health Professions Education
- Using Design Thinking to Improve Psychological Interventions: The Case of the Growth Mindset During the Transition to High School. [europepmc]
- Using wise interventions to motivate deliberate practice. [europepmc]
- Too much of a good thing? Exploring the inverted-U relationship between self-control and happiness. [europepmc]
- Teacher and Teaching Effects on Students' Attitudes and Behaviors. [europepmc]
- A tripartite taxonomy of character: Evidence for intrapersonal, interpersonal, and intellectual competencies in children. [europepmc]
- "Same but different": Associations between multiple aspects of self-regulation, cognition, and academic abilities. [europepmc]
- Grit as Predictor of Entrepreneurship and Self-Employment in Spain. [europepmc]
- Thinking in action: Need for Cognition predicts Self-Control together with Action Orientation. [europepmc]
- Longitudinal Associations Between Grit, Academic Outcomes, and Residency Match Rates Among Pharmacy Students. [europepmc]
- Cognitive and noncognitive predictors of success. [europepmc]
- Grit as Perseverance in Physical Activity Participation. [europepmc]
- The development of grit and growth mindset during adolescence. [europepmc]
- Fostering Grit: Perceived School Goal-Structure Predicts Growth in Grit and Grades. [europepmc]
- Beyond Passion and Perseverance: Review and Future Research Initiatives on the Science of Grit. [europepmc]
- Towards an Integrative Taxonomy of Social-Emotional Competences. [europepmc]
- National Evaluation of Surgical Resident Grit and the Association With Wellness Outcomes. [europepmc]
- Editorial: Do We Need Socio-Emotional Skills? [europepmc]
- Predictors and consequences of intellectual humility. [europepmc]
- The Development of Cognitive Reappraisal From Early Childhood Through Adolescence: A Systematic Review and Methodological Recommendations. [europepmc]
- Large studies reveal how reference bias limits policy applications of self-report measures. [europepmc]
- The changes we need: Education post COVID-19. [europepmc]
- College Students' Sense of Belonging: A National Perspective. [europepmc]
- Executive Functions in Social Context: Implications for Conceptualizing, Measuring, and Supporting Developmental Trajectories. [europepmc]
- Genetic associations between non-cognitive skills and academic achievement over development. [europepmc]
- Exploring the interplay of academic stress, motivation, emotional intelligence, and mindfulness in higher education: a longitudinal cross-lagged panel model approach. [europepmc]
Related