The spandrels of San Marco and the Panglossian paradigm: a critique of the adaptationist programme

1979/09/21 by Stephen Jay Gould, S. J. Gould, R. C. Lewontin +1 · 7,802 citations
Arts and Humanities · Neuroscience · Psychology · #Adaptation (eye) #Artificial intelligence #Biology #Computer science #Epiphenomenon #Epistemology #Evolution and Science Education #Evolutionary Psychology and Human Behavior #Evolutionary biology #Exaptation #Genetic architecture #Genetics #Maladaptation #Natural selection #Neuroscience #Philosophy #Philosophy and History of Science #Phyletic gradualism #Selection (genetic algorithm)

paper · doi:10.1098/rspb.1979.0086

published in Proceedings of the Royal Society B Biological Sciences 205(1161), 581-598 (Royal Society)

openalex publication_date 1979/09/21 · openalex created_date 2016/06/24 · openalex updated_date 2026/08/04

Abstract

An adaptationist programme has dominated evolutionary thought in England and the United States during the past 40 years. It is based on faith in the power of natural selection as an optimizing agent. It proceeds by breaking an oragnism into unitary 'traits' and proposing an adaptive story for each considered separately. Trade-offs among competing selective demands exert the only brake upon perfection; non-optimality is thereby rendered as a result of adaptation as well. We criticize this approach and attempt to reassert a competing notion (long popular in continental Europe) that organisms must be analysed as integrated wholes, with Baupläne so constrained by phyletic heritage, pathways of development and general architecture that the constraints themselves become more interesting and more important in delimiting pathways of change than the selective force that may mediate change when it occurs. We fault the adaptationist programme for its failure to distinguish current utility from reasons for origin (male tyrannosaurs may have used their diminutive front legs to titillate female partners, but this will not explain why they got so small); for its unwillingness to consider alternatives to adaptive stories; for its reliance upon plausibility alone as a criterion for accepting speculative tales; and for its failure to consider adequately such competing themes as random fixation of alleles, production of non-adaptive structures by developmental correlation with selected features (allometry, pleiotropy, material compensation, mechanically forced correlation), the separability of adaptation and selection, multiple adaptive peaks, and current utility as an epiphenomenon of non-adaptive structures. We support Darwin's own pluralistic approach to identifying the agents of evolutionary change.

Cited by

• Phylogenetic analyses reveal that horses deviate from a pervasive pattern of skull shape evolution
• The future of evolutionary behavioral biology
• Trophic ecology outweighed intrinsic constraints in shaping skull evolution of carnivorous Permian synapsids
• Development is (embodied) intelligence - Biological information, agency, and contextuality
• Early evolvability in arthropod tagmosis exemplified by a new radiodont from the Burgess Shale
• Let’s go WILD: increasing inclusivity in theories of developmental psychology
• Clonal dynamics and somatic evolution of haematopoiesis in mouse
• Morphological evolution in a time of phenomics
• Entropy Collapse: A Universal Failure Mode of Intelligent Systems
• Is the human chin a spandrel? Insights from an evolutionary analysis of ape craniomandibular form
• The evolution of human infants’ helplessness: unique, relational, and long-lasting developmental implications
• Molecular evolutionary models and mechanistic explanation
• Computational model of flower pattern evolution predicts spontaneous emergence of boundary cell types across the petal epidermis
• Biology Needs Philosophy, But What Philosophy?
• Homo luzonensis and the role of homoplasy in the morphology of hominin insular species
• Can Pareto Optimality Be Evidence of Life?
• Caution in Interpreting Regulatory RNA Associations With Eusocial Evolution in Bees
• Policy Spandrels: How Design Decisions Can Open Up Spaces for Unintended Policy Change
• Body reconstruction and size estimation of plesiosaurs
• Within‐individual leaf trait variation increases with phenotypic integration in a subtropical tree diversity experiment
• The Evolutionary Biology of Ourselves: Unit Requirements and Organizational Change in United States History
• Adaptation in the African egg‐eating snake: a comparative approach to a classic study in evolutionary functional morphology
• Transgenerational plasticity research: Challenges and opportunities
• Hidden paths to endless forms most wonderful: parasite-blind diversification of host quality
• How developmental constraints shape the evolution of repeated structures
• An Illustrated Introduction to the Basic Biological Principles
• Six million years of vole dental evolution shaped by tooth development
• Cognition in eco, cognition in vitro - Mesure, explication, et contextualité en sciences cognitives
• Detecting Hidden Diversification Shifts in Models of Trait-Dependent Speciation and Extinction
• Testing Convergence Versus History: Convergence Dominates Phenotypic Evolution for over 150 Million Years in Frogs
• Language, gesture, skill: the co-evolutionary foundations of language
• Trait variation and integration across scales: is the leaf economic spectrum present at local scales?
• Evolutionary principles underpinning codon usage bias: patterns, functions, and mechanisms
• Evolution of Primate Cognition
• Involutionary Momentum: Affective Ecologies and the Sciences of Plant/Insect Encounters
• Epidemiology, epigenetics and the ‘Gloomy Prospect’: embracing randomness in population health research and practice
• Discussions of the “Not So Fit”: How Ableism Limits Diverse Thought and Investigative Potential in Evolutionary Biology
• Unraveling the Mysteries of Sleep: Exploring Phylogenomic Sleep Signals in the Recently Characterized Archaeal Phylum Lokiarchaeota near Loki’s Castle
• Olfactory bulb tracks breathing rhythms and place in freely behaving mice
• Comparative morpho‐functional analysis of the humerus and ulna in three Western European moles species of the genus Talpa, including the newly described T. aquitania
• The representation of animal communication and language evolution in introductory linguistics textbooks
• Emergence of Scale-Free Syntax Networks
• Richard Lewontin and Theodosius Dobzhansky: Genetics, Race, and the Anxiety of Influence
• What is microbial dormancy?
• Most m6A RNA Modifications in Protein-Coding Regions Are Evolutionarily Unconserved and Likely Nonfunctional
• Does Covariation Between Cranial and Pelvic Shapes Alleviate the Obstetric Dilemma? Insights From a Brazilian Sample
• Evolutionary Patterns of Ammonoids: Phenotypic Trends, Convergence, and Parallel Evolution
• Symbolic Behaviour in Artificial Intelligence
• Optimization and variability can coexist
• Adaptation-exaptation in international politics: UNRWA as the substitutive-compensatory pivot of the Palestinian condition
• Markedness in phonology and in syntax: the problem of grounding
• The critical thermal maximum: history and critique
• Behavioral correlations across breeding contexts provide a mechanism for a cost of aggression
• Evolutionary–developmental (evo-devo) dynamics of hominin brain size
• Molecular Labor Division: Its Cause and Consequence
• Leveling with Tinbergen: Four levels simplified to causes and consequences
• Pollen Wars: Explosive Pollination Removes Pollen Deposited from Previously Visited Flowers
• "Permanence" - An Adaptationist Solution to Fermi's Paradox?
• Rapid Anxiety Reduction (RAR): A unified theory of humor
• The promise of paleobiology as a nomothetic, evolutionary discipline
• The Units of Life
• Evolution of morphological allometry
• Chronic Herbivory: Impacts on Architecture and Sex Expression of Pinyon Pine
• The Cognitive Basis of Science
• The contrasted evolutionary fates of deep‐sea chemosynthetic mussels (Bivalvia, Bathymodiolinae)
• An analysis of epipubic bone function in mammals using scaling theory
• Origin of the Eocene planktonic foraminifer Hantkenina by gradual evolution
• Molecular-scale, nonlinear actomyosin binding dynamics drive population-scale adaptation and evolutionary convergence
• Mechanoethology: The Physical Mechanisms of Behavior
• The generality of Constructive Neutral Evolution
• On the role of phylogeny in determining activity patterns of rodents
• Effects of mass extinction and recovery dynamics on long-term evolutionary trends: a morphological study of Strophomenida (Brachiopoda) across the Late Ordovician mass extinction
• Dinosaurs from the Santonian–Campanian Atlantic coastline substantiate phylogenetic signatures of vicariance in Cretaceous North America
• Oncilla robot: a versatile open-source quadruped research robot with compliant pantograph legs
• The erect ?penis? is a flag of submission in a female-dominated society: greetings in Serengeti spotted hyenas
• Human Evolution and the Chimpanzee Referential Doctrine
• Adaptive Plasticity in Amphibian Metamorphosis
• Developmental structure in brain evolution
• Evolution of eye development in the darkness of caves: adaptation, drift, or both?
• What Is the Function of Confirmation Bias?
• Natural language and natural selection
• Ritual human sacrifice promoted and sustained the evolution of stratified societies
• Is Consciousness a Spandrel?
• Sympatric Speciation in a Bacterial Endosymbiont Results in Two Genomes with the Functionality of One
• The seven sins of memory: Insights from psychology and cognitive neuroscience.
• Towards a balanced social psychology: Causes, consequences, and cures for the problem-seeking approach to social behavior and cognition
• Climbing and the daily energy cost of locomotion in wild chimpanzees: implications for hominoid locomotor evolution
• On Wakefield's harmful dysfunction analysis of mental disorder
• The levels of analysis revisited
• The genetic theory of adaptation: a brief history
• How a neutral evolutionary ratchet can build cellular complexity
• THE MEASUREMENT OF SELECTION ON CORRELATED CHARACTERS
• Gulliver's further travels: the necessity and difficulty of a hierarchical theory of selection
• Individuality and adaptation across levels of selection: How shall we name and generalize the unit of Darwinism?
• Constructive neutral evolution: exploring evolutionary theory’s curious disconnect
• Darwinian alchemy: Human genes from noncoding DNA
• Did Darwin write the Origin backwards?
• Evolution: The Missing Ingredient in Systems Ecology
• Historical Perspectives in Ecology and Evolutionary Biology: The Use of Phylogenetic Comparative Analyses
• Is Evolutionary Psychology Possible?
• The evolutionary origins of modularity
• Human brain evolution and the “Neuroevolutionary Time-depth Principle:” Implications for the Reclassification of fear-circuitry-related traits in DSM-V and for studying resilience to warzone-related posttraumatic stress disorder
• Explanations for adaptations, just‐so stories, and limitations on evidence in evolutionary biology
• SKULL SHAPE EVOLUTION IN DUROPHAGOUS CARNIVORANS
• Systematic evaluation of isoform function in literature reports of alternative splicing
• Anatomy and development of the koala, Phascolarctos cinereus : an evolutionary perspective on the superfamily Vombatoidea
• Adaptive Evolution in Cities: Progress and Misconceptions
• The Neurobiology of Consolidations, Or, How Stable is the Engram?
• TOWARD A SELECTION THEORY OF MOLECULAR EVOLUTION
• Evolutionary remnants as widely accessible evidence for evolution: the structure of the argument for application to evolution education
• On causal roles and selected effects: our genome is mostly junk
• How Did Bacteria Come to Be?
• Optimizing Migration in a Reluctant and Inefficient Flier: The Eared Grebe
• Appendicular osteology of Concavenator corcovatus (Theropoda: Carcharodontosauridae) from the Lower Cretaceous of Spain
• Prey Dynamics and the Breeding Phenology of Common Terns (Sterna hirundo)
• Northern Hawk-Owls in the Nearctic Boreal Forest: Prey Selection and Population Consequences of Multiple Prey Cycles
• Morphological corollaries and ecological implications of flightlessness in the kakapo (Psittaciformes: Strigops habroptilus)
• Why Women Have Orgasms: An Evolutionary Analysis
• The breast/nipple/areola complex and human sexuality
• The interaction between developmental bias and natural selection: from centipede segments to a general hypothesis
• The developmental renaissance in adaptationism
• The fitness challenge of studying molecular adaptation
• Extended Evolutionary Synthesis: A review of the latest scientific research
• The synthesis and the two scenarios
• Non-coding RNA: what is functional and what is junk?
• Dynamics and adaptive benefits of modular protein evolution
• Eliminating Genetic Reductionism from Developmental Science
• What, if Anything, are Species?
• Chemical defense and evolutionary ecology of dorid nudibranchs and some other opisthobranch gastropods
• The emerging conceptual framework of evolutionary developmental biology
• A biomechanical model of feeding kinematics for Dunkleosteus terrelli (Arthrodira, Placodermi)
• Developmental drive: an important determinant of the direction of phenotypic evolution
• Sinuses and flotation: Does the aquatic ape theory hold water?
• The Extended (Evolutionary) Synthesis Debate: Where Science Meets Philosophy
• From the “Modern Synthesis” to cybernetics: Ivan Ivanovich Schmalhausen (1884–1963) and his research program for a synthesis of evolutionary and developmental biology
• Rethinking Hardy–Weinberg and genetic drift in undergraduate biology
• The new biology: beyond the Modern Synthesis
• Unifying biology: The evolutionary synthesis and evolutionary biology
• Explaining wartime rape
• Culture: The Driving Force of Human Cognition
• Development inCladonia Ochrochlora
• From the Selfish Gene to the “We”: Cooperation Often Needs Suppressors
• Developmental mechanisms: putting genes in their place
• Moral Foundations Theory
• Oppositions in panbiogeography: Can the conflicts between selection, constraint, ecology, and history be resolved?
• Exaptation: A Crucial Tool for an Evolutionary Psychology
• Is a New and General Theory of Evolution Emerging?
• Which provenance and where? Seed sourcing strategies for revegetation in a changing environment
• The Facial Integument of Centrosaurine Ceratopsids: Morphological and Histological Correlates of Novel Skin Structures
• Ontogenetic and life history trait changes associated with convergent ecological specializations in extinct ungulate mammals
• Evolution and speciation in the Eocene planktonic foraminifer Turborotalia
• Evolvability is a selectable trait
• Oldest evidence for grooming claws in euprimates
• The limits of Haidt: How his explanation of political animosity fails.
• How much of language, if any, came about in the same sort of way as the brooding chamber in snails?
• The exaptive excellence of spandrels as a term and prototype
• Straw men and fairy tales: Evaluating reactions toa natural history of rape
• The History of Sexuality Meets Evolutionary Psychology
• Language structure in then-object naming game
• Cross-species analysis traces adaptation of Rubisco toward optimality in a low-dimensional landscape
• Reductionism, “Bad Science,” and Politics: A Critique of Anti-Reductionist Reasoning
• The evolution of misbelief
• Computed tomography analysis of the cranium of Champsosaurus lindoei and implications for the choristoderan neomorphic ossification
• Pterosaur dietary hypotheses: a review of ideas and approaches
• Water transport in plants obeys Murray's law
• Adaptationism [wikipedia]
• Darwin's Dangerous Idea [wikipedia]
• Richard Dawkins [wikipedia]
• Spandrel (biology) [wikipedia]
• Teleology in biology [wikipedia]

Related

• Explanations for adaptations, just‐so stories, and limitations on evidence in evolutionary biology
• Controversy in Evolutionary Theory: A multilevel view of the issues
• The synthesis and the two scenarios
• Moving beyond the adaptationist paradigm for human evolution, and why it matters
• Natural selection according to Darwin: cause or effect?