2025/04/10 by Sejin Ha, Ha, Seungwoong, Henrik Olsson +7 · 1 citation
Social Sciences · Physics and Astronomy · #Wikis in Education and Collaboration #Opinion Dynamics and Social Influence #Knowledge Management and Sharing
paper · pdf · doi:10.48550/arxiv.2504.08152
Collective discourse and action are driven by collective minds. These shared semantic representations and related processes shape societal responses to critical societal challenges such as climate change and political upheavals. In online communities, collective minds are susceptible to the influences of editorial practices and community dynamics, making them vulnerable to manipulation. However, understanding these influences is difficult because of the limits of experimenting with and predicting complex social systems. Here, we develop a computational model of collective minds, calibrated and validated with data from 400 million comments across five U.S. online news platforms and a survey. Our model enables us to quantitatively describe and experiment with different editorial agenda-setting practices and aspects of community dynamics to understand how they shape the collective mind. We find that some editorial influences can be reversed relatively rapidly, but others, such as amplification and reframing of certain topics, as well as community influences such as trolling and counterspeech, tend to persist and durably change the collective mind. These findings illuminate ways collective minds can avoid manipulation and pathways for communities to maintain healthy and authentic collective discourse amid ongoing societal challenges.