The Public as Thermostat: Dynamics of Preferences for Spending
1995/11/01 by Christopher Wlezien · 41 citations
Social Sciences · Economics, Econometrics and Finance · #Electoral Systems and Political Participation #Fiscal Policies and Political Economy #Policy Transfer and Learning
paper · doi:10.2307/2111666
Abstract
Theory: Democratic accountability requires that the public be reasonably well-informed about what policymakers actually do. Such a public would adjust its preferences for or less policy in response to policy outputs themselves. In effect, the public would behave like a thermostat; when the actual policy temperature differs from the preferred policy temperature, the public would send a signal to adjust policy accordingly, and once sufficiently adjusted, the signal would stop. Hypotheses: In domains where policy is clearly defined and salient to the public, changes in the public's preferences for more policy activity are negatively related to changes in policy. Methods: A thermostatic model of American public preferences for spending on defense and a set of five social programs is developed and then tested using time series regression analysis. Results: Changes in public preferences for more spending reflect changes in both the preferred levels of spending and spending decisions themselves. Most importantly, changes in preferences are negatively related to spending decisions, whereby the public adjusts its preferences for more spending downward (upward) when appropriations increase (decrease). Thus, consistent with the Eastonian model, policy outputs do feed back on public inputs, at least in the defense spending domain and across a set of social spending domains.
Citations
Cited by
- It's (Change in) the (Future) Economy, Stupid: Economic Indicators, the Media, and Public Opinion
- All Talk, No Action? Politicians’ Agenda Responsiveness to Citizens’ Engagement on Social Media
- Rising inequality and public support for redistribution
- Agenda responsiveness in the European Council: public priorities, policy problems and political attention
- The Public Salience of Foreign and Security Policy in Britain, Germany and France
- Voters Share Polls That Say What They Want to Hear: Experimental Evidence From Spain and the USA
- Public opinion and the welfare state: sources, processes, and consequences
- Socioeconomic (in)congruence in EU public policy: the role of civil society
- News and Public Opinion: Which Comes First?
- Policy preferences in response to large forced migration inflows
- “How much should public transport services be expanded, and who should pay? Experimental evidence from Switzerland”
- Political Preferences, Policy Loss and Shifting Support for European Integration
- Media Reflect! Policy, the Public, and the News
- Left-Wing Governments and Far-Right Success
- Democracy and Government Performance: Holding Incumbents Accountable in English Local Governments
- Social tipping processes towards climate action: A conceptual framework
- Give the Media What They Need: Negativity as a Media Access Tool for Politicians
- Public opinion foundations of the clean energy transition
- From Catastrophic to Concrete: Reframing AI Risk Communication for Public Mobilization
- The urban–rural divide in policy priorities across time and space
- Race, “Deservingness,” and Social Spending Attitudes: The Role of Policy Delivery Mechanism
- Policy over votes: why extreme governments respond to their supporters
- Examining public support for Ukraine’s defense against autocratic aggression
- Does the left still own social policies? The effect of incumbent partisanship on citizens’ perceptions of public spending in Spain
- Attitudes towards education spending when facing a fiscal trade-off: an analysis of stakeholders
- The Biased Reaction to Changes in Family‐Related Public Expenditure: How Generosity and Universalism Relate to Fertility
- Veil of Valence: Consensus and Disagreement in Public Opinion Towards School Funding, 1998–2016
- Religion and the city: local governments as the flag holders of freedom from religion in Israel
- Addressing the Citizenship and Democratic Deficits: The Potential of Deliberative Democracy for Public Administration
- Mass support for conserving 30% of the Earth by 2030: Experimental evidence from five continents
- The impact of public opinion on voting and policymaking
- Public Opinion and Policy Representation: On Conceptualization, Measurement, and Interpretation
- Bringing Emotions into the Study of Responsiveness: The Case of Protective Policies
- Survey Article: Unfounded Pessimism about Electoral Accountability
- A Thermostatic Model of Congressional Elections
- Climate policy feasibility across Europe relies on the conditional middle
- Ideology for the Future
- Welfare, egalitarianism, and polarization: the politics of noncontributory social programs
- Viewed from Different Engels? Differences in Reactions to “Socialism” as a Policy Label
- Is opinion-policy congruence rewarded at the ballot box?
- Left–right political orientations are not systematically related to conspiracism
Related