Targeted Maximum Likelihood Estimation for Causal Inference in Observational Studies

2016/11/01 by Megan S. Schuler, Sherri Rose · 43 citations
Mathematics · #Advanced Causal Inference Techniques #Statistical Methods and Inference #Statistical Methods and Bayesian Inference

paper · doi:10.1093/aje/kww165

Abstract

Estimation of causal effects using observational data continues to grow in popularity in the epidemiologic literature. While many applications of causal effect estimation use propensity score methods or G-computation, targeted maximum likelihood estimation (TMLE) is a well-established alternative method with desirable statistical properties. TMLE is a doubly robust maximum-likelihood-based approach that includes a secondary "targeting" step that optimizes the bias-variance tradeoff for the target parameter. Under standard causal assumptions, estimates can be interpreted as causal effects. Because TMLE has not been as widely implemented in epidemiologic research, we aim to provide an accessible presentation of TMLE for applied researchers. We give step-by-step instructions for using TMLE to estimate the average treatment effect in the context of an observational study. We discuss conceptual similarities and differences between TMLE and 2 common estimation approaches (G-computation and inverse probability weighting) and present findings on their relative performance using simulated data. Our simulation study compares methods under parametric regression misspecification; our results highlight TMLE's property of double robustness. Additionally, we discuss best practices for TMLE implementation, particularly the use of ensembled machine learning algorithms. Our simulation study demonstrates all methods using super learning, highlighting that incorporation of machine learning may outperform parametric regression in observational data settings.

Citations

• The central role of the propensity score in observational studies for causal effects

Cited by

• Challenges in Obtaining Valid Causal Effect Estimates With Machine Learning Algorithms
• Supervised Machine Learning: A Brief Primer
• Estimating treatment effects with machine learning
• Applications of Machine Learning to the Problem of Antimicrobial Resistance: an Emerging Model for Translational Research
• Estimation of Causal Effects of Multiple Treatments in Observational Studies with a Binary Outcome
• Assessment of the conditional exchangeability assumption in causal machine learning models: a simulation study
• How to select predictive models for decision-making or causal inference
• Causal thinking for decision making on Electronic Health Records: why and how
• Accounting for motion in resting-state fMRI: What part of the spectrum are we characterizing in autism spectrum disorder?
• Synthesis estimators for transportability with positivity violations by a continuous covariate
• Inference procedures in sequential trial emulation with survival outcomes: Comparing confidence intervals based on the sandwich variance estimator, bootstrap and jackknife
• Causal Effect Estimation with TMLE: Handling Missing Data and Near-Violations of Positivity
• Past, present, and future of Phase 3 vaccine trial design: rethinking statistics for the 21st century
• The impact of physical activity on psychological distress in young people: An analysis of longitudinal data from the Millennium Cohort Study using causal machine learning
• Rate doubly robust estimation for weighted average treatment effects
• Associations between alcohol use and HIV care cascade outcomes among adults undergoing population-based HIV testing in East Africa
• LLM-based Agents for Automated Confounder Discovery and Subgroup Analysis in Causal Inference
• Antidopaminergic Medications and Clinical Changes in Measures of Huntington's Disease: A Causal Analysis
• Measuring changes in transmission of neglected tropical diseases, malaria, and enteric pathogens from quantitative antibody levels. [europepmc]
• Principles of confounder selection. [europepmc]
• State-Level and County-Level Estimates of Health Care Costs Associated with Food Insecurity. [europepmc]
• Health Center-Based Community-Supported Agriculture: An RCT. [europepmc]
• Diet as a Source of Exposure to Environmental Contaminants for Pregnant Women and Children from Six European Countries. [europepmc]
• Associations between alcohol use and HIV care cascade outcomes among adults undergoing population-based HIV testing in East Africa. [europepmc]
• Machine learning as a strategy to account for dietary synergy: an illustration based on dietary intake and adverse pregnancy outcomes. [europepmc]
• Estimation of causal effects of multiple treatments in observational studies with a binary outcome. [europepmc]
• G-computation, propensity score-based methods, and targeted maximum likelihood estimator for causal inference with different covariates sets: a comparative simulation study. [europepmc]
• The obesity paradox in critically ill patients: a causal learning approach to a casual finding. [europepmc]
• An Expanded Obstetric Comorbidity Scoring System for Predicting Severe Maternal Morbidity. [europepmc]
• Supervised Machine Learning: A Brief Primer. [europepmc]
• "AI's gonna have an impact on everything in society, so it has to have an impact on public health": a fundamental qualitative descriptive study of the implications of artificial intelligence for public health. [europepmc]
• In-hospital mortality from severe COVID-19 in a tertiary care center in Mexico City; causes of death, risk factors and the impact of hospital saturation. [europepmc]
• Applications of Machine Learning to the Problem of Antimicrobial Resistance: an Emerging Model for Translational Research. [europepmc]
• Machine Learning for Causal Inference: On the Use of Cross-fit Estimators. [europepmc]
• Association Between Glucagon-Like Peptide 1 Receptor Agonist and Sodium-Glucose Cotransporter 2 Inhibitor Use and COVID-19 Outcomes. [europepmc]
• A scoping review on the use of machine learning in research on social determinants of health: Trends and research prospects. [europepmc]
• The role of machine learning in clinical research: transforming the future of evidence generation. [europepmc]
• Introduction to computational causal inference using reproducible Stata, R, and Python code: A tutorial. [europepmc]
• Estimating influences of unemployment and underemployment on mental health during the COVID-19 pandemic: who suffers the most? [europepmc]
• Accounting for motion in resting-state fMRI: What part of the spectrum are we characterizing in autism spectrum disorder? [europepmc]
• Mapping of machine learning approaches for description, prediction, and causal inference in the social and health sciences. [europepmc]
• Artificial Intelligence for Antimicrobial Resistance Prediction: Challenges and Opportunities towards Practical Implementation. [europepmc]
• Preoperative SGLT2 Inhibitor Use and Postoperative Diabetic Ketoacidosis. [europepmc]

Related

• Application of targeted maximum likelihood estimation in public health and epidemiological studies: a systematic review
• Invited Commentary: Demystifying Statistical Inference When Using Machine Learning in Causal Research
• Causal machine learning methods and use of cross-fitting in settings with high-dimensional confounding
• Machine Learning for Causal Inference
• Robust Causal Learning for the Estimation of Average Treatment Effects