Conceptualizing Criminal Governance
2020/07/20 by Benjamin Lessing · 27 citations
Social Sciences · Medicine · #Crime, Illicit Activities, and Governance #Crime Patterns and Interventions #HIV, Drug Use, Sexual Risk
paper · doi:10.1017/s1537592720001243
Abstract
In informal urban areas throughout the developing world, and even in some US and UK neighborhoods, tens if not hundreds of millions of people live under some form of criminal governance. For them, states’ claims of a monopoly on the use of force ring hollow; for many issues, a local criminal organization is the relevant authority. Yet the state is far from absent: residents may pay taxes, vote, and even inform on gangs as punishment for abusive behavior. Criminal governance flourishes in pockets of low state presence, but ones that states can generally enter at will, if not always without violence. It thus differs from state, corporate, and rebel governance because it is embedded within larger domains of state power. I develop a conceptual framework centered around the who, what, and how of criminal governance, organizing extant research and proposing a novel dimension: charismatic versus rational-bureaucratic forms of criminal authority. I then delineate the logics that may drive criminal organizations to provide governance for non-members, establishing building blocks for future theory-building and -testing. Finally, I explore how criminal governance intersects with the state, refining the concept of crime–state “symbiosis” and distinguishing it from neighboring concepts in organized-crime and drug-violence scholarship.
Cited by
- Commitments of Silence: Reciprocity Networks and Criminal Organizations in Montevideo
- Illegal Market Governance and Organized Crime Groups’ Resilience: A Study of The Sinaloa Cartel
- Governing the Shadows: Territorial Control and State Making in Civil War
- Criminal Communication: Public Representations, Repertoires, and Regimes of Criminal Governance
- The Big Role of Small Groups: A Research Agenda
- The Supply and Demand of Rebel Governance
- Demand and Supply of Criminal Governance: Experimental Evidence from Mexico, Honduras, Guatemala, and El Salvador
- El tren de Aragua: La transnacionalización del crimen organizado a través del tráfico de migrantes
- From Prison Gang to Transnational Criminal Organization. A Social Network Analysis of the Tren de Aragua
- State-Building in the City: An Experiment in Civilian Alternatives to Policing
- Political Entrepreneurs or Bandits? The “Criminal” Origins of Peripheral Rebellions
- Criminal Governance in Latin America: Prevalence and Correlates
- Criminal fragmentation in Mexico
- Peace Dividends: Criminal Governance, Rational Violence, and Economic Development
- National identification weakens, and territorial identification strengthens, the relationship between masculine honor values and the justification of practices of connivance with the mafia
- Organized crime after earthquakes
- The Shifting Landscape of Organised Crime
- The business of protection: Insuring urban violence risks in contemporary Brazil
- Out-Competing Rivals: Armed Group Governance and Civilian Attitudes in Colombia
- Introduction to Special Issue Production, Trade and Governance: A New Definition of Organized Crime
- Cocaine trafficking from non-traditional ports: examining the cases of Argentina, Chile and Uruguay. [europepmc]
- Migrant Entrepreneurs as Agents of Development? Geopolitical Context and Transmobility Strategies of Colombian Migrants Returning from Venezuela. [europepmc]
- Alternative Systems: The Interplay Between Criminal Groups' Influence and Political Trust on Civic Honesty in the Global Context. [europepmc]
- Bifurcations in a Model of Criminal Organizations and a Corrupt Judiciary. [europepmc]
- The psychology of criminal authority: Introducing the Legitimacy of Secret Power Scale. [europepmc]
- The implicit association between masculinity and criminal organizations. [europepmc]
- Navigating Criminal Governance in Colombia: A Life Stories Approach. [europepmc]
Related