Why Do Some Occupations Pay More than Others? Social Closure and Earnings Inequality in the United States
2002/07/01 by Kim A. Weeden, Kim A. Weeden · 30 citations
Business, Management and Accounting · Social Sciences · #Management and Organizational Studies #Social and Cultural Dynamics #Contemporary Sociological Theory and Practice
paper · doi:10.1086/344121
Abstract
This article elaborates and evaluates the neo‐Weberian notion of social closure to investigate positional inequality in the United States. It argues that social and legal barriers around occupations raise the rewards of their members by restricting the labor supply, enhancing diffuse demand, channeling demand, or signaling a particular quality of service. Hypotheses derived from the closure perspective are evaluated using new data that map five institutionalized closure devices—licensing, educational credentialing, voluntary certification, association representation, and unionization—onto 488 occupations. Results from multilevel models demonstrate that closure practices, particularly those that generate tangible restrictions on the labor supply, shape the contemporary structure of occupational earnings. Returns to these strategies vary across occupations but are not tightly linked to the complexity of the occupation's knowledge base. If suitably elaborated, closure theory thus offers a promising complement to individualistic explanations of earnings inequality.
Cited by
- Class origin closure: economic advantages of occupational elitism
- Wealth Accumulation and Opportunity Hoarding: Class-Origin Wealth Gaps over a Quarter of a Century in a Scandinavian Country
- The Sociogenomics of Social Stratification and General Theories of Inequality
- Stratified scars: social inequality in the labour market consequences of apprenticeship dropout
- Credential stickiness: how initial educational sorting conditions the value of later credentials in Chinese graduate education
- Occupations and Inequality: Theoretical Perspectives and Mechanisms
- Closure and matching payoffs from college majors
- Test-Based Admission to Selective Universities: A Lever for First-Generation Students or a Safety Net for the Professional Classes?
- Economic Elites, Investments, and Income Inequality
- The Contribution of National Income Inequality to Regional Economic Divergence
- Wages of Virtue: The Relative Pay of Care Work
- The plateauing of cognitive ability among top earners
- Field of Study in College and Lifetime Earnings in the United States
- Labor Market Effects of Field of Study in Comparative Perspective
- Occupational Licensing, Intergenerational Occupational Persistence and Social Mobility
- The Chains That Bind? Restrictive Covenants and Labor Market Entrants' Perceived Occupational Mobility
- The Case for a New Class Map
- Occupation-related differences in cognitive aging: Comparative effects of job type, skill level, and education
- The internal effects of corporate “tech ethics”: how technology professionals evaluate their employers’ crises of moral legitimacy
- Who Is Ahead in the Labor Queue? Institutions’ and Employers’ Perspective on Overeducation, Undereducation, and Horizontal Mismatches
- Education, cognitive skills and earnings in comparative perspective
- Socioeconomic homogeneity in acquaintance networks: Occupational prestige, education, and intergenerational mobility
- Entrepreneurship and social mobility: Three status metaphors for future research*
- Yesterday’s model for tomorrow’s economy? Dual VET and wage inequality in the knowledge economy
- A New Take on the Categorical Imperative: Gatekeeping, Boundary Maintenance, and Evaluation Penalties in Science
- Gender Differences in Productivity
- Wage Differentials between Heat-Exposure Risk and No Heat-Exposure Risk Groups. [europepmc]
- The impact of occupational structures on ethnic and gendered employment gaps: An event history analysis using social security register data. [europepmc]
- Vanishing social classes? Facts and figures of the Italian labour market. [europepmc]
- The movement of class: on occupation and everyday mobility patterns in the United States. [europepmc]
Related