Unpacking the Black Box of Causality: Learning about Causal Mechanisms from Experimental and Observational Studies
2011/11/01 by Kosuke Imai, KOSUKE IMAI, Luke Keele +5 · 104 citations
Mathematics · Social Sciences · #Advanced Causal Inference Techniques #Qualitative Comparative Analysis Research #Survey Sampling and Estimation Techniques
paper · doi:10.1017/s0003055411000414
Abstract
Identifying causal mechanisms is a fundamental goal of social science. Researchers seek to study not only whether one variable affects another but also how such a causal relationship arises. Yet commonly used statistical methods for identifying causal mechanisms rely upon untestable assumptions and are often inappropriate even under those assumptions. Randomizing treatment and intermediate variables is also insufficient. Despite these difficulties, the study of causal mechanisms is too important to abandon. We make three contributions to improve research on causal mechanisms. First, we present a minimum set of assumptions required under standard designs of experimental and observational studies and develop a general algorithm for estimating causal mediation effects. Second, we provide a method for assessing the sensitivity of conclusions to potential violations of a key assumption. Third, we offer alternative research designs for identifying causal mechanisms under weaker assumptions. The proposed approach is illustrated using media framing experiments and incumbency advantage studies.
Citations
Cited by
- Public Opinion and the Democratic Peace
- Attitudes and Action in International Refugee Policy: Evidence from Australia
- The effects of government propaganda in electoral authoritarian regimes: Evidence from Turkey
- Party Competition and Cooperation Shape Affective Polarization: Evidence from Natural and Survey Experiments in Israel
- Relaxing Assumptions, Improving Inference: Integrating Machine Learning and the Linear Regression
- Lower Artificial Intelligence Literacy Predicts Greater AI Receptivity
- Russian Invasion of Ukraine and Chinese Public Support for War
- Human Rights and Public Support for War
- Tracing Causal Paths from Experimental and Observational Data
- Survey Design, Order Effects, and Causal Mediation Analysis
- Historical Ownership and Territorial Disputes
- Moral Support: How Moral Values Shape Foreign Policy Attitudes
- Too Important to Ignore? Why Ambiguity and Broad Appeals Fail with Rising Issue Salience
- A Clearer Picture: The Contribution of Visuals and Text to Framing Effects
- Democratic Peace and Covert Military Force: An Experimental Test
- Why Do People Join Backlash Protests? Lessons from Turkey
- Mechanisms of Morality
- A Clash of Norms? How Reciprocity and International Humanitarian Law affect American Opinion on the Treatment of POWs
- Critical Junctures: Independence Movements and Democracy in Africa
- Military Alliances and Public Support for War
- The Path of the Boomerang: Human Rights Campaigns, Third-Party Pressure, and Human Rights
- Perceptions of Electability: Candidate (and Voter) Ideology, Race, and Gender
- Quasi-Experimental Designs for Causal Inference
- The ‘sour grapes’ of conspiracy theories: how does the emotion of ressentiment predict conspiracy beliefs?
- Split Decisions: Household Finance When a Policy Discontinuity Allocates Overseas Work
- Psychological reactance to system-level policies before and after their implementation
- Autocratization Spillover: When Electing an Authoritarian Erodes Election Trust across Borders
- Misinformation, Narratives, and Intergroup Attitudes: Evidence from India
- ‘The Economy is Rigged’: Inequality Narratives, Fairness, and Support for Redistribution in Six Countries
- Unequal Democracies
- What Is Your Estimand? Defining the Target Quantity Connects Statistical Evidence to Theory
- Generalizability of choice architecture interventions
- Alone but better off? Adult child migration and health of elderly parents in Moldova
- Fostering refugee receptivity through perspective taking: Evidence from Thailand
- Do Personality Traits Predict Voter Attitudes When Politics Is Structured Around Conflict? Lessons from Israel
- Affective polarization and coalition signals
- The Paradox of Algorithms and Blame on Public Decision-makers
- How party polarisation exacerbates the link between democratic deficit and populist voting: evidence from Europe
- Sexual Harassment and Hierarchical Workplace Relationships after #MeToo: Consequences for Women Subordinates
- Communicating the Evidence: Understanding Individual-Level Responses to Increased Transparency of the Evidence in Evidence-Informed Policy
- Paying Them to Hate US: The Effect of US Military Aid on Anti-American Terrorism, 1968–2018
- Collective PES Contracts Can Motivate Institutional Creation to Conserve Forests: Experimental Evidence
- Personality and political representation—How personality traits shape <scp>MPs</scp>' attitudes toward gender equality
- Influencing People’s Populist Attitudes With Rhetoric and Emotions: An Online Experiment in the United States
- Can reducing learning costs improve public support for means‐tested benefit programs?
- Technological vulnerability among the higher-educated: implications for party preferences
- Beliefs about Climate Beliefs: The Importance of Second-Order Opinions for Climate Politics
- Public Preferences, Gender, and Foreign Support for Armed Movements
- The wealth of nations and the health of populations: A quasi-experimental design of the impact of sovereign debt crises on child mortality
- Conflict and Contraception in Colombia
- Does mental health mediate the effect of nonsurgical exposures on pain and functional outcomes in osteoarthritis? A systematic review
- In the Metaverse, Politicians Can Hear You Scream: Corporate Scandals, Big Tech Regulation, and the Microfoundations of Focusing Events
- Not in My Schoolyard: Disability Discrimination in Educational Access
- Perceived Inequality as an Impediment to Mass Taxation: Evidence From Latin America
- Playing a different game: Situation perception mediates framing effects on cooperative behaviour
- Fearing Food: The Influence of Risk Perceptions on Public Preferences for Uniform and Centralized Risk Regulation
- Intergenerational Mobility at the Top of the Educational Distribution
- Unnamed but Reassuring: Quasi-Secrecy and Public Support for Foreign Policy
- Humanitarian concerns and threat perceptions: An analysis of the key drivers of refugee attitudes in Germany
- Genetic influences on depression and selection into adverse life experiences
- Protecting the center until it doesn’t: when blame shifting strategies are nullified in authoritarian regimes
- School-to-School Collaboration, Student Learning Outcomes, and Mediating Factors: Evidence From Shanghai's Strong School Project
- Assessing Performance from Space
- Pension Policy and Governmentality in China: Manufacturing Public Compliance
- Interest-Based Negotiation over Natural Resources: Experimental Evidence from Liberia
- Personality Traits and Vote Switching: A Tale of Open-Minded Switchers and Agreeable Populism Resisters
- Performance Information, Racial Bias, and Citizen Evaluations of Government: Evidence from Two Studies
- Great Expectations: The Democratic Advantage in Trade Attitudes
- The Moderating Effect of Debates on Political Attitudes
- Explaining Causal Findings Without Bias: Detecting and Assessing Direct Effects
- Effectiveness of Incumbent’s Strategic Communication during Economic Crisis under Electoral Authoritarianism: Evidence from Turkey
- Is opinion-policy congruence rewarded at the ballot box?
- Labor market risk shapes individuals’ environmental attitudes and policy preferences
- State Capacity, Bureaucratic Politicization, and Corruption in the Brazilian State
- Meaning and Modularity: The Multivalence of “Mechanism” in Sociological Explanation
- On the role of surrogates in the efficient estimation of treatment effects with limited outcome data
- Do high electricity bills undermine public support for renewables? Evidence from the European Union
- Identifying Unmeasured Confounders in Panel Causal Models: A Two-Stage LM-Wald Approach
- The price of ethnic marginalization: the peril of ethnic exclusion in times of public health crisis
- Do routinely measured risk factors for obesity explain the sex gap in its prevalence? Observations from Saudi Arabia. [europepmc]
- Socioeconomic Determinants of Multimorbidity: A Population-Based Household Survey of Hong Kong Chinese. [europepmc]
- Evidence for a causal link between sepsis and long-term mortality: a systematic review of epidemiologic studies. [europepmc]
- Differential Recall Bias, Intermediate Confounding, and Mediation Analysis in Life Course Epidemiology: An Analytic Framework with Empirical Example. [europepmc]
- Causal mediation analysis in the context of clinical research. [europepmc]
- Mediators of Physical Activity on Neurocognitive Function: A Review at Multiple Levels of Analysis. [europepmc]
- Understanding causal pathways within health systems policy evaluation through mediation analysis: an application to payment for performance (P4P) in Tanzania. [europepmc]
- Mechanism evaluation of a lifestyle intervention for patients with musculoskeletal pain who are overweight or obese: protocol for a causal mediation analysis. [europepmc]
- "Scaling-out" evidence-based interventions to new populations or new health care delivery systems. [europepmc]
- Confounding and collinearity in regression analysis: a cautionary tale and an alternative procedure, illustrated by studies of British voting behaviour. [europepmc]
- Impact of cystic fibrosis on birthweight: a population based study of children in Denmark and Wales. [europepmc]
- Plasma sRAGE is independently associated with increased mortality in ARDS: a meta-analysis of individual patient data. [europepmc]
- Comparison of logistic-regression based methods for simple mediation analysis with a dichotomous outcome variable. [europepmc]
- Exposure to Residential Greenness as a Predictor of Cause-Specific Mortality and Stroke Incidence in the Rome Longitudinal Study. [europepmc]
- Financial Hardship and Quality of Life among African American and White Cancer Survivors: The Role of Limiting Care Due to Cost. [europepmc]
- Burnout Toll on Empathy Would Mediate the Missing Professional Support in the COVID-19 Outbreak. [europepmc]
- Socioeconomic Status and Its Relation to Hypertension in Rural Nepal. [europepmc]
- Normative vs personal attitudes toward persons with HIV, and the mediating role of perceived HIV stigma in rural Uganda. [europepmc]
- Integrative analysis of the plasma proteome and polygenic risk of cardiometabolic diseases. [europepmc]
- Association between a single mother family and childhood undervaccination, and mediating effect of household income: a nationwide, prospective birth cohort from the Japan Environment and Children's Study (JECS). [europepmc]
- Influence of Maternal Exposure to Mass Media on Growth Stunting Among Children Under Five: Mediation Analysis Through the Water, Sanitation, and Hygiene Program. [europepmc]
- Affective Polarization and Misinformation Belief. [europepmc]
- Tutorial on causal mediation analysis with binary variables: An application to health psychology research. [europepmc]
- Effect Measure Modification by Covariates in Mediation: Extending Regression-based Causal Mediation Analysis. [europepmc]
- Maternal depression and acculturative stress impacts on Mexican-origin children through authoritarian parenting. [europepmc]
Related