PERMANOVA, ANOSIM, and the Mantel test in the face of heterogeneous dispersions: What null hypothesis are you testing?
2013/11/01 by Marti J. Anderson, Daniel C. I. Walsh · 55 citations
Environmental Science · #Species Distribution and Climate Change #Ecology and Vegetation Dynamics Studies #Wildlife Ecology and Conservation
paper · doi:10.1890/12-2010.1
Abstract
ANOSIM, PERMANOVA, and the Mantel test are all resemblance‐based permutation methods widely used in ecology. Here, we report the results of the first simulation study, to our knowledge, specifically designed to examine the effects of heterogeneity of multivariate dispersions on the rejection rates of these tests and on a classical MANOVA test (Pillai's trace). Increasing differences in dispersion among groups were simulated under scenarios of changing sample sizes, correlation structures, error distributions, numbers of variables, and numbers of groups for balanced and unbalanced one‐way designs. The power of these tests to detect environmental impacts or natural large‐scale biogeographic gradients was also compared empirically under simulations based on parameters derived from real ecological data sets. Overall, ANOSIM and the Mantel test were very sensitive to heterogeneity in dispersions, with ANOSIM generally being more sensitive than the Mantel test. In contrast, PERMANOVA and Pillai's trace were largely unaffected by heterogeneity for balanced designs. PERMANOVA was also unaffected by differences in correlation structure, unlike Pillai's trace. For unbalanced designs, however, all of the tests were (1) too liberal when the smaller group had greater dispersion and (2) overly conservative when the larger group had greater dispersion, especially ANOSIM and the Mantel test. For simulations based on real ecological data sets, PERMANOVA was generally, but not always, more powerful than the others to detect changes in community structure, and the Mantel test was usually more powerful than ANOSIM. Both the error distributions and the resemblance measure affected results concerning power. Differences in the underlying construction of these test statistics result in important differences in the nature of the null hypothesis they are testing, their sensitivity to heterogeneity, and their power to detect important changes in ecological communities. For balanced designs, PERMANOVA and PERMDISP can be used to rigorously identify location vs. dispersion effects, respectively, in the space of the chosen resemblance measure. ANOSIM and the Mantel test can be used as more “omnibus” tests, being sensitive to differences in location, dispersion or correlation structure among groups. Unfortunately, none of the tests (PERMANOVA, Mantel, or ANOSIM) behaved reliably for unbalanced designs in the face of heterogeneity.
Citations
Cited by
- Root traits correlate with crop rhizosphere microbiome diversity independent of legume relatedness
- A hyper‐arid environment shapes an inverse pattern of the fast–slow plant economics spectrum for above‐, but not below‐ground resource acquisition strategies
- Substrate- and life habit-induced morphological convergence and divergence in Recent marine bivalve communities
- Forest clear‐cuts support diverse moth fauna but lack common grassland species
- Temporal Shifts in Biological Community Structure in Response to Wetland Restoration: Implications for Wetland Biodiversity Conservation and Management
- Intra-annual consistent diet of lanternfish and krill in adult female southern elephant seals Mirounga leonina from the South Georgia population
- Meiofauna assemblages in and around the Aleutian Trench, with focus on Harpacticoida (Copepoda)
- The Effect of Thermal Stress on the Physiology and Bacterial Communities of Two Key Mediterranean Gorgonians
- Depth-stratified community structure of Beaufort Sea slope zooplankton and its relations to water masses
- Pesticide-free fields under minimum tillage and flower strips enhance carabid beetles and spiders through increased overwintering and spill over processes
- Regional contrasts in environmental conditions associated with retrogressive thaw slumps across the Arctic and the Qinghai-Tibetan Plateau
- Connection over creation: hydrological connectivity drives post-restoration community assembly in coastal ponds
- Planting food forests can increase soil biodiversity in agricultural landscapes of Northwest Europe
- Does browning‐induced light limitation reduce fish body growth through shifts in prey composition or reduced foraging rates?
- Diurnal temperature range drives understory plant community composition in micro-climatically complex temperate montane forests
- Fish species composition reflects geomorphology in the Western Amazon, the Earth's vertebrate biodiversity hotspot
- Spatial and temporal comparisons of salt marsh soil fungal communities following the deepwater horizon spill
- Seabird-vectored pelagic nutrients integrated into temperate intertidal rocky shores
- Large‐scale changes in macrobenthic biodiversity driven by mangrove afforestation
- Context‐dependent forest elephant seed dispersal: implications for pathways of elephant‐driven patterns of biodiversity and carbon storage
- Symbiodiniaceae diversity in Pocillopora corals in different environments of the Colombian Eastern Pacific: symbiont specificity in spite of coral-host flexibility
- Global distribution of deep-sea natural products shows environmental and phylogenetic undersampling with potential for biodiscovery
- Amplicon sequencing reveals the cryptic diversity in the dicyemid parasites of coleoid cephalopods sampled from the Atlantic and Pacific Oceans
- Aquatic <scp>eDNA</scp> outperforms sedimentary <scp>eDNA</scp> for the detection of estuarine fish communities in subtropical coastal vegetated ecosystems
- Subtle diurnal microbial rhythms in a large mammalian carnivore
- Host Plant Switching and Viral Infections Reshape the Microbiome of the Aphid Vector <i>Aphis gossypii</i>
- Lizard polymorphic throat colors are distinguishable by conspecifics and predators across variable light environments
- Vibroacoustic signalling of the Maltese Messor ants (Hymenoptera, Formicidae), with geographical insights into M. ibericus
- Latent stress response in translocated eastern oysters (<i>Crassostrea virginica</i>) in the Gulf of St. Lawrence
- Pollution gradient leads to local adaptation and small-scale spatial variability of communities and functions in an urban marine environment
- Demonstrating microbial co-occurrence pattern analyses within and between ecosystems. [europepmc]
- Normalization and microbial differential abundance strategies depend upon data characteristics. [europepmc]
- Gut Microbial Diversity Assessment of Indian Type-2-Diabetics Reveals Alterations in Eubacteria, Archaea, and Eukaryotes. [europepmc]
- Whole-Genome Sequencing of Drug-Resistant Salmonella enterica Isolates from Dairy Cattle and Humans in New York and Washington States Reveals Source and Geographic Associations. [europepmc]
- Microbial communities in sediment from Zostera marina patches, but not the Z. marina leaf or root microbiomes, vary in relation to distance from patch edge. [europepmc]
- Machine Learning Leveraging Genomes from Metagenomes Identifies Influential Antibiotic Resistance Genes in the Infant Gut Microbiome. [europepmc]
- Environmental Factors Support the Formation of Specific Bacterial Assemblages on Microplastics. [europepmc]
- Drinking water microbiome assembly induced by water stagnation. [europepmc]
- The gut microbiome is associated with behavioural task in honey bees. [europepmc]
- Strong succession in arbuscular mycorrhizal fungal communities. [europepmc]
- Differences in the Gut Microbiota Establishment and Metabolome Characteristics Between Low- and Normal-Birth-Weight Piglets During Early-Life. [europepmc]
- Characterization of Emetic and Diarrheal Bacillus cereus Strains From a 2016 Foodborne Outbreak Using Whole-Genome Sequencing: Addressing the Microbiological, Epidemiological, and Bioinformatic Challenges. [europepmc]
- Genetic risk for autoimmunity is associated with distinct changes in the human gut microbiome. [europepmc]
- The fecal resistome of dairy cattle is associated with diet during nursing. [europepmc]
- Fungal community assembly in drought-stressed sorghum shows stochasticity, selection, and universal ecological dynamics. [europepmc]
- QIIME 2 Enables Comprehensive End-to-End Analysis of Diverse Microbiome Data and Comparative Studies with Publicly Available Data. [europepmc]
- Metagenomic approaches in microbial ecology: an update on whole-genome and marker gene sequencing analyses. [europepmc]
- Influence of host genetics in shaping the rumen bacterial community in beef cattle. [europepmc]
- Important ecophysiological roles of non-dominant Actinobacteria in plant residue decomposition, especially in less fertile soils. [europepmc]
- Dietary Fiber Hierarchical Specificity: the Missing Link for Predictable and Strong Shifts in Gut Bacterial Communities. [europepmc]
- Microplastics accumulate fungal pathogens in terrestrial ecosystems. [europepmc]
- Deprivation of dietary fiber in specific-pathogen-free mice promotes susceptibility to the intestinal mucosal pathogen Citrobacter rodentium . [europepmc]
- The Power of Microbiome Studies: Some Considerations on Which Alpha and Beta Metrics to Use and How to Report Results. [europepmc]
- The global distribution and environmental drivers of the soil antibiotic resistome. [europepmc]
- Gut microbiome dysbiosis across early Parkinson's disease, REM sleep behavior disorder and their first-degree relatives. [europepmc]
Related