The Uncertain Geographic Context Problem
2012/06/22 by Mei-Po Kwan, Mei‐Po Kwan · 49 citations
Social Sciences · Economics, Econometrics and Finance · #Urban Transport and Accessibility #Economic and Environmental Valuation #Urban, Neighborhood, and Segregation Studies
paper · doi:10.1080/00045608.2012.687349
Abstract
Any study that examines the effects of area-based attributes on individual behaviors or outcomes faces another fundamental methodological problem besides the modifiable areal unit problem (MAUP). It is the problem that results about these effects can be affected by how contextual units or neighborhoods are geographically delineated and the extent to which these areal units deviate from the true geographic context. The problem arises because of the spatial uncertainty in the actual areas that exert the contextual influences under study and the temporal uncertainty in the timing and duration in which individuals experienced these contextual influences. Using neighborhood effects and environmental health research as a point of departure, this article clarifies the nature and sources of this problem, which is referred to as the uncertain geographic context problem (UGCoP). It highlights some of the inferential errors that the UGCoP might cause and discusses some means for mitigating the problem. It reviews recent studies to show that both contextual variables and research findings are sensitive to different delineations of contextual units. The article argues that the UGCoP is a problem as fundamental as the MAUP but is a different kind of problem. Future research needs to pay explicit attention to its potential confounding effects on research results and to methods for mitigating the problem.
Cited by
- Well-Being, Context, and Everyday Activities in Space and Time
- Beyond Space (As We Knew It): Toward Temporally Integrated Geographies of Segregation, Health, and Accessibility
- Ecology in an anthropogenic biosphere
- The relation between physical and social neighbourhood characteristics and loneliness. A systematic review
- Spatial Segregation Measures: A Methodological Review
- Place-Based Developmental Research: Conceptual and Methodological Advances in Studying Youth Development in Context
- Hybridizing Geographically Weighted Regression and Multilevel Models: A New Approach to Capture Contextual Effects in Geographical Analyses
- Reproducibility and Replicability in Geographical Analysis
- Treatment Geometry and Causal Identification with Earth Observation Data
- Contextual Uncertainties, Human Mobility, and Perceived Food Environment: The Uncertain Geographic Context Problem in Food Access Research
- Estimation of Contextual Exposure to HIV from GPS Data
- A statistical framework for measuring the temporal stability of human mobility patterns
- GPS-based street-view greenspace exposure and wearable assessed physical activity in a prospective cohort of US women
- Restoring nature, enhancing active mobility: The role of street greenery in the EU’s 2024 restoration law
- How would travel contexts affect people’s perceptions and evaluations of urban green space?
- Temporal and spatial variation in personal ambient temperatures for outdoor working populations in the southeastern USA
- A Simulation of Ageing and Care Accessibility in Italian Inner Areas
- Modeling Spatial Heterogeneity in Exposure Buffers and Risk: A Hierarchical Bayesian Approach
- Neighbors and visitors: impact of diversity on attitudes toward migrants
- Economic Inequality and Mental Health: Causality, Mechanisms, and Interventions
- Shared space and resource use within a building environment: An indoor geography
- Modeling Human Spatial Mobility Patterns with the Lévy Flight Cluster Model
- The role of residential urban form and built environment in supporting social interaction, health, and well-being: a focus on forming and maintaining ties
- The geography of partisan homophily in the 2020 US presidential election
- International variation in neighborhood walkability, transit, and recreation environments using geographic information systems: the IPEN adult study. [europepmc]
- Built Environment Influences of Children's Physical Activity: Examining Differences by Neighbourhood Size and Sex. [europepmc]
- Social and Physical Environmental Factors Influencing Adolescents' Physical Activity in Urban Public Open Spaces: A Qualitative Study Using Walk-Along Interviews. [europepmc]
- Risky Substance Use Environments and Addiction: A New Frontier for Environmental Justice Research. [europepmc]
- "Spatial Energetics": Integrating Data From GPS, Accelerometry, and GIS to Address Obesity and Inactivity. [europepmc]
- International comparison of observation-specific spatial buffers: maximizing the ability to estimate physical activity. [europepmc]
- Where do people purchase food? A novel approach to investigating food purchasing locations. [europepmc]
- Within What Distance Does "Greenness" Best Predict Physical Health? A Systematic Review of Articles with GIS Buffer Analyses across the Lifespan. [europepmc]
- Interplay of Socioeconomic Status and Supermarket Distance Is Associated with Excess Obesity Risk: A UK Cross-Sectional Study. [europepmc]
- Is All Urban Green Space the Same? A Comparison of the Health Benefits of Trees and Grass in New York City. [europepmc]
- The Uncertain Geographic Context Problem in the Analysis of the Relationships between Obesity and the Built Environment in Guangzhou. [europepmc]
- Urban Green Space and Its Impact on Human Health. [europepmc]
- Neighborhood Socioeconomic Deprivation and Allostatic Load: A Scoping Review. [europepmc]
- Cohort profile: the Geoscience and Health Cohort Consortium (GECCO) in the Netherlands. [europepmc]
- The Neighborhood Effect Averaging Problem (NEAP): An Elusive Confounder of the Neighborhood Effect. [europepmc]
- Impacts of Individual Daily Greenspace Exposure on Health Based on Individual Activity Space and Structural Equation Modeling. [europepmc]
- The Social Context of HIV Prevention and Care among Black Men Who Have Sex with Men in Three U.S. Cities: The Neighborhoods and Networks (N2) Cohort Study. [europepmc]
- Top 10 Research Priorities in Spatial Lifecourse Epidemiology. [europepmc]
- Methodologies for assessing contextual exposure to the built environment in physical activity studies: A systematic review. [europepmc]
- Ambulatory Assessment for Physical Activity Research: State of the Science, Best Practices and Future Directions. [europepmc]
- Deep phenotyping meets big data: the Geoscience and hEalth Cohort COnsortium (GECCO) data to enable exposome studies in The Netherlands. [europepmc]
- Associations between the built environment and dietary intake, physical activity, and obesity: A scoping review of reviews. [europepmc]
- Associations between Nature Exposure and Health: A Review of the Evidence. [europepmc]
- Confounding by Socioeconomic Status in Epidemiological Studies of Air Pollution and Health: Challenges and Opportunities. [europepmc]
- Residential Green Space and Cognitive Function in a Large Cohort of Middle-Aged Women. [europepmc]
Related