Urbanization and the Predation Paradox: The Role of Trophic Dynamics in Structuring Vertebrate Communities
2012/09/01 by Jason D. Fischer, Sarah H. Cleeton, Timothy P. Lyons +2 · 283 citations
Environmental Science · #Animal Ecology and Behavior Studies #Biology #Ecology #Economic geography #Economics #Geography #Land Use and Ecosystem Services #Predation #Structuring #Trophic level #Urbanization #Vertebrate #Wildlife Ecology and Conservation
paper · doi:10.1525/bio.2012.62.9.6
published in BioScience 62(9), 809-818 (Oxford University Press)
openalex publication_date 2012/09/01 · openalex created_date 2025/10/10 · openalex updated_date 2026/07/26
Abstract
As the pace and extent of urbanization increase, an understanding of the mechanisms that shape wildlife communities in cities will be essential to their effective management. Predation could be an important determinant of the structure of these communities, but the research to date suggests a predation paradox: Vertebrate predator numbers increase with urbanization, whereas predation rates decline. We reviewed studies on predator abundance and the survival of terrestrial vertebrates in urban and nonurban contexts to evaluate whether the predation paradox is a widespread phenomenon. We conclude that there is substantial support for it. We discuss hypotheses to explain the paradox and suggest that urbanization has fundamentally altered trophic dynamics by reducing top-down control through multiple mechanisms and by increasing bottom-up forcing through the greater availability of anthropogenic foods. The hypotheses are summarized in a conceptual model that generates testable predictions designed to advance our understanding of trophic dynamics in metropolitan areas.
Cited by
- Hierarchical filters determine community assembly of urban species pools
- A global synthesis of the impacts of urbanization on bird dawn choruses
- Urban Evolutionary Ecology and the Potential Benefits of Implementing Genomics
- Urbanisation Facilitates Intrapopulation Dietary Niche Diversity in a Generalist Carnivore
- Plasticity rather than genetic effects explains nest site selection in urban European blackbirds
- Recent Microbial Evolutionary Insights From Metagenomics
- Bottom–up and top–down drivers influence urbanization effects on insect herbivory in oaks
- Behavioral DiverCity: individual differences in behavior change along an urbanization gradient
- Seasonal variation of flight initiation distance in Eurasian red squirrels in urban versus rural habitat
- The ecological impacts of commensal species: black rats, Rattus rattus, at the urban–bushland interface
- Commensal in conflict: Livestock depredation patterns by free-ranging domestic dogs in the Upper Spiti Landscape, Himachal Pradesh, India. [europepmc]
- Urban conservation hotspots: predation release allows the grassland-specialist burrowing owl to perform better in the city. [europepmc]
- Consequences of resource supplementation for disease risk in a partially migratory population. [europepmc]
- Prey abundance and urbanization influence the establishment of avian predators in a metropolitan landscape. [europepmc]
- Estimating age-dependent survival when juveniles resemble females: Invasive ring-necked parakeets as an example. [europepmc]
- Predation Pressure on Sentinel Insect Prey Along a Riverside Urbanization Gradient in Hungary. [europepmc]
- Fear and stressing in predator-prey ecology: considering the twin stressors of predators and people on mammals. [europepmc]
- Downsizing for downtown: Limb lengths, toe lengths, and scale counts decrease with urbanization in western fence lizards ( Sceloporus occidentalis ). [europepmc]
- Seasonal and daily shifts in behavior and resource selection: how a carnivore navigates costly landscapes. [europepmc]
- Urban resources limit pair coordination over offspring provisioning. [europepmc]
- The evolutionary consequences of human-wildlife conflict in cities. [europepmc]
- Predation release of Texas horned lizards ( Phrynosoma cornutum ) living in small towns. [europepmc]
- Mammalian body size is determined by interactions between climate, urbanization, and ecological traits. [europepmc]
- Infection risk varies within urbanized landscapes: the case of coyotes and heartworm. [europepmc]
- Downtown diet: a global meta-analysis of increased urbanization on the diets of vertebrate predators. [europepmc]
- Antipredator behaviors in urban settings: Ecological experimentation powered by citizen science. [europepmc]
- Assessing the Trophic Impact of Bleaching: The Model Pair Berghia stephanieae / Exaiptasia diaphana . [europepmc]
- House Sparrow (Passer domesticus) escape behavior is triggered faster in smaller settlements. [europepmc]
- Spatial Overlap and Habitat Selection of Corvid Species in European Cities. [europepmc]
- Age-dependent relationships among diet, body condition, and Echinococcus multilocularis infection in urban coyotes. [europepmc]
- Trophic downgrading of an adaptable carnivore in an urbanising landscape. [europepmc]
- Does novelty influence the foraging decisions of a scavenger? [europepmc]
- Adaptation in the Alleyways: Candidate Genes Under Potential Selection in Urban Coyotes. [europepmc]
- Behavioral DiverCity: individual differences in behavior change along an urbanization gradient. [europepmc]
- DNA metabarcoding on roadkill stomach contents reveals the breadth of species present in bobcat diets. [europepmc]
Related