The Ontology of “Political Violence”: Action and Identity in Civil Wars
2003/08/28 by Stathis N. Kalyvas · 20 citations
Social Sciences · #Political Conflict and Governance #Politics and Conflicts in Afghanistan, Pakistan, and Middle East #Southeast Asian Sociopolitical Studies
paper · doi:10.1017/s1537592703000355
Abstract
I discuss several conceptual problems raised by current understandings of political violence, especially as they pertain to actions, motivations, and identities in civil wars. Actions “on the ground” often turn out to be related to local and private conflicts rather than the war's driving (or “master”) cleavage. The disjunction between dynamics at the top and at the bottom undermines prevailing assumptions about civil wars, which are informed by two competing interpretive frames, most recently described as “greed and grievance.” Rather than posit a dichotomy between greed and grievance, I point to the interaction between political and private identities and actions. Civil wars are not binary conflicts, but complex and ambiguous processes that foster the “joint” action of local and supralocal actors, civilians, and armies, whose alliance results in violence that aggregates yet still reflects their diverse goals. It is the convergence of local motives and supralocal imperatives that endows civil wars with their particular and often puzzling character, straddling the divide between the political and the private, the collective and the individual.
Cited by
- A Plague of Initials: Fragmentation, Cohesion, and Infighting in Civil Wars
- Political violence in democracies: An Introduction
- Winning Hearts and Minds for Rebel Rulers: Foreign Aid and Military Contestation in Syria
- Introducing ACLED: An Armed Conflict Location and Event Dataset
- Against Ethnicity: Democracy, Equality, and the Northern Irish Conflict
- Rebels against Rebels
- Language, Religion, and Ethnic Civil War
- Is Ethnicity Identifiable?
- Violent Resistance: Militia Formation and Civil War in Mozambique
- Fixed attitudes, contextual shifts: deconstructing public support for Lebanese Hezbollah through survey experiments
- Political Entrepreneurs or Bandits? The “Criminal” Origins of Peripheral Rebellions
- Keeping communal peace in the shadow of civil war: A natural experiment from Côte d’Ivoire
- Public Preferences, Gender, and Foreign Support for Armed Movements
- The micro-dynamics of peace and conflict
- “So, the Killings Continued”: Wartime Mobilization and Post-War Violence in KwaZulu-Natal, South Africa
- Why do pastoralists in Mali join jihadist groups? A political ecological explanation
- Who, what, and where? Linking violence to civil wars
- Institutions as Perpetrators: Power and Political Violence in Responses to Rape
- Do Commodity Price Shocks Cause Armed Conflict? A Meta-Analysis of Natural Experiments
- Disorganized Political Violence: A Demonstration Case of Temperature and Insurgency
- Fabricating Communists: The Imagined Third That Reinvented the National Fault Line in Mid-Twentieth-Century Colombia’s Civil War
Related