An Expanded Derivation of the Threshold Structure of the Polytomous Rasch Model That Dispels Any “Threshold Disorder Controversy”

2012/07/30 by David Andrich · 118 citations
Decision Sciences · Mathematics · Psychology · Social Sciences · #Artificial intelligence #Bernoulli's principle #Cognitive psychology #Computer science #Developmental psychology #Econometrics #Empirical research #Epistemology #Inference #Interpretation (philosophy) #Item response theory #Mathematical economics #Mathematics #Philosophy #Polytomous Rasch model #Probabilistic logic #Property (philosophy) #Psychology #Psychometric Methodologies and Testing #Psychometrics #Rasch model #Reliability and Agreement in Measurement #School Choice and Performance #Statistics #Variable (mathematics)

paper · doi:10.1177/0013164412450877

published in Educational and Psychological Measurement 73(1), 78-124 (SAGE Publishing)

openalex publication_date 2012/07/30 · openalex created_date 2025/10/10 · openalex updated_date 2026/07/29

Abstract

Responses to items with formats in more than two ordered categories are ubiquitous in education and the social sciences. Because the putative ordering of the categories reflects an understanding of what it means to have more of the variable, it seems mandatory that the ordering of the categories is an empirical property of the assessments and not merely a property of the model used to analyze them. To provide an unequivocal interpretation of category ordering in rating formats, this article expands the original derivation of the polytomous Rasch model for ordered categories. To do so, it integrates a complex of mathematical relationships among response spaces from which a space of experimentally independent Bernoulli variables, characterized by Rasch’s simple logistic model, can be inferred. From this inference, the article establishes the necessary and sufficient evidence to test the hypothesis that the required ordering of the categories is an empirical property of the assessments. This expanded derivation, which exposes how Adams, Wu, and Wilson (2012) misconstrue the model and its implications, is intended to dispel the so-called disordered threshold controversy they claim exists.

Cited by

• Tree-Based Global Model Tests for Polytomous Rasch Models
• A Taxonomy of Polytomous Item Response Models
• Evaluating Item Response Format and Content Using Partial Credit Trees in Scale Development
• Assessing psychopathy among justice involved adolescents with the PCL:YV: an item response theory examination across gender. [europepmc]
• Validity of personality measurement in adults with anxiety disorders: psychometric properties of the Spanish NEO-FFI-R using Rasch analyses. [europepmc]
• Development of an item bank for the EORTC Role Functioning Computer Adaptive Test (EORTC RF-CAT). [europepmc]
• Using Patient-Reported Outcome Measures (PROMs) to promote quality of care and safety in the management of patients with Advanced Chronic Kidney disease (PRO-trACK project): a mixed-methods project protocol. [europepmc]
• The Screen for Cognitive Impairment in Psychiatry: Proposal for a polytomous scoring system. [europepmc]
• Method of successive dichotomizations: An improved method for estimating measures of latent variables from rating scale data. [europepmc]
• State of the psychometric methods: comments on the ISOQOL SIG psychometric papers. [europepmc]
• Specific Measures of Quality of Life in Patients with Multimorbidity in Primary Healthcare: A Systematic Review on Patient-Reported Outcome Measures' Adequacy of Measurement. [europepmc]
• Investigating psychometric properties of the Thai version of the Zarit Burden Interview using rasch model and confirmatory factor analysis. [europepmc]
• Order-Constrained Estimation of Nominal Response Model Parameters to Assess the Empirical Order of Categories. [europepmc]
• Illuminating the complexities of conflict with evolution: validation of the scales of evolutionary conflict measure (SECM). [europepmc]
• Next of kin participation in the care of older persons in nursing homes: A pre-post non-randomised educational evaluation, using within-group and individual person-level comparisons. [europepmc]
• An item analysis according to the Rasch model of the German 12-item WHO Disability Assessment Schedule (WHODAS 2.0). [europepmc]
• Rasch analysis for development and reduction of Symptom Questionnaire for Visual Dysfunctions (SQVD). [europepmc]
• Development and validation of a self-reported questionnaire to assess occupational balance in parents of preterm infants. [europepmc]
• Examination of validity, reliability, and interpretability of a self-reported questionnaire on Occupational Balance in Informal Caregivers (OBI-Care) - A Rasch analysis. [europepmc]
• Associations between occupational balance, subjective health, and well-being of informal caregivers of older persons based on a cross-sectional study. [europepmc]
• Psychometric evaluation of the Positive Mental Health (PMH) scale using item response theory. [europepmc]
• Novel insights regarding the measurement properties of the SCOPA-AUT. [europepmc]
• The Rasch Analysis Shows Poor Construct Validity and Low Reliability of the Quebec User Evaluation of Satisfaction with Assistive Technology 2.0 (QUEST 2.0) Questionnaire. [europepmc]
• Differential Item Functioning of the Mini-BESTest Balance Measure: A Rasch Analysis Study. [europepmc]
• Application of the Rasch measurement model in rehabilitation research and practice: early developments, current practice, and future challenges. [europepmc]
• Measuring Quality of Life in Adults with Scoliosis: A Cross-Sectional Study Comparing SRS-22 and ISYQOL Questionnaires. [europepmc]
• Detecting Rating Scale Malfunctioning With the Partial Credit Model and Generalized Partial Credit Model. [europepmc]
• Validity of the Arabic Version of the PROMIS Anxiety and PROMIS Depression in Cancer Questionnaires: Measuring Depression and Anxiety in Oncologic Patients in Saudi Arabia-A Rasch Analysis Study. [europepmc]

Related

• On the Structure of Ordered Latent Trait Models
• A Rasch Model for Partial Credit Scoring
• Measuring agreement among several raters classifying subjects into one or more (hierarchical) categories: A generalization of Fleiss' kappa
• Item Response Thresholds Models
• Extended Rasch Modeling: The eRm Package for the Application of IRT Models in R