The Strength of Phenotypic Selection in Natural Populations
2001/03/01 by J. G. Kingsolver, Joel G. Kingsolver, H. E. Hoekstra +14 · 1,905 citations
Agricultural and Biological Sciences · Environmental Science · Mathematics · #Animal Behavior and Reproduction #Biology #Directional selection #Disruptive selection #Evolutionary biology #Mathematics #Natural selection #Plant and animal studies #Selection (genetic algorithm) #Stabilizing selection #Statistics #Wildlife Ecology and Conservation
paper · doi:10.1086/319193
published in The American Naturalist 157(3), 245-261 (University of Chicago Press)
openalex publication_date 2001/03/01 · openalex created_date 2025/10/10 · openalex updated_date 2026/08/04
Abstract
How strong is phenotypic selection on quantitative traits in the wild? We reviewed the literature from 1984 through 1997 for studies that estimated the strength of linear and quadratic selection in terms of standardized selection gradients or differentials on natural variation in quantitative traits for field populations. We tabulated 63 published studies of 62 species that reported over 2,500 estimates of linear or quadratic selection. More than 80% of the estimates were for morphological traits; there is very little data for behavioral or physiological traits. Most published selection studies were unreplicated and had sample sizes below 135 individuals, resulting in low statistical power to detect selection of the magnitude typically reported for natural populations. The absolute values of linear selection gradients |beta| were exponentially distributed with an overall median of 0.16, suggesting that strong directional selection was uncommon. The values of |beta| for selection on morphological and on life-history/phenological traits were significantly different: on average, selection on morphology was stronger than selection on phenology/life history. Similarly, the values of |beta| for selection via aspects of survival, fecundity, and mating success were significantly different: on average, selection on mating success was stronger than on survival. Comparisons of estimated linear selection gradients and differentials suggest that indirect components of phenotypic selection were usually modest relative to direct components. The absolute values of quadratic selection gradients |gamma| were exponentially distributed with an overall median of only 0.10, suggesting that quadratic selection is typically quite weak. The distribution of gamma values was symmetric about 0, providing no evidence that stabilizing selection is stronger or more common than disruptive selection in nature.
Cited by
- Context Dependence of Local Adaptation to Abiotic and Biotic Environments: A Quantitative and Qualitative Synthesis
- Natural selection on floral traits of Lobelia (Lobeliaceae): spatial and temporal variation
- Natural selection and animal personality
- EFFECTS OF NATURAL AND SEXUAL SELECTION ON ADAPTIVE POPULATION DIVERGENCE AND PREMATING ISOLATION IN A DAMSELFLY
- Fine-scale spatio-temporal variation in natural selection on reproductive traits across two wild bird species
- Understanding variation in metabolic rate
- Non-genetic inheritance of induced defense morphologies across multiple unexposed generations of Daphnia lumholtzi
- Sexual selection in wild populations of seed bugs: the role of size in pre-copulatory mate choice by females and males
- The fitness advantage of a high-performance weapon
- Inferred Attractiveness: A generalized mechanism for sexual selection that can maintain variation in traits and preferences over time
- A roadmap to identifying and filling shortfalls in Neotropical ornithology
- Planting Genomes in the Wild: Arabidopsis from Genetics History to the Ecology and Evolutionary Genomics Era
- The value of long-term ecological research for evolutionary insights
- Measurement and Meaning in Biology
- Niche Construction Theory: A Practical Guide for Ecologists
- The genetic architecture of polygenic adaptation under a network-derived trait
- Persistence of the ecological niche in pond damselflies underlies a stable adaptive zone despite varying selection
- Roles for Bmp4 and CaM1 in Shaping the Jaw: Evo-Devo and Beyond
- Predicting the contribution of single trait evolution to rescuing a plant population from demographic impacts of climate change
- Explaining stasis: microevolutionary studies in natural populations
- A fitness-based indicator for the effect of aquaculture-produced salmon lice on wild sea trout
- Systems genomics of salinity stress response in rice
- How development affects evolution
- Wing membrane thickness, allometric scaling and wing interference patterns in damselflies: a target of sexual selection?
- The pace of modern life II: from rates of contemporary microevolution to pattern and process
- Natural selection and the predictability of evolution in Timema stick insects
- Unifying approaches from statistical genetics and phylogenetics for mapping phenotypes in structured populations
- Path analysis of natural selection via survival and fecundity across contrasting environments in Avena barbata
- Measuring Natural Selection on Genotypes and Phenotypes in the Wild
- Trait Correlations Shift in Sign and Magnitude in Response to Urbanization
- Examining costs of induced and constitutive immune investment in Tenebrio molitor
- Systems genomics of salinity stress response in rice
- Inferring the strength of directional selection on armor plates in Lake Washington stickleback while accounting for migration and drift
- Genetic variance in reproductive timing contributes to trait evolvability
- Measuring Performance in Nature: Implications for Studies of Fitness Within Populations
- Phenotypic selection in weedy radish and its bidirectional crop–weed hybrids across two contrasting environments
- Inheritance and Natural Selection on Functional Traits
- Unpredictable Evolution in a 30-Year Study of Darwin's Finches
- Spatially and temporally varying selection on intrapopulation quantitative trait loci for a life history trade‐off in Mimulus guttatus
- Cheating death: selection on digestive physiology overcomes expected growth costs of antipredator defences
- The adaptive landscape as a conceptual bridge between micro- and macroevolution
- Seven Shortfalls that Beset Large-Scale Knowledge of Biodiversity
- Understanding and using quantitative genetic variation
- Measuring and comparing evolvability and constraint in multivariate characters
- A mathematical framework for evo-devo dynamics
- Quantitative-genetic analysis of directional adaptation suggests low maximum sustainable rates of change in agreement with data from field populations
- Longitudinal and cross-sectional selection on flowering traits in a self-incompatible annual
- The fitness costs of developmental canalization and plasticity
- Toward a synthetic understanding of the role of phenology in ecology and evolution
- Trophic Specialization on unique resources despite limited niche divergence in a celebrated example of sympatric speciation
- Evolution of Homosexuality
- Interplay between fecundity, sexual and growth selection on the spring phenology of European beech (Fagus sylvatica L.).
- The missing fraction problem as an episodes of selection problem
- Only the Good Die Old? Ontogenetic Determinants of Locomotor Performance in Eastern Cottontail Rabbits (Sylvilagus floridanus)
- The danger of applying the breeder's equation in observational studies of natural populations
- Introduction: the enigma of sexual size dimorphism
- Human-induced dwarfing of Himalayan snow lotus, Saussurea laniceps (Asteraceae)
- Lifetime Fitness in Wild Female Baboons: Trade-Offs and Individual Heterogeneity in Quality
- Ecological opportunity and the origin of adaptive radiations
- Bipedality and hair loss in human evolution revisited: The impact of altitude and activity scheduling
- Limits to evolution at range margins: when and why does adaptation fail?
- Pollination Syndromes and Floral Specialization
- Integrating viability and fecundity selection to illuminate the adaptive nature of genetic clines
- Strength and tempo of directional selection in the wild
- How species evolve collectively: implications of gene flow and selection for the spread of advantageous alleles
- Which evolutionary processes influence natural genetic variation for phenotypic traits?
- An introduction to microevolution: rate, pattern, process
- Darwin's beautiful contrivances: evolutionary and functional evidence for floral adaptation
- Biodiversity, Species Interactions and Ecological Networks in a Fragmented World
- Understanding quantitative genetic variation
- Evolution of Flightlessness in Rails (Gruiformes: Rallidae): Phylogenetic, Ecomorphological, and Ontogenetic Perspectives
- Directional selection is the primary cause of phenotypic diversification
- Extended-spectrum beta-lactamase producing Enterobacteriaceae in companion animals
- Stabilizing Selection, Purifying Selection, and Mutational Bias in Finite Populations
- The genetic mating system of a sea spider with male-biased sexual size dimorphism: evidence for paternity skew despite random mating success
- Parallel shifts in ecology and natural selection in an island lizard
- Experimentally assessing the relative importance of predation and competition as agents of selection
- PROBING THE ADAPTIVE LANDSCAPE USING EXPERIMENTAL ISLANDS: DENSITY-DEPENDENT NATURAL SELECTION ON LIZARD BODY SIZE
- Adaptive diversification of growth allometry in the plant Arabidopsis thaliana
- Convergent Evolution and Divergent Selection: Lizards at the White Sands Ecotone
- Natural selection in a contemporary human population
- A Model of the Effect of Uncertainty on the C elegans L2/L2d Decision
- The nature of fisheries‐ and farming‐induced evolution
- How species evolve collectively: implications of gene flow and selection for the spread of advantageous alleles. [europepmc]
- Estimating individual contributions to population growth: evolutionary fitness in ecological time. [europepmc]
- Hormone-mediated suites as adaptations and evolutionary constraints. [europepmc]
- Fundulus as the premier teleost model in environmental biology: opportunities for new insights using genomics. [europepmc]
- Estimating evolutionary parameters when viability selection is operating. [europepmc]
- The loci of evolution: how predictable is genetic evolution? [europepmc]
- Understanding the evolution and stability of the G-matrix. [europepmc]
- Eco-evolutionary dynamics. [europepmc]
- Understanding and using quantitative genetic variation. [europepmc]
- The population genetics of mutations: good, bad and indifferent. [europepmc]
- Viability selection prior to trait expression is an essential component of natural selection. [europepmc]
- Adaptation, plasticity, and extinction in a changing environment: towards a predictive theory. [europepmc]
- Integrating evolutionary and functional approaches to infer adaptation at specific loci. [europepmc]
- Coupled dynamics of body mass and population growth in response to environmental change. [europepmc]
- Character displacement and the origins of diversity. [europepmc]
- Personality and the emergence of the pace-of-life syndrome concept at the population level. [europepmc]
- Evolutionary rescue and the limits of adaptation. [europepmc]
- Seasonal variation in life history traits in two Drosophila species. [europepmc]
- Modularity: genes, development and evolution. [europepmc]
- A population genetic interpretation of GWAS findings for human quantitative traits. [europepmc]
- Measuring and understanding individual differences in cognition. [europepmc]
- A roadmap for urban evolutionary ecology. [europepmc]
- Adaptive responses of animals to climate change are most likely insufficient. [europepmc]
- Fluctuating optimum and temporally variable selection on breeding date in birds and mammals. [europepmc]
- Predicting future from past: The genomic basis of recurrent and rapid stickleback evolution. [europepmc]
Related