Audit Culture Revisited
2015/05/06 by Cris Shore, Susan Wright · 21 citations
Social Sciences · #Political and Economic history of UK and US #Public Policy and Administration Research
paper · pdf · doi:10.1086/681534
Abstract
The spread of the principles and techniques of financial accounting into new systems for measuring, ranking, and auditing performance represents one of the most important and defining features of contemporary governance. Audit procedures are redefining accountability, transparency, and good governance and reshaping the way organizations and individuals have to operate. They also undermine professional autonomy and have unanticipated and dysfunctional consequences. Taking up the concept of audit culture as an analytical framework, we examine the origins, spread, and rationality driving these new financialized techniques of governance, not least through the work of the Big Four accountancy firms, and trace their impact across a number of fields, from administration and the military to business corporations and universities. We ask, what new kinds of ethics of accountability does audit produce? Building on Mitchell (1999), Strathern (2000a), Trouillot (2001), and Merry (2011), we identify how the techniques and logics of financial accountancy have five audit effects. These are “domaining,” “classificatory,” “individualizing and totalizing,” “governance,” and “perverse” effects. We conclude by reflecting on the problems of audit culture and suggest ways to reclaim the professional values and democratic spaces that are being eroded by these new systems of governing by numbers.
Citations
Cited by
- The Past and Present of Peer Review in the Humanities: An Introduction
- On the menu: Academic managerialism and critical theory
- The (Anti)Microbial Gaze: Surveillance Meets Resistance
- Impossible, unknowable, accountable: Dramas and dilemmas of data law
- Doing the right thing, not just doing the thing right: the importance of explicitly ethical policy advice
- Asian Tricks and Research Misconduct: From Orientalism and Occidentalism to Solidarity against Audit Cultures
- Visualization of rank-citation curves for fast detection of h-index anomalies in university metrics
- ‘Homo Metricus’: The New Academic Worker. How Quantitative Research Evaluation Practices Reshape the Intellectual Capital Needed to Succeed in Contemporary Universities?
- Gaming the Data. How the Finnish School Audit Saved the Profession from New Public Management
- AI, the conflicted university, and the classroom
- Spreading the gospel: Legitimating university rankings as boundary work
- How Do Companies Respond to Environmental, Social and Governance (ESG) ratings? Evidence from Italy
- Global university rankings: Metrics, performance, governance
- Epidemiological accountability: philanthropists, global health and the audit of saving lives. [europepmc]
- How is the discourse of performance-based financing shaped at the global level? A poststructural analysis. [europepmc]
- Tackling land's 'stubborn materiality': the interplay of imaginaries, data and digital technologies within farmland assetization. [europepmc]
- The relational institution: an ethnographic study of recovery orientation and relational engagement on a psychiatric rehabilitation ward in London. [europepmc]
- Health care assistant and registered nurse dyads, working together and apart - a qualitative study. [europepmc]
- Brackish knowledge: exploring the material, epistemic, and institutional entanglements of numerical modelling of the Dutch coast. [europepmc]
- From constraints to innovations: a student agency typology and its implications for pedagogical change. [europepmc]
- Exploring and developing crime prevention through environmental design (CPTED) audits: an iterative process [europepmc]
Related