Quartet Sampling distinguishes lack of support from conflicting support in the green plant tree of life
2018/02/14 by James B. Pease, Joseph W. Brown, Joseph F. Walker +2 · 393 citations
Agricultural and Biological Sciences · Biochemistry, Genetics and Molecular Biology · #Biology #Clade #Coalescent theory #Ecology #Epistemology #Eudicots #Evolutionary biology #Fern and Epiphyte Biology #Gene #Genetics #Genomics and Phylogenetic Studies #Key (lock) #Phylogenetic tree #Phylogenetics #Phylogenomics #Plant Diversity and Evolution #Premise #Supermatrix #Taxonomy (biology) #Tree (set theory) #Tree of life (biology)
paper · doi:10.1002/ajb2.1016
published in American Journal of Botany 105(3), 385-403 (Wiley)
openalex publication_date 2018/02/14 · openalex created_date 2025/10/10 · openalex updated_date 2026/08/05
Abstract
PREMISE OF THE STUDY: Phylogenetic support has been difficult to evaluate within the green plant tree of life partly due to a lack of specificity between conflicted versus poorly informed branches. As data sets continue to expand in both breadth and depth, new support measures are needed that are more efficient and informative. METHODS: We describe the Quartet Sampling (QS) method, a quartet-based evaluation system that synthesizes several phylogenetic and genomic analytical approaches. QS characterizes discordance in large-sparse and genome-wide data sets, overcoming issues of alignment sparsity and distinguishing strong conflict from weak support. We tested QS with simulations and recent plant phylogenies inferred from variously sized data sets. KEY RESULTS: QS scores demonstrated convergence with increasing replicates and were not strongly affected by branch depth. Patterns of QS support from different phylogenies led to a coherent understanding of ancestral branches defining key disagreements, including the relationships of Ginkgo to cycads, magnoliids to monocots and eudicots, and mosses to liverworts. The relationships of ANA-grade angiosperms (Amborella, Nymphaeales, Austrobaileyales), major monocot groups, bryophytes, and fern families are likely highly discordant in their evolutionary histories, rather than poorly informed. QS can also detect discordance due to introgression in phylogenomic data. CONCLUSIONS: Quartet Sampling is an efficient synthesis of phylogenetic tests that offers more comprehensive and specific information on branch support than conventional measures. The QS method corroborates growing evidence that phylogenomic investigations that incorporate discordance testing are warranted when reconstructing complex evolutionary histories, in particular those surrounding ANA-grade, monocots, and nonvascular plants.
Cited by
- From cacti to carnivores: Improved phylotranscriptomic sampling and hierarchical homology inference provide further insight into the evolution of Caryophyllales
- Ancient alleles drive contemporary climate adaptation in an alpine plant
- AmpliPhy improves gene trees by adding homologous sequences without affecting alignments
- Ancient hybridization and phylogenetic discordance: Exploring evolutionary complexity in Asteraceae
- An integrative framework reveals widespread gene flow during the early radiation of oaks and relatives in Quercoideae (Fagaceae)
- The macroevolutionary singularity of snakes
- Divergence and reticulation in the Mexican white oaks: ecological and phylogenomic evidence on species limits and phylogenetic networks in the Quercus laeta complex (Fagaceae)
- A roadmap of phylogenomic methods for studying polyploid plant genera
- A nuclear phylogenomic tree of grasses (Poaceae) recovers current classification despite gene tree incongruence
- Target enrichment data reveal rapid divergence with reticulate evolution of Maianthemum (Asparagaceae: Convallarioideae) in the Himalayan‐Hengduan Mountains and eastern Asia
- Evidence of introgression amid phylogenetic conflict in Brachyotum , a plant radiation from the Tropical Andes
- Phylogenomics reveals the reticulate evolution and biogeographic history of New World cypresses, Hesperocyparis (Cupressaceae)
- Revisiting the phylogeny of Primulaceae s.l. using whole plastid genomes: Highlighting phylogenetic conflicts and their implications
- The explosive radiation of the Neotropical Tillandsia subgenus Tillandsia (Bromeliaceae) has been accompanied by pervasive hybridization
- New insights into infrageneric relationships of Lonicera (Caprifoliaceae) as revealed by nuclear ribosomal DNA cistron data and plastid phylogenomics
- Refining generic limits in Hyacinthinae (Asparagaceae, Scilloideae): Conflict and concordance between morphology and phylogenomics
- Parallel ddRAD and Genome Skimming Analyses Reveal a Radiative and Reticulate Evolutionary History of the Temperate Bamboos
- Phylotranscriptomic and ecological analyses reveal the evolution and morphological adaptation of Abies
- The link between ancient whole‐genome duplications and cold adaptations in the Caryophyllaceae
- Challenge accepted: Evolutionary lineages versus taxonomic classification of North American shrub willows (Salix)
- Hybrid capture resolves the phylogeny of Tetradium (Rutaceae) and supports the inclusion of a species from Sulawesi
- The origin and morphological character evolution of the paleotropical woody bamboos
- Integrative utilization of genomic resources for improved phylogenetic resolution in Sonerileae (Melastomataceae)
- Building a robust backbone for Astragalus using a clade‐specific target enrichment bait set
- Rampant hybridization underlies cytonuclear discordance and shallow plastid divergence in Juniperus (Cupressaceae)
- Incomplete lineage sorting and local extinction shaped the complex evolutionary history of the Paleogene relict conifer genus, Chamaecyparis (Cupressaceae)
- Integrated morphological and phylogenomic analyses revealed a novel genus Paramicrotoena (Lamiaceae − Pogostemoneae) discovered in the Pan-Himalaya
- Widespread incongruence in the phylogenomics of the ancient land plant lineage, Selaginellaceae (lycophytes)
- New Methods to Calculate Concordance Factors for Phylogenomic Datasets
- Assembling genomes of non‐model plants: A case study with evolutionary insights from Ranunculus (Ranunculaceae)
- Efficient assembly of plant genomes: A case study with evolutionary implications in Ranunculus (Ranunculaceae)
- Navigating phylogenetic conflict and evolutionary inference in plants with target-capture data
- Phylogenomic analyses of the Austral podocarps (Podocarpus: Podocarpaceae) support hybrid ancestry of a New Zealand species
- Phylogenetic analysis suggests early divergence followed by convergent morphological evolution in the Silene sections Odontopetalae and Sordidae (Caryophyllaceae)
- Unraveling evolutionary pathways: allopolyploidization and introgression in polyploid Prunus (Rosaceae)
- Phylogenomic analyses clarify the pattern of evolution of Adephaga (Coleoptera) and highlight phylogenetic artefacts due to model misspecification and excessive data trimming
- A comparison of two universal angiosperm bait sets and the phylogenomics of Alismatales
- A Global Genomic Resource for Outcrossing Arabidopsis lyrata and Arabidopsis arenosa
- Phylogenomic challenges in polyploid-rich lineages: Insights from paralog processing and reticulation methods using the complex genus Packera (Asteraceae: Senecioneae)
- Phylogeny of gracillariid leaf‐mining moths: evolution of larval behaviour inferred from phylogenomic and Sanger data
- Phylotranscriptomic evidence for pervasive ancient hybridization among Old World salamanders
- Non-adaptive Radiation Promotes Phenotypic Diversification and Convergent Evolution of Aposematic Mimicry in a Highly Diverse Genus of Megaloptera
- Museomics help resolving the phylogeny of snowfinches (Aves, Passeridae, Montifringilla and allies)
- Resolving the Avian Tree of Life from Top to Bottom: The Promise and Potential Boundaries of the Phylogenomic Era
- Phylogenomics resolves the deep phylogeny of seed plants and indicates partial convergent or homoplastic evolution between Gnetales and angiosperms
- Phylogenomics resolves the deep phylogeny of seed plants and indicates partial convergent or homoplastic evolution between Gnetales and angiosperms. [europepmc]
- Phylogeny of Hawaiian Melicope (Rutaceae): RAD-seq Resolves Species Relationships and Reveals Ancient Introgression. [europepmc]
- Adaptation to hummingbird pollination is associated with reduced diversification in Penstemon . [europepmc]
- Maximize Resolution or Minimize Error? Using Genotyping-By-Sequencing to Investigate the Recent Diversification of Helianthemum (Cistaceae). [europepmc]
- New Methods to Calculate Concordance Factors for Phylogenomic Datasets. [europepmc]
- Reconstruction of the spatio-temporal diversification and ecological niche evolution of Helianthemum (Cistaceae) in the Canary Islands using genotyping-by-sequencing data. [europepmc]
- An integrative phylogenomic approach to elucidate the evolutionary history and divergence times of Neuropterida (Insecta: Holometabola). [europepmc]
- Phylogenomic Relationships and Evolution of Polyploid Salix Species Revealed by RAD Sequencing Data. [europepmc]
- Four myriapod relatives - but who are sisters? No end to debates on relationships among the four major myriapod subgroups. [europepmc]
- Molecular Evolution and Organization of Ribosomal DNA in the Hawkweed Tribe Hieraciinae (Cichorieae, Asteraceae). [europepmc]
- Analysis of Paralogs in Target Enrichment Data Pinpoints Multiple Ancient Polyploidy Events in Alchemilla s.l. (Rosaceae). [europepmc]
- Allele Sorting as a Novel Approach to Resolving the Origin of Allotetraploids Using Hyb-Seq Data: A Case Study of the Balkan Mountain Endemic Cardamine barbaraeoides . [europepmc]
- Target enrichment improves phylogenetic resolution in the genus Zanthoxylum (Rutaceae) and indicates both incomplete lineage sorting and hybridization events. [europepmc]
- Deep Ancestral Introgression Shapes Evolutionary History of Dragonflies and Damselflies. [europepmc]
- Plastid phylogenomic insights into relationships of all flowering plant families. [europepmc]
- Widespread introgression across a phylogeny of 155 Drosophila genomes. [europepmc]
- Transcriptomics provides a robust framework for the relationships of the major clades of cladobranch sea slugs (Mollusca, Gastropoda, Heterobranchia), but fails to resolve the position of the enigmatic genus Embletonia. [europepmc]
- Novel Approaches for Species Concepts and Delimitation in Polyploids and Hybrids. [europepmc]
- Organelle Phylogenomics and Extensive Conflicting Phylogenetic Signals in the Monocot Order Poales. [europepmc]
- Phylotranscriptomic insights into a Mesoproterozoic-Neoproterozoic origin and early radiation of green seaweeds (Ulvophyceae). [europepmc]
- Phylogenomic analysis of 997 nuclear genes reveals the need for extensive generic re-delimitation in Caesalpinioideae (Leguminosae). [europepmc]
- Incongruence in the phylogenomics era. [europepmc]
- Phylotranscriptomics unveil a Paleoproterozoic-Mesoproterozoic origin and deep relationships of the Viridiplantae. [europepmc]
- Evolutionary dynamics of genome size and content during the adaptive radiation of Heliconiini butterflies. [europepmc]
- Species delimitation of tea plants (Camellia sect. Thea) based on super-barcodes. [europepmc]
Related