Marx's Theory of Metabolic Rift: Classical Foundations for Environmental Sociology
1999/09/01 by John Bellamy Foster · 31 citations
Environmental Science · Engineering · #Sustainability and Ecological Systems Analysis #Ecosystem dynamics and resilience #Sustainable Industrial Ecology
paper · doi:10.1086/210315
Abstract
This article addresses a paradox: on the one hand, environmental sociology, as currently developed, is closely associated with the thesis that the classical sociological tradition is devoid of systematic in-sights into environmental problems; on the other hand, evidence of crucial classical contributions in this area, particularly in Marx, but also in Weber, Durkheim, and others, is too abundant to be convinc-ingly denied. The nature of this paradox, its origins, and the means of transcending it are illustrated primarily through an analysis of Marx’s theory of metabolic rift, which, it is contended, offers impor-tant classical foundations for environmental sociology. CLASSICAL BARRIERS TO ENVIRONMENTAL SOCIOLOGY In recent decades, we have witnessed a significant transformation in social thought as various disciplines have sought to incorporate ecological awareness into their core paradigms in response to the challenge raised by environmentalism and by what is now widely perceived as a global ecological crisis. This transformation has involved a twofold process of rejecting much of previous thought as ecologically unsound, together with an attempt to build on the past, where possible. This can be seen as oc-curring with unequal degrees of success in the various disciplines. Geogra-phy, with its long history of focusing on the development of the natural landscape and on biogeography (see Sauer 1963), was the social science that adapted most easily to growing environmental concerns. Anthropol-
Cited by
- Contested territorialization and biophysical expansion of oil palm plantations in Indonesia
- Metabolic ecology
- Law’s quick fix? Ecocide, social transformation and the pitfalls of criminalisation
- De-Carbonization in Former Soviet Republics, 1992–2000: The Ecological Consequences of De-Modernization
- The Agrarian Question as an Ecological Question: An Introduction
- No farm is an island: constrained choice, landscape thinking, and ecological insect management among Wisconsin farmers
- Deepening, and repairing, the metabolic rift
- From extractivism to global extractivism: the evolution of an organizing concept
- A green new deal for agriculture: for, within, or against capitalism?
- Environment, Society, and Machine Learning
- Ecocide in Peru: Repsol and the colonial regime of permission
- Extimate nature: Environmental crisis and the Excluded
- MST's Arvoredo app: Family farmers and grassroots environmental data-driven governance in Brazil
- The Temporal Turn in Social Movement Studies: Political Readings of Temporality
- Guns versus Climate: How Militarization Amplifies the Effect of Economic Growth on Carbon Emissions
- The carbon intensity of well-being and presidential politics in the United States, 1960–2023
- The concept of metabolism in ocean biogeochemistry: departures, consistencies, and implications
- The ultimate learning outcome of transformative sustainability education: A case for ecocentric dispositions
- Environment and the racialization of space in US cities
- Working the Waste Commodity Frontier: Metabolic Value and Informal Waste Work
- The Anthropocene Interregnum: Ecological Marxism and the Social Metabolism of the Present
- Degrowing alternative agriculture: institutions and aspirations as sustainability metrics for small farmers in Bosnia and India
- Markets, Nature, and Society
- Ecology of a widespread large omnivore, Homo sapiens , and its impacts on ecosystem processes. [europepmc]
- Digging our own grave: A Marxian consideration of formal education as a destructive enterprise. [europepmc]
- A review of GIS methodologies to analyze the dynamics of COVID-19 in the second half of 2020. [europepmc]
- The Political Economy of Australia's Waste Crisis: From Neoliberalism to the Circular Economy Agenda. [europepmc]
- The Effect of Non-Cognitive Ability on Farmer's Ecological Protection of Farmland: Evidence from Major Tea Producing Areas in China. [europepmc]
- One Health in the consciousness of veterinary students from the perspective of knowledge of antibiotic therapy and antimicrobial resistance: a multi-centre study. [europepmc]
- Limited Attention to Climate Change in U.S. Sociology. [europepmc]
- Life in the hole: practices and emotions in the cultural political economy of mitigation deterrence [europepmc]
Related