Macroeconomics and Reality

1980/01/01 by Christopher A. Sims · 117 citations
Economics, Econometrics and Finance · #Monetary Policy and Economic Impact #Economic theories and models #Complex Systems and Time Series Analysis

paper · doi:10.2307/1912017

Abstract

Existing strategies for econometric analysis related to macroeconomics are subject to a number of serious objections, some recently formulated, some old. These objections are summarized in this paper, and it is argued that taken together they make it unlikely that macroeconomic models are in fact over identified, as the existing statistical theory usually assumes. The implications of this conclusion are explored, and an example of econometric work in a non-standard style, taking account of the objections to the standard style, is presented. THE STUDY OF THE BUSINESS cycle, fluctuations in aggregate measures of economic activity and prices over periods from one to ten years or so, constitutes or motivates a large part of what we call macroeconomics. Most economists would agree that there are many macroeconomic variables whose cyclical fluctuations are of interest, and would agree further that fluctuations in these series are interrelated. It would seem to follow almost tautologically that statistical models involving large numbers of macroeconomic variables ought to be the arena within which macroeconomic theories confront reality and thereby each other. Instead, though large-scale statistical macroeconomic models exist and are by some criteria successful, a deep vein of skepticism about the value of these models runs through that part of the economics profession not actively engaged in constructing or using them. It is still rare for empirical research in macroeconomics to be planned and executed within the framework of one of the large models. In this lecture I intend to discuss some aspects of this situation, attempting both to offer some explanations and to suggest some means for improvement. I will argue that the style in which their builders construct claims for a connection between these models and reality-the style in which is achieved for these models-is inappropriate, to the point at which claims for identification in these models cannot be taken seriously. This is a venerable assertion; and there are some good old reasons for believing it;2 but there are also some reasons which have been more recently put forth. After developing the conclusion that the identification claimed for existing large-scale models is incredible, I will discuss what ought to be done in consequence. The line of argument is: large-scale models do perform useful forecasting and policy-analysis functions despite their incredible identification; the restrictions imposed in the usual style of identification are neither essential to constructing a model which can perform these functions nor innocuous; an alternative style of identification is available and practical. Finally we will look at some empirical work based on an alternative style of macroeconometrics. A six-variable dynamic system is estimated without using 1 Research for this paper was supported by NSF Grant Soc-76-02482. Lars Hansen executed the computations. The paper has benefited from comments by many people, especially Thomas J. Sargent

Cited by

• Estimation and Inference of Impulse Responses by Local Projections
• The macroeconomic effects of public debt: an empirical analysis of Mozambique
• Potential early phase success and ultimate failure of economic sanctions
• Postwar U.S. Business Cycles: An Empirical Investigation
• The Impact of the Volatility of Monetary Policy Shocks
• Reciprocity, Triangularity, and Cooperation in the Middle East, 1979-97
• Fiscal shocks and their consequences
• Cointegration Tests of the Monetary Exchange Rate Model for Three High-Inflation Economies
• A Time‐Series Model of Interest Rates with the Effective Lower Bound
• Happiness Begets Money: Emotion and Engagement in Live Streaming
• Effects of Monetary and Macroprudential Policies—Evidence from Four Inflation Targeting Economies
• From a Quantity to an Interest Rate‐Based Framework: Multiple Monetary Policy Instruments and Their Effects in China
• Causal Effects of Monetary Shocks: Semiparametric Conditional Independence Tests with a Multinomial Propensity Score
• Impulse Response Estimation by Smooth Local Projections
• Ideology Justifies Morality: Political Beliefs Predict Moral Foundations
• From Vector Autoregressions to AI-based Time Series Forecasting: A Review
• Price determination in the EU ETS market: Theory and econometric analysis with market fundamentals
• A scalable estimator of higher-order information in complex dynamical systems
• Size isn't everything: Understanding the relationship between police workforce and crime problems
• Do the benefits outweigh the disadvantages? Exploring the role of artificial intelligence in renewable energy
• Reduced-Rank Covariance Estimation in Vector Autoregressive Modeling
• Confidence intervals for parameters in high-dimensional sparse vector autoregression
• Estimation of Causal Invertible VARMA Models
• COPAR - Multivariate time series modeling using the COPula AutoRegressive model
• srvar-toolkit: A Python Implementation of Shadow-Rate Vector Autoregressions with Stochastic Volatility
• Forecasting and stress testing with quantile vector autoregression
• Principled Identification of Structural Dynamic Models
• Effects of Climate Change on Moroccan Coastal Upwelling: Relationships between the NAO, Upwelling Index, and Sea Surface Temperature (1978-2024)
• Bayesian estimation of large dimensional time varying VARs using copulas
• chatter: a Python library for applying information theory and AI/ML models to animal communication
• Analysis of Contagion in China's Stock Market: A Hawkes Process Perspective
• Change Point Detection for Functional Autoregressive Processes on the Sphere
• Early-Warning Signals of Political Risk in Stablecoin Markets: Human and Algorithmic Behavior Around the 2024 U.S. Election
• Time Series Forecasting via Direct Per-Step Probability Distribution Modeling
• Order Selection in Vector Autoregression by Mean Square Information Criterion
• Estimation of High-dimensional Nonlinear Vector Autoregressive Models
• Steady‐state priors for vector autoregressions
• High Dimensional Forecasting via Interpretable Vector Autoregression
• Explaining Europe’s transformed electoral landscape: structure, salience, and agendas
• Local projections vs. VARs: Lessons from thousands of DGPs
• Causal Discovery from Conditionally Stationary Time Series
• Estimation of Independent Component Analysis Systems
• Hydra: Dual Exponentiated Memory for Multivariate Time Series Analysis
• Inside the Black Box: The Credit Channel of Monetary Policy Transmission
• In search of a new economic model determined by logistic growth
• Cross-Validatory Model Selection for Bayesian Autoregressions with Exogenous Regressors
• Rigour versus the need for evidential diversity
• Vector Autoregressions
• The UK housing market and the monetary policy transmission mechanism: An SVAR approach
• Structured Estimation of Heterogeneous Time Series
• A Cross-Domain Approach to Analyzing the Short-Run Impact of COVID-19 on the U.S. Electricity Sector
• Responses to Monetary Policy Shocks in the East and West of Europe: A Comparison
• Like the ad or the brand? Marketing stimulates different electronic word-of-mouth content to drive online and offline performance
• Exploration of the Parameter Space in Macroeconomic Agent-Based Models
• Group Interventions on Deep Networks for Causal Discovery in Subsystems
• The causal interpretation of panel vector autoregressions
• A Multi-Layer Machine Learning and Econometric Pipeline for Forecasting Market Risk: Evidence from Cryptoasset Liquidity Spillovers
• Forecasting with Bayesian Panel Vector Autoregressions Using the R Package bpvars
• Toward Reasoning-Centric Time-Series Analysis
• Non-Normal Eigenvector Amplification in Multi-Dimensional Kesten Processes
• Backward-in-Time Selection of the Order of Dynamic Regression Prediction\n Model
• Dynamical Systems Models for Market Evolution: A Mechanistic Alternative to Autoregressive Methods
• Optimal participation of energy communities in electricity markets under uncertainty. A multi-stage stochastic programming approach
• Stock market sensitivities to European monetary policy
• Coupling causality and interpretable machine learning to reveal the reaction coordinate of C–N coupling with a supramolecular Cu-calix[8]arene catalyst
• Modeling Women’s Need For Action in Violent Relationships
• Bayesian Vector Autoregressions
• Shadow Rate Models and Monetary Policy
• A deep learning-based method for deep soil salinity prediction: considering the driving mechanisms of salinity profiles
• Regularized estimation in sparse high-dimensional time series models
• Power play: The agenda dynamics of the United States president, House of Representatives, and Senate
• Forecasting in small open emerging economies Evidence from Thailand
• Local Projections and VARs Estimate the Same Impulse Responses
• Community-level Contagion among Diverse Financial Assets
• Relation between regional uncertainty spillovers in the global banking system
• Geometric Dynamics of Consumer Credit Cycles: A Multivector-based Linear-Attention Framework for Explanatory Economic Analysis
• The death of laparoscopy
• Real-E: A Foundation Benchmark for Advancing Robust and Generalizable Electricity Forecasting
• Rethinking Beta: A Causal Take on CAPM
• Causal mechanism and mediation analysis for macroeconomics dynamics: a bridge of Granger and Sims causality
• Exploring Trade Openness and Logistics Efficiency in the G20 Economies: A Bootstrap ARDL Analysis of Growth Dynamics
• Quantum-Optimized Selective State Space Model for Efficient Time Series Prediction
• The Scientific Illusion in Empirical Macroeconomics
• Bias-Adjusted LLM Agents for Human-Like Decision-Making via Behavioral Economics
• Non-parametric Causal Discovery for EU Allowances Returns Through the Information Imbalance
• An International Dynamic Asset Pricing Model
• Ergodicity bounds in the Sliced Wasserstein distance for Schur stable autoregressive processes
• Comparative Analysis of Time Series Foundation Models for Demographic Forecasting: Enhancing Predictive Accuracy in US Population Dynamics
• Estimating causal effects from panel data with dynamic multivariate panel models
• Comparative Analysis of Time Series Transformers on Multivariate Time Series Data
• Forecasting with time-varying vector autoregressive models
• Distributionally Robust Optimization with Correlated Data from Vector Autoregressive Processes
• Learning causal networks from systems biology time course data: an effective model selection procedure for the vector autoregressive process. [europepmc]
• Urbanization and Income Inequality in Post-Reform China: A Causal Analysis Based on Time Series Data. [europepmc]
• Nonlinear Granger Causality between Health Care Expenditure and Economic Growth in the OECD and Major Developing Countries. [europepmc]
• Copula directional dependence for inference and statistical analysis of whole-brain connectivity from fMRI data. [europepmc]
• PM 2.5 Pollution and Inhibitory Effects on Industry Development: A Bidirectional Correlation Effect Mechanism. [europepmc]
• Age-Period-Cohort Analysis on the Time Trend of Hepatitis B Incidence in Four Prefectures of Southern Xinjiang, China from 2005 to 2017. [europepmc]
• Non-linear Impact of China's Economic Growth on the Health of Residents-An Empirical Study Based on TVP-FAVAR Model. [europepmc]
• Construction, comparison and evolution of networks in life sciences and other disciplines. [europepmc]
• Multifractal signatures of perceptual processing on anatomical sleeves of the human body. [europepmc]
• Volcanic activity controls cholera outbreaks in the East African Rift. [europepmc]
• On forecasting the community-level COVID-19 cases from the concentration of SARS-CoV-2 in wastewater. [europepmc]
• COVID-19 and airline employment: Insights from historical uncertainty shocks to the industry. [europepmc]
• Shipping markets in turmoil: An analysis of the Covid-19 outbreak and its implications. [europepmc]
• Deep learning of contagion dynamics on complex networks. [europepmc]
• Correlation between the Level of Social Distancing and Activity of Influenza Epidemic or COVID-19 Pandemic: A Subway Use-Based Assessment. [europepmc]
• The asymmetric and multi-scale volatility correlation between global oil price and economic policy uncertainty of China. [europepmc]
• Quantification of the effects of climatic conditions on French hospital admissions and deaths induced by SARS-CoV-2. [europepmc]
• Dynamic spillovers between the term structure of interest rates, bitcoin, and safe-haven currencies. [europepmc]
• Rigour versus the need for evidential diversity. [europepmc]
• Granger Causality Analysis of Chignolin Folding. [europepmc]
• A study on the interaction between logistics industry and manufacturing industry from the perspective of integration field. [europepmc]
• The Impact of Coordinated Development of Ecological Environment and Technological Innovation on Green Economy: Evidence from China. [europepmc]
• Environmental pollution and economic growth: Evidence of SO 2 emissions and GDP in China. [europepmc]
• Inference of dynamic interaction networks: A comparison between Lotka-Volterra and multivariate autoregressive models. [europepmc]
• Analysis of the Effectiveness of Public Health Measures on COVID-19 Transmission. [europepmc]

Related

• Complexity, causality, and expectations: Why macroeconomics needs a program of empirical microfoundations
• Empirical Macroeconomics and DSGE Modeling in Statistical Perspective
• Random walks and non-linear paths in macroeconomic time series. Some evidence and implications.
• The problems of macroeconomics as institutional problems: complementing the ‘what went wrong’ story with a social epistemology perspective
• The Scientific Illusion in Empirical Macroeconomics