‘Fear and loathing across party lines’ (also) in Europe: Affective polarisation in European party systems

2019/07/22 by Andres Reiljan · 75 citations
Social Sciences · #Electoral Systems and Political Participation #Populism, Right-Wing Movements #Social Media and Politics

paper · doi:10.1111/1475-6765.12351

Abstract

Abstract Several scholars in the United States have recently addressed an increased partisan animosity between Democrats and Republicans, and have termed this phenomenon ‘affective polarisation’. This surge in partisan affective polarisation is perceived to be highly problematic, as it has been found to have a negative impact on the functioning of the party system and even society at large. The aim of this article is to study the concept of affective polarisation in European party systems. It introduces the Affective Polarisation Index (API) that allows for measuring and comparing levels of affective polarisation also in multiparty systems. This novel measure is applied to 22 European democracies and the United States between 2005 and 2016. The results indicate that affective polarisation is acutely present in European party systems, as partisans are often extremely hostile towards competing parties. The most affectively polarised countries are in Central Eastern and Southern Europe where the degree of affective polarisation is notably higher than it is in the United States, while Northwestern European countries are more moderate in terms of partisan feelings. Further analysis reveals that affective polarisation is significantly correlated with ideological polarisation, but the relationship between the two appears to be conditional: in some Western European political systems ideological polarisation does not lead itself to strong interparty hostility, while in Central Eastern Europe a high degree of affective polarisation can be present even in ideologically centrist party structures. These findings validate the claim that ideological and affective polarisation are two distinct aspects of polarisation, and that the latter also merits additional attention.

Citations

• Globalization and the transformation of the national political space: Six European countries compared

Cited by

• The (alleged) consequences of affective polarization: A survey experiment in nine democracies
• The social media discourse of engaged partisans is toxic even when politics are irrelevant
• Far-right agenda setting: How the far right influences the political mainstream
• The Way we Were: How Histories of Co-Governance Alleviate Partisan Hostility
• Consequences of affective polarization: Avoidance, intolerance and support for violence in the United Kingdom and Norway
• A new regime divide? Democratic backsliding, attitudes towards democracy and affective polarization
• Communicating a common front: mainstream party rhetoric and affective polarisation towards the radical right
• A Threat to Cohesion: Intragroup Affective Polarization in the Context of Intractable Intergroup Conflict
• Affective Polarization and the Populist Radical Right: Creating the Hating?
• Updating cleavage theory for the twenty-first century
• A New Measure of Affective Polarization
• ‘Seen one, seen ‘em all’: political outgroup homogeneity and negative affect
• Why masses support democratic backsliding
• Cleavage theory meets Bourdieu: studying the role of group identities in cleavage formation
• An unrequited conflict: affective polarisation among ruralites, suburbanites and urbanites in Switzerland
• The limits of Brexit prejudice
• The Polarizing Effect of Partisan Echo Chambers
• Choosing Democracy Over Party? How Civic Education Can Mitigate the Anti-Democratic Effects of Partisan Polarization
• Defending the Status Quo or Seeking Change? Electoral Outcomes, Affective Polarization, and Support for Referendums
• Affective Polarization in Comparative and Longitudinal Perspective
• What Do We Measure When We Measure Affective Polarization across Countries?
• A Longitudinal Study on the Dynamic Relationship Between Affective Polarization and Radical Right’s Emergence: The Case of VOX in Spain
• Cross-Country Trends in Affective Polarization
• Affective Polarization towards Parties and Leaders, and Electoral Participation in 13 Parliamentary Democracies, 1980–2019
• It’s Not Polarization; It’s the Radicalization of the Political Right
• Does affective polarisation increase turnout? Evidence from Germany, The Netherlands and Spain
• Heroes and villains: motivated projection of political identities
• Cleavage politics, polarisation and participation in Western Europe
• The Relational Toll of Political Involvement in Polarized Times: Relationship Decay Within Activists’ Personal Networks
• How we think about the political stances of others: evidence on projection from Canada, Germany, and the UK
• Polarisation, identity and affect - conceptualising affective polarisation in multi-party systems
• The age of virtue signaling: Moral grandstanding as competitive display among young men
• An ERP-study on the extent to which partisanship conditions the early processing of politicians’ faces
• How Do Individual and Societal Factors Shape News Authentication? Comparing Misinformation Resilience Across Hong Kong, the Netherlands, and the United States
• Affective Polarization in Multiparty Systems? Comparing Affective Polarization Towards Voters and Parties in Norway and the United States
• In-Party Love, Out-Party Hate, and Affective Polarization in Twelve Established Democracies
• United in success, fragmented in failure: The moderating effect of perceived government performance on affective polarization between coalition partners
• Unaffected polarization? Populism and affective polarization in comparative perspective
• Party Systems, Democratic Positions, and Regime Changes: Introducing the Party-System Democracy Index
• Affective polarization and coalition signals
• Do Journalists’ Political Orientations Translate into Partisan News Reporting? The Limits of Bias and the Limits of Counter Mechanisms
• When polarization meets backsliding: Affective polarization and support for undemocratic practices in Turkey
• Attitude Formation Based on Political Views: An Expectancy-Value Model of Interpersonal Likability in Politics
• Network polarization: The study of political attitudes and social ties as dynamic multilevel networks
• The young, the radical and the dissatisfied: the transformation of the Portuguese right-wing electorate in the 21 ^st century
• Left–right political orientation fails to explain environmental attitudes of Europeans outside Western Europe: exploring the moderating role of party positions and issue salience
• The nature and origins of political polarization over science
• Affective polarisation and the sorting of policy preferences in multiparty systems
• Determinants of Affective Polarization in Mexico's 2018 Presidential Election
• Empathic Engagement and Polarization in Multi-Party Democracies: The Case of the Populist Radical Right
• How issue opinions relate to individual-level affective polarization: Exploring the psychological mechanisms of affective polarization regarding immigration in a multi-party setting
• Conflict on the campaign trail? How campaign effort and electoral competitiveness shape affective polarization
• Party system polarization and the effective number of parties
• Mainstream partisans’ affective response to (non) cooperation with populist radical right parties
• The Impact of Online Political Conflict Frames on Party Evaluations and Trust in Politicians
• Does polarization increase participation? A systematic literature review and meta-analysis
• The geography of discontent revisited: decoupling attitudinal clustering and affective intensification in urban Britain
• Towards ‘better deregulation’: from crude cost-cutting to the targeted pruning of policy activities
• Parties influence public opinion far beyond their partisans: evidence from two quasi-experiments
• Assessing COVID-19 pandemic policies and behaviours and their economic and educational trade-offs across US states from Jan 1, 2020, to July 31, 2022: an observational analysis
• Political polarization: Radicalism and immune beliefs
• The nature and origins of political polarization over science. [europepmc]
• Algorithmic Political Bias in Artificial Intelligence Systems. [europepmc]
• The Electoral Consequences of Affective Polarization? Negative Voting in the 2020 US Presidential Election. [europepmc]
• I hate you when I am anxious: Anxiety during the COVID-19 epidemic and ideological hostility. [europepmc]
• How warm are political interactions? A new measure of affective fractionalization. [europepmc]
• Putting the affect into affective polarisation. [europepmc]
• The Volebny Kompas Datasets on Slovak Voter and Party Positions. [europepmc]
• Narcissism and Affective Polarization. [europepmc]
• Dysfunctional democracy and political polarisation: the case of Poland. [europepmc]
• Economic Threats, Political and National Identification Predict Affective Polarization: Longitudinal Evidence From Spain. [europepmc]
• Development and Validation of the Affective Polarization Scale. [europepmc]
• Polarisation through deviation discourse: strategic usage of Europeanisation by political and media actors in Georgia. [europepmc]
• Dynamics of sociopolitical polarization and effects of misperception-correcting information around the 2022 Brazilian elections. [europepmc]
• How Crises Shape Circles of Solidarity: Evidence From the COVID-19 Pandemic in Italy [europepmc]

Related

• Affective Polarization in Multiparty Systems? Comparing Affective Polarization Towards Voters and Parties in Norway and the United States
• Beyond the two-party divide : how coalition dynamics and ideological orientations redefine affective polarization in Europe
• What Do We Measure When We Measure Affective Polarization across Countries?
• Fear and Loathing? Affective Polarization Feels Less Negative Than Assumed
• Cleavage politics, polarisation and participation in Western Europe