ITS alchemy: On the use of ITS as a DNA marker in fungal ecology
2023/07/25 by Håvard Kauserud · 1 voice · 38 citations
Agricultural and Biological Sciences · Biochemistry, Genetics and Molecular Biology · #Mycorrhizal Fungi and Plant Interactions #Plant Pathogens and Fungal Diseases #Forest Ecology and Biodiversity Studies
paper · doi:10.1016/j.funeco.2023.101274
Abstract
High throughput sequencing of PCR amplicons derived from environmental DNA (aka DNA metabarcoding) has become an integral part of fungal ecology, enabling in-depth characterization of fungal communities. In most cases, the rDNA Internal Transcribed Spacer (ITS) region, which has a long history as a target in fungal systematics, is used as a DNA barcode marker. Despite improvements in sequencing techniques and bioinformatics approaches, there are inherent limitations associated with the use of a single-locus DNA marker that are often ignored. In this text, I discuss both inherent biological and methodological limitations associated with the use of the ITS marker. For example, proper species delimitation is often not possible with a single marker, and a significant DNA barcoding gap (i.e. interspecific divergence) is often missing between sister taxa in ITS. Further, we can rarely be fully confident about the assigned species-level taxonomy based on available reference sequences. In addition to the inherent limitations, an extra layer of complexity and variation is blended into DNA metabarcoding data due to PCR and sequencing errors that may look similar to natural molecular variation. The bioinformatics processing of ITS amplicons must take into account both the basic properties of the ITS region, as well as the generated errors and biases. In this regard, we cannot adopt approaches and settings from other markers, such as 16S and 18S, blindly. For example, due to intraspecific variability in the ITS region, and sometimes intragenomic variability, ITS sequences must be clustered to approach species level resolution in community studies. Therefore, I argue that the concept of amplicon sequence variants (ASVs) is not applicable. Although the ITS region is by far the best option as a general DNA (meta)barcoding marker for fungi, this contribution is meant to remind against a naive or simplistic use of the ITS region, and for stimulating further discussions.
Citations
Cited by
- Global richness of arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi
- Gut fungi are associated with human genetic variation and disease risk
- Singleton-based species names and fungal rarity: Does the number really matter?
- Host range and global distribution of Gaeumannomyces root fungi of cereal crops and wild grasses
- Legacy Effects of Cropping System and Precipitation Influence the Core Camelina sativa Microbiome
- Revisions to the Gliophorus irrigatus complex (Agaricales, Hygrophoraceae, Gliophorus, section Unguinosae) including four new species, one new combination and comparisons of basidiome vs. eDNA distributions
- Fungal endophyte communities in galled oak leaves: Stability in leaves, divergence in galls
- Gaps in the current state of genomic marker data for British Isles lichens and associated taxa – limits and future prospects for eDNA
- Progression of saproxylic fungal communities in fine woody debris in boreal forests of Oulanka, Finland, assessed by DNA metabarcoding
- Biogeography and host associations of Russula subsection Xerampelinae based on large‐scale analysis of UNITE sequence data
- The Impact of Oil Palm Plantations and Pastures on Benthic Prokaryotic and Fungal Communities in Tropical Streams
- Foliar mycobiome remains unaltered under urban air-pollution but differentially express stress-related genes
- Development and Validation of Molecular Assays for Detection of Root- and Butt-Rot Diseases in Western Redcedar
- Nanopore-Sequencing Metabarcoding for Identification of Phytopathogenic and Endophytic Fungi in Olive ( Olea europaea ) Twigs. [europepmc]
- Impact of Dietary Regime and Seasonality on Hindgut's Mycobiota Diversity in Dairy Cows. [europepmc]
- Development of a novel mycobiome diagnostic for fungal infection. [europepmc]
- Biotic interactions outweigh abiotic factors as drivers of bark microbial communities in Central European forests. [europepmc]
- Singleton-based species names and fungal rarity: Does the number really matter? [europepmc]
- Identification of Fusarium oxysporum Causing Leaf Blight on Dendrobium chrysotoxum in Yunnan Province, China. [europepmc]
- Fungal and bacterial communities and their associations in snow-free and snow covered (sub-)alpine Pinus cembra forest soils. [europepmc]
- Global Spore Sampling Project: A global, standardized dataset of airborne fungal DNA. [europepmc]
- A Comprehensive View of Food Microbiota: Introducing FoodMicrobionet v5. [europepmc]
- Effect of plant communities on bacterial and fungal communities in a Central European grassland. [europepmc]
- An integrative taxonomy approach reveals Saccharomyces chiloensis sp. nov. as a newly discovered species from Coastal Patagonia. [europepmc]
- The Ribosomal Operon Database: A Full-Length rDNA Operon Database Derived From Genome Assemblies. [europepmc]
- ITSxpress version 2: software to rapidly trim internal transcribed spacer sequences with quality scores for amplicon sequencing. [europepmc]
- Microbial diversity in the arid and semi-arid soils of Botswana. [europepmc]
- Comparison of commonly used software pipelines for analyzing fungal metabarcoding data. [europepmc]
- Exploring Environmental Microfungal Diversity Through Serial Single Cell Screening. [europepmc]
- Idiosyncratic responses to biotic and environmental filters in wood-inhabiting fungal communities. [europepmc]
- A curated soil fungal dataset to advance fungal ecology and conservation research in Australia and Antarctica. [europepmc]
- Microbial decay of wooden structures: actors, activities and means of protection. [europepmc]
- Protein Coding Low-Copy rpb2 and ef1-α Regions Are Viable Fungal Metabarcoding DNA Markers Which Can Supplement ITS for Better Accuracy. [europepmc]
- Absolute abundance unveils Basidiobolus as a cross-domain bridge indirectly bolstering gut microbiome homeostasis. [europepmc]
- The Human Mycobiome: Composition, Immune Interactions, and Impact on Disease. [europepmc]
- Gut fungal profiles reveal phylosymbiosis and codiversification across humans and nonhuman primates. [europepmc]
- A Reference DNA Barcode Library for UK Fungi associated with Bark and Ambrosia Beetles. [europepmc]
- Comparative mitogenomics of kingdom Fungi - evolutionary insights and metagenomic applications. [europepmc]
Discussions
Related