2025/01/29 by Brunori, Gianluca, Arcuri, Sabrina, Galli, Francesca
Agricultural and Biological Sciences · #Agricultural Economics and Policy #Agriculture, Land Use, Rural Development #CAP reform #Organic Food and Agriculture #Polarisation #Politicisation #agri-food systems #consensus
paper · doi:10.48416/ijsaf.v31i1.701
openalex publication_date 2025/01/29 · openalex created_date 2025/12/04 · openalex updated_date 2026/07/01
In 2024, a wave of farmers’ protests shook policymaking in the EU. The protests began in reaction to national policy measures and soon coalesced into a unified movement across Europe, directed against the CAP reform (into force since January 2023). The protests took an anti-European tone and were supported by anti-system political forces. In response, European Institutions modified salient environmental aspects of the reform and withdrew, or blocked policy measures proposed within the Farm to Fork strategy. The Head of the EU Commission initiated a “strategic dialogue” with key stakeholders to develop a common vision for the future of the EU agriculture and food sector. This paper examines the relationship between crisis, (de)politicization, and polarization in the CAP reform process, with a focus on how actors mobilize strategies to politicize, depoliticize, or polarize policy debates. Drawing on a conceptual framework that integrates recent literature on (de)politicization and consensus-building, and a thematic analysis of policy discourse from 2021 to 2024, we explore how institutional dynamics and stakeholder interactions shape the prospects for transformative food system change. We argue that consensus or compromise-building is a crucial mechanism for transformational change and the very process of creating it is at the heart of debates on (de)politicization vs (de)polarization. We conclude that deliberative arenas and independent science and media can play a complementary role in this debate, by fostering dialogue, highlighting trade-offs and establishing the basis for finding compromises.