How “Us” and “Them” Relates to Voting Behavior—Social Structure, Social Identities, and Electoral Choice

2021/03/07 by Simon Bornschier, Simón Bornschier, Silja Häusermann +2 · 60 citations
Social Sciences · #Electoral Systems and Political Participation #Populism, Right-Wing Movements #Religion and Society Interactions

paper · doi:10.1177/0010414021997504

Abstract

The last decades have seen the emergence of a divide pitting the new left against the far right in advanced democracies. We study how this universalism-particularism divide is crystallizing into a full-blown cleavage, complete with structural, political and identity elements. So far, little research exists on the identities that voters themselves perceive as relevant for drawing in- and out-group boundaries along this divide. Based on an original survey from Switzerland, a paradigmatic case of electoral realignment, we show that voters’ “objective” socio-demographic characteristics relate to distinctive, primarily culturally connoted identities. We then inquire into the degree to which these group identities have been politicized, that is, whether they divide new left and far right voters. Our results strongly suggest that the universalism-particularism “cleavage” not only bundles issues, but shapes how people think about who they are and where they stand in a group conflict that meshes economics and culture.

Citations

• Education‐based group identity and consciousness in the authoritarian‐libertarian value conflict
• Expressive Partisanship: Campaign Involvement, Political Emotion, and Partisan Identity
• Education effects on authoritarian–libertarian values: a question of socialization1
• Status threat, not economic hardship, explains the 2016 presidential vote
• Cosmopolitan Immigration Attitudes in Large European Cities: Contextual or Compositional Effects?
• Geographic Divides and Cosmopolitanism: Evidence From Switzerland
• From Aristocratic to Ordinary: Shifting Modes of Elite Distinction

Cited by

• The Great Global Divider? A Comparison of Urban-Rural Partisan Polarization in Western Democracies
• Redistribution attitudes and vote choice across the educational divide
• Polarizing social figures? Climate activists in German media and popular discourse
• Updating cleavage theory for the twenty-first century
• Supply-side dynamics of parties’ group appeals: How dominance affects the choice between symbolic and policy-based appeals
• Backlash or Progressive Mobilization? Voter Reactions to Perceived Trajectories of Women’s Representation
• Separated by Degrees: Social Closure by Education Levels Strengthens Contemporary Political Divides
• Mediale Trigger. Emotionen und Argumente in deutschen Pressekommentaren
• Cleavage theory meets Bourdieu: studying the role of group identities in cleavage formation
• The Geography of EU Discontent and the Regional Development Trap
• The welfare preferences of socially liberal and socially conservative voters
• From educational conflicts to an educational cleavage? The multiple transformations of educational conflicts from medieval to post-industrial times
• Education-based affective attitudes: higher educated-bias is related to more political trust and less populism
• The Changing Face of the AfD Electorate—A Longitudinal Analysis from 2013 to 2022
• Changing affective alignments between parties and voters
• How do voters interpret social class appeals? Lessons from open-ended responses
• The Urban–Rural Divide in People’s Minds: Stereotypes of Urbanites and Ruralites in Nine European Countries
• Group-based congruence and political support
• Reference groups and electoral behavior
• Who wants to accelerate digitalization? Evidence from the next generation EU program
• The rural-urban cleavage in US presidential elections: Stability and sudden change
• Narratives of Backlash? Perceptions of Changing Status Hierarchies in Open-Ended Survey Responses
• Realignment within the right field: competition between the mainstream right and the far right
• Cleavage politics, polarisation and participation in Western Europe
• Cleavage theory meets civil society: a framework and research agenda
• Cleavages and divides in voting and political theory
• Der lange Schatten der DDR? Zum Zusammenhang von ehemaliger Systemnähe und aktuellen politischen Orientierungen von Ostdeutschen
• Place, education, and voting along the transnational cleavage in Europe
• Risky appeals: The electoral consequences of group-targeted campaign pledges
• Why do security forces vote for far-right parties? Evidence from Europe
• Social networks and distributive conflict: the class divide in social ties and attitudes to income inequality across 29 countries
• How generational replacement feeds the urban-rural divide: Evidence from Switzerland (1995–2023)
• Subjective losers of globalization
• The Gender Cleavage: Updating Rokkanian Theory for the Twenty-First Century
• A path forward: social democratic strategies and responses to far-right populist challenges
• Still Going Strong? The Social and Political Relevance of Class Identification Over Time in Four Countries
• Detecting Group Mentions in Political Rhetoric A Supervised Learning Approach
• Individual ideology and biased perceptions of relative income position
• Seeing Divides: Citizens’ Biased Perceptions of Political Cleavages
• Beyond left and right: Socio-cultural determinants of parenting leave policy in advanced democracies
• Urban jungle, radical roar: sprawl, economic decline and the success of populist radical right in metropolitan Spain
• You and whose economy? Group‐based retrospection in economic voting
• The Politics of Status Preservation: Immigration and the Knowledge Economy Class
• Existem Clivagens Políticas no Brasil?
• New threat of culture wars? The religious roots of public opinion polarization on morality issues in Europe
• Population-Scale Network Embeddings Expose Educational Divides in Network Structure Related to Right-Wing Populist Voting
• Rally Around the Winner—A Two-Wave Panel Survey on the Impact of the U.S. Election on Foreign Policy Stances
• Politicizing Inequality in Times of Sociocultural Conflict: How New Left and Far Right Voters Think About Inequality
• Representation matters: Technocracy, populism, and attitudes towards international organisations
• When place shapes attitudes: explaining rural discontent with climate policies
• Political emotions: a new policy science for tackling the climate crisis
• The Evolution of Public Opinion Over Gay Rights in Switzerland
• Social Identities in the Policy Process of Authoritarian Systems. [europepmc]
• Discovering cooperation: Endogenous change in international organizations. [europepmc]
• A New Social Conflict on Globalisation-Related Issues in Germany? A Longitudinal Perspective. [europepmc]
• Voices from the margins: How national stories are linked with support for populist radical right parties. [europepmc]
• Perceptions of Social Mobility, Gender, and Progressive Politics. [europepmc]
• The Electoral Coalition of the Radical Right in Western Europe. [europepmc]
• How to explain the German East-West divide in support of a populist radical right party (AfD): mapping socioeconomic, psychological, and cultural explanatory factors from a demand-side, voter-level perspective. [europepmc]
• How Crises Shape Circles of Solidarity: Evidence From the COVID-19 Pandemic in Italy [europepmc]

Related

• Realignment within the right field: competition between the mainstream right and the far right
• Identity Through Distinction: Contextualizing Populist In- and Outgroup References
• Careless whisper: Political elite discourses activate national identities for far‐right voting preferences
• Identity, Beliefs, and Political Conflict
• The Endurance of Identity-Based Voting: Evidence from the United States and Comparative Democracies