2001/04/26 by Douglas Scott, Scott, Douglas, Martin White +5
Physics and Astronomy · #Astrophysics (astro-ph) #FOS: Physical sciences #General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology (gr-qc) #High Energy Physics - Phenomenology (hep-ph) #astro-ph #gr-qc #hep-ph
paper · pdf · doi:10.48550/arxiv.astro-ph/0104435
14 pages, including 2 figures, uses mn.sty
arxiv created 2001/04/26 · arxiv updated 2009/11/30
The cold dark matter paradigm has been extremely successful for explaining a wide range of cosmological phenomena. Nevertheless, since evidence for non-baryonic dark matter remains indirect, all reasonable alternatives should be explored. One proposed idea, involving a fundamental acceleration scale a0 = 1-2e-10 m/s2, is called MOdified Newtonian Dynamics or MOND. MOND was suggested to explain the flat rotation curves of galaxies without the need for dark matter. Whether or not it can adequately fit the available data has been debated for almost 20 years (and we summarise many of these studies), but only recently have there been attempts to extend MOND to larger scale regimes. We discuss how the basic properties of MOND make it at best ambiguous to apply these ideas to cosmological scales. We emphasize the difficulties inherent in developing a full theory in which to embed MOND. Without such a theory there is no obviously consistent way to discuss the early Universe and the growth of perturbations. Recent claims that MONDian cosmology works very well are therefore not supportable. We also provide an argument for why a0~cH0 naturally, a coincidence which is often suggested as a motivation for taking MOND seriously. We discuss other alternative theories of gravity concluding, as others have, that no metric theory extensions appear workable for explaining rotation curves as well as other observed phenomena. The whole premise of many of these attempts is fatally flawed - galaxies are not pre-selected, discrete, isolated regions which formed monolithically and around which one can construct an axially-symmetric dynamical model in order to remove the need for dark matter. In the modern view, galaxies are part of a dynamic continuum of objects which collectively make up the evolving large-scale structure of the universe.